Tuesday, September 21, 2010

BYU's Barry Bickmore Helps Organize Takedown of Monckton

Since launching his blog, BYU's Barry Bickmore has quickly become a prominent defender of climate science. I've noticed increasing references to him on the leading popular blogs and websites dealing with global warming. Now he has kicked it up another notch.

Last May, the House Select Committee on Energy Independence and Global Warming held a hearing on the reliability of climate science in the wake of 'Climategate.' Several scientists were invited to testify. The lone witness invited by the Republicans was Christopher Monckton.

Bickmore, a proud Republican himself, has been quite critical of Monckton on his blog. In fact, according to Bickmore,

A few weeks ago, Monckton e-mailed the president of my university asking him to check on my mental health, because I had been publishing all kinds of lies about him and sending him hate mail! (Nothing came of it, in case you were wondering, and I’m still working at the old day job.)
Now Bickmore and four others have assembled responses to Monckton's testimony by 21 climate scientists, that refute Monckton's claims. The report is titled, Climate Scientists Respond (PDF).

The Guardian has an article: 'Chemical nonsense': Leading scientists refute Lord Monckton's attack on climate science

For more information and links, see Skeptical Science.

Oh, yes. Go Cougars!


Continue reading...

Monday, September 20, 2010

Steve's Primordial Soup: God and the Universe

Last spring BYU biologist Steven Peck (i.e. SteveP of Mormon Organon and BCC) had an article published in Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought titled, "Crawling Out of the Primordial Soup: A Step toward the Emergence of an LDS Theology Compatible with Organic Evolution" (PDF). His is one of the few (maybe only?) serious attempts I know of to explore how LDS theology can embrace evolution. The article focuses on broad concepts rather than particular scriptures or General Authority statements.

When I first began writing this post I started by summarizing the paper. However, I found that I was wasting a lot of pixels simply re-stating what was already written in the article. So instead I am going to split this into several posts and focus on parts of the article of interest to me.

First let's look at five general views Steve describes as to how God may relate to the universe.

Flat Religious Naturalism - There is no supernatural. God = nature.

Evolving Theistic Naturalism - God is an emergent property of nature.

Atemporal Theism - The traditional view the God exists outside of time and transcends the universe.

Temporal Theism - God is God, but he can be influenced by the world. He can see all logically possible futures, but no particular future is predestined.

Eschatological Theism - God intervenes to assure that contingent events occur as needed in order to fulfill his purposes.

Surprisingly (to me), Steve sees Flat Religious Naturalism as potentially compatible with Mormon theology, but not Evolving Theistic Naturalism. With our doctrine of the eternal nature of matter in mind, he writes:

[M]atter could be broadly conceived to include God, spirits, and intelligence as part of the “finer” or “purer” matter thought to make up the extended “universe.” In this context, flat religious naturalism might be conceivable in the LDS faith, as it has few answers to questions about why the universe exists as it does and embraces the idea that its constituent substances are eternal. This matter includes the intelligences that eventually became God by taking on His mantle. Therefore, mystery and awe at this scale may be the only appropriate response.
That seems like a better fit with Evolving Theistic Naturalism to me. Where did gods begin to be? How about somewhere out in the multiverse, eternal elements came together through a process of Darwinian selection in such a manner that gods emerged, propagated and spread into new universes. To my mind, this fits Evolving Theistic Naturalism but is in the same spirit of how Steve sees LDS theology fitting with Flat Religious Naturalism. So what is the real distinction here? Is it just a matter of defining terms, or whether we're talking about our universe or the multiverse, and our God versus some ancestor god? What am I missing?


Further posts in this series:

Steve's Primordial Soup: An Embodied God

Steve's Primordial Soup: Natural Evil
Steve's Primordial Soup: Teleology
Steve's Primordial Soup: Odds and Ends

Continue reading...

Wednesday, September 15, 2010

The Pleasant Side of Digging up the Dead

There is apparently an honest-to-goodness conference being advertised where geocentrism--the idea that the solar system and the rest of the universe revolves around Earth--is going to be exhumed and the attendees will attempt to breathe life into it. (See Galileo Was Wrong: The Church was Right.) The whole thing could be a hoax, but these days you never really know.

When I first read about the conference my first reaction was anger that such a settled theory--Nay, Fact!--would still be seriously questioned by mentally competent adults. But that was before I read some of the nice explanations that blossomed around the blogosphere explaining why geocentrism is wrong. Now I feel fortunate because I learned some things.

Below are three links for your reading pleasure. Each has material not found in the others, so read them all.

1. Geo-xcentricities; you too can be Galileo with just a pair of binoculars (and gaffer tape)

2. Geocentrism: Was Galileo Wrong? - Don't miss the movie of Jupiter!

3. Geocentrism? Seriously?






Continue reading...

Thursday, September 09, 2010

Science Scorned (by the Right)

This week's Nature has an editorial, Science scorned, that expresses some of my own concerns. I've pasted the whole thing below. Both republicans and democrats should find this worrying.

“The four corners of deceit: government, academia, science and media. Those institutions are now corrupt and exist by virtue of deceit. That's how they promulgate themselves; it is how they prosper.” It is tempting to laugh off this and other rhetoric broadcast by Rush Limbaugh, a conservative US radio host, but Limbaugh and similar voices are no laughing matter.

There is a growing anti-science streak on the American right that could have tangible societal and political impacts on many fronts — including regulation of environmental and other issues and stem-cell research. Take the surprise ousting last week of Lisa Murkowski, the incumbent Republican senator for Alaska, by political unknown Joe Miller in the Republican primary for the 2 November midterm congressional elections. Miller, who is backed by the conservative 'Tea Party movement', called his opponent's acknowledgement of the reality of global warming “exhibit 'A' for why she needs to go”.

The right-wing populism that is flourishing in the current climate of economic insecurity echoes many traditional conservative themes, such as opposition to taxes, regulation and immigration. But the Tea Party and its cheerleaders, who include Limbaugh, Fox News television host Glenn Beck and Sarah Palin (who famously decried fruitfly research as a waste of public money), are also tapping an age-old US political impulse — a suspicion of elites and expertise.

Denialism over global warming has become a scientific cause célèbre within the movement. Limbaugh, for instance, who has told his listeners that “science has become a home for displaced socialists and communists”, has called climate-change science “the biggest scam in the history of the world”. The Tea Party's leanings encompass religious opposition to Darwinian evolution and to stem-cell and embryo research — which Beck has equated with eugenics. The movement is also averse to science-based regulation, which it sees as an excuse for intrusive government. Under the administration of George W. Bush, science in policy had already taken knocks from both neglect and ideology. Yet President Barack Obama's promise to “restore science to its rightful place” seems to have linked science to liberal politics, making it even more of a target of the right.

US citizens face economic problems that are all too real, and the country's future crucially depends on education, science and technology as it faces increasing competition from China and other emerging science powers. Last month's recall of hundreds of millions of US eggs because of the risk of salmonella poisoning, and the Deepwater Horizon oil spill, are timely reminders of why the US government needs to serve the people better by developing and enforcing improved science-based regulations. Yet the public often buys into anti-science, anti-regulation agendas that are orchestrated by business interests and their sponsored think tanks and front groups.

In the current poisoned political atmosphere, the defenders of science have few easy remedies. Reassuringly, polls continue to show that the overwhelming majority of the US public sees science as a force for good, and the anti-science rumblings may be ephemeral. As educators, scientists should redouble their efforts to promote rationalism, scholarship and critical thought among the young, and engage with both the media and politicians to help illuminate the pressing science-based issues of our time.
Just in case you wonder whether Limbaugh actually said what was attributed to him, yes he did--and more.


Continue reading...

Updates on Climate Scapegoats

I'm late passing these items on, but here you go.

First, a judge denied VA attorney general Ken Cuccinelli's demand for the University of Virginia's records relating to climatologist Michael Mann. However, I don't get the feeling that this story is over yet.

Second, Rajendra Pachauri is the chairman of the IPCC and has been accused of conflicts of interest and inappropriately profiting from his position. Would you be surprised to learn that an independent audit found no evidence of such things and that the original story alleging such things has been retracted? No, me neither. Apparently, instead of making millions and millions of dollars off of his work, he only brings home about: £47,000 (~$72,400), none of which comes from the UN.


Continue reading...

Friday, September 03, 2010

My Required Reading

I've added a new feature to my right sidebar: Required Reading. Each link is to a collection of resources that I consider essential reading in order to be informed on the topic. I tend to forget that some of my readers are new to the subjects discussed here and may be looking for additional material. Where possible I have included online publications, but I've also included book recommendations. Although there are only a couple of categories listed right now, I plan to add more.

My criteria for adding material is still somewhat fuzzy. I have generally avoided linking to my own material, and I've tried to limit the suggestions to books or published papers. However, there are exceptions. The collection is also admittedly biased. It's not an attempt to be comprehensive; it's what I think you need to read in order to be up to speed, particularly with respect to the intersection of Mormonism and science. (Having said that, I am open to suggestions, but no promises.) As such, it will remain a work-in-progress, so check back from time to time.

Go read and enjoy!


Continue reading...

Monday, August 30, 2010

Hezekiah's Tunnel Refutes Flood Geology

BioLogos has a nice paper by two geologists titled, "Christian Geologists on Noah’s Flood: Biblical and Scientific Shortcomings of Flood Geology (PDF)." Here are two paragraphs from the introduction.

Our primary interest in this paper is...the widely promulgated notion that the Flood can account for the earth’s complex geology. Flood Geology derives from a belief that Genesis teaches that the world is very young – less than 10,000 years. To explain the vast thicknesses and incredible complexity of the earth’s sedimentary deposits within a short history, it is argued that the Flood must have been both global and violent. Flood Geology is thus synonymous with belief in a young earth. It is our conviction that this position is unreasonable from both a biblical and scientific perspective.
Flood Geology proponents would have us believe that there is extensive evidence for a violent, earth-wide flood that is apparent if one is willing to consider the possibility. As Christian geologists, we have no philosophical objection to a cataclysmic event of divine origin, and have long been willing to consider evidence of such an event. What we have observed, however, is that evidence for Flood Geology is largely, if not entirely, non-existent. Given the placement and character of sedimentary deposits currently on earth, deposition by a single flood is not only implausible, but utterly impossible unless God temporarily suspended His natural laws in order to establish layers and fossil beds that would subsequently communicate a story vastly different than what actually happened.
The authors then present several brief vignettes that show how geological features are at odds with Flood Geology. These include:
  • Salt Deposits
  • Grand Canyon: order of deposition
  • Fossil Sequence
  • Tree Rings and Varves
That last one is where Hezekiah's tunnel comes in, along with the Isaiah portion of the Dead Sea Scrolls. You'll have to read the paper to see how they fit in to the issue, but I will just say that that section was my favorite (Mmm, tastes good!) and, although I don't think it should be too difficult to understand, it's well worth taking the time to comprehend. Pay particular attention to Figure 6, which shows several alternative examples of what one would expect to see under different scenarios that represent common creationist arguments.

After reading the paper, come back here to discuss it, if you like.


Continue reading...

Wednesday, August 25, 2010

First Flesh

When a 1929 reading committee consisting of Apostles rejected B.H. Roberts' manuscript, The Truth, the Way, the Life, one of their chief objections was to the idea that the earth had suffered a cataclysm that eliminated all life, and that Adam was the first creation--the 'first flesh' (Moses 3:7)--of the new creation. Like many others, Roberts had noted that the creation account of Genesis 1 and 2 seems to actually contain two different stories with the second having a different order [1], and he thought comments by Joseph Smith to the effect that the earth was formed from broken-up planets provided the way to reconcile the difference. Roberts had previously published a similar interpretation in the late 1800s in the periodical, The Contributor, and in his book, The Gospel and Man's Relationship to Diety. The committee wrote:

We feel that the arguments as given contradict the accounts given in all our scriptures, and more especially in the temple ceremonies. As we understand the term, 'first flesh also,' does not have reference to Adam as being the first living creature on earth, but that he, through the 'fall' became the first 'flesh,' or mortal soul....We are taught in the Temple as well as in the scriptures that man was the last creation placed upon the earth, before death was introduced [2].
In support of this argument, several scriptures were quoted where the word 'flesh' is used as a synonym for mortality.

However, this interpretation appears to be a twentieth century product. I don't know whether or not this interpretation originated with Joseph Fielding Smith--the committee report asserted that the same view was held by then-deceased Presidents Joseph F. Smith and Anthon H. Lund--but he was the first that I know of to articulate it. He was on the reading committee and it seems likely that the committee report reflects his reasoning. His own writings published later contain almost identical arguments. For example, in Man, His Origin and Destiny he wrote:
The expression, "the first flesh upon the earth," is simply a statement of the fact that Adam—the first man on the earth—was, by reason of his transgression the first to partake of mortality. That is to say, the fall brought the mortal as well as the spiritual death. "Mortality" and "flesh" are often used as synonymous terms. The account in Genesis of creation informs us that Adam and Eve were the first to become subject to the mortal, or temporal, death. This fall brought death into the world....The mortal condition was extended so that it eventually embraces every creature on the land, in the air, and in the sea. In this way all creatures became "flesh," but not until after man had so become...

So Adam became the "first flesh on the earth," through the fall, not that he was placed here before any other creature.
Similar passages can be found in Doctrines of Salvation vol. 1, a collection of his sermons and writings, and in both cases a similar list of scriptures is cited. This interpretation of 'first flesh' was further amplified by his son-in-law, Bruce R. McConkie, and it has become the dominant interpretation in the Church.

But the rejected B.H. Roberts was not the only one who saw things differently. Orson Pratt gave two speeches in the 1870s in which he explained that the account of Genesis 1 was of the spiritual creation (something Joseph Fielding Smith and Bruce R. McConkie would later categorically deny), and that the physical creation began with the creation of Adam as the 'first flesh.'
We learn, therefore, when speaking of this spiritual creation, that not only all the children of men, of all generations, and of all ages, were created spiritually in heaven, but that fish and fowls, and beast, and all animated things, having life, were first made spiritual in heaven, on the fifth and sixth days, before bodies of flesh were prepared for them on the earth; and that there was no flesh upon the earth until the morning of the seventh day. On that morning God made the first fleshly tabernacle and took man's spirit and put within it, and man became a living soul—the first flesh upon the earth—the first man also. Though it was the seventh day no flesh but this one tabernacle was yet formed. No fish, fowl and beast was as yet permitted to have a body of flesh. The second chapter of Genesis, (new translation) informs us that the spirits of fowls were created in heaven, the spirits of fish and cattle, and all things that dwell upon the earth, had their pre-existence. They were created in heaven, the spiritual part of them; not their flesh and bones [3].
As late as 1904 the 'Editor's Table' of the Church's Improvement Era printed someone's objection to a youth manual that stated, "Last of all came beasts, insects, and animal life generally, with man to crown the whole work of creation." The correspondent explained, "Now, as I understand the first chapter, it relates the order of the spiritual creation of all things, and the second chapter that of the temporal, or earthly creation," and quoted Moses 3:4-7 as support [4]. The editor responded,
It must be stated that the text of the manual is very short, and teachers are expected to add facts not always found in the text, but to be obtained from other authorized books upon the subject. The correspondent is undoubtedly correct in his statement, and the text of the manual should be interpreted to conform with the views held by the Prophet Joseph, in the Pearl of Great Price.
It seems clear that the novelty of B.H. Roberts' interpretation was the element of cataclysmic destruction, not the order of creation. (Actually, outside of Mormonism, Roberts' idea wasn't novel.)

Joseph Fielding Smith's interpretation hinges on the meaning of 'flesh' in Moses 3:7. As mentioned above, he cited scriptural passages where 'flesh' is synonymous with 'mortality' as justification for his interpretation. Although this interpretive move allows for harmonization of the creation accounts, it does not account for three other uses of the word within the same chapter (verses 5, 21, and 23) where it seems clear that the equation with mortality does not apply.

None of these interpretations fit well with science. Joseph Fielding Smith's interpretation makes Adam the first mortal life on the earth, something contradicted by the vast fossil record. However, Orson Pratt's interpretation isn't any better. In fact, he actually attacked geology on the grounds that if Adam was the first creation, then the the fossil record could not be informative of Earth's history. Roberts' interpretation is speculative and ultimately not helpful. (For a more science-friendly interpretation, see Sterling Talmage's view here.)

An unstated premise of each of these interpretations is that the creation accounts are all intended to be consistent with one another, and that they are an accurate description of history according to our Greek-influenced way of thinking. However, although this premise is often assumed, perhaps the resulting conflict with science is an indication that it should be re-examined.

We often read the scriptures as if their meaning is self-evident. Like fish in water, we are often unaware of our cultural surroundings and their influence on us. Looking at how different leaders have interpreted 'first flesh' serves as a reminder that current, dominant interpretations may not always have been dominant, and may not be final.


Notes:

1. Mainstream biblical scholarship recognizes these two creation stories as having been composed by different people at different times. Aside from the different order, one of the most obvious clues supporting this interpretation is the use of different names for God. In Genesis 1-2:4 God is always 'elohim.' In the rest of the creation narrative God is always 'yahweh elohim' (i.e. Jehovah Elohim, or LORD God in the KJV).

2. B.H. Roberts, The Truth, The Way, The Life, BYU Studies, p. 292-293.

3. Orson Pratt, Journal of Discourses, Vol. 21, p. 200 (1879). See also Vol. 15, p. 253 (1872).

4. Improvement Era, Vol. VII, No. 5, March 1904.


Continue reading...

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP