Thursday, November 17, 2005

The Buttars Collection

It looks like Utah Senator Chris Buttars will be in the news for some time to come. I am therefore collecting all of my posts on him here, listed in reverse chronological order. This page will be available on the sidebar as long as I deem appropriate.

Continue Reading


Buttars' Bill Defeated

Duane Jeffery on SB96

Buttars' Bill Passes House Commmittee 7-6

Sen. Buttars' Bill Looking Less Likely

Sen. Chris Buttars on KUER

Sen. Buttars' Bill Released

Buttars: Back in Black

Utah Board of Education Defies Buttars

Sen. Buttars in USA Today

Sen. Buttars: Doing Utah Proud

Sen. Buttars is Disowned by Discovery Institute

NCSE on Utah and ID

Oh No, Not in Utah

Continue reading...

Buttars: Back in Black

Chris Buttars has a bill on evolution, and he's not letting any of you jerks look at it until he's finished atheist-proofing it.

From the Deseret News:

A Utah senator says he has opened a confidential bill file challenging the State Board of Education's position on teaching evolution in public schools — a measure he'll unveil at the conservative Utah Eagle Forum's annual convention just days before the 2006 Legislature begins.

"I have it 'confidential' " — or shielded from public view — "and it's 'prioritized.' That means it will be heard," Sen. Chris Buttars, R-West Jordan, said Wednesday.

When asked if it would require intelligent design — an idea that life is so complex it can't be explained by Charles Darwin's theory of evolution and natural selection alone — to be taught in Utah public schools, Buttars said: "I'm not answering that yet. I certainly think it should. I believe with the president of the United States that intelligent design should have an equal position (in evolution lessons). But whether I do that in this bill this time, I'm not sure."

...[The] bill language will remain shielded from public view "until I'm satisfied that, one, the intent of the bill is clear, two, how it will be administered is also clear, and three, it can withstand a court challenge."

Here's my favorite part:
Utah Eagle Forum President Gayle Ruzicka praises Buttars' efforts. She asked Buttars to speak on the subject of evolution and intelligent design at the group's Jan. 14 convention. She said Buttars offered to unveil the bill at the same time.
I mean this with all sincerity and seriousness. From what I've seen from Buttars thus far, I am not confident that he could accurately summarize the claims and support for either evolution or intelligent design. But I will give him this bit of credit--it looks like he's talking about including ID in a philosophy or humanities class.

Continue reading...

Where There Is No Vision, the People Perish

PLoS Biology has a--well they call it a "feature." It's not really a primary article, nor is it a review article. I guess it's closest to a popular science article. Anyway, the article is "Jump-Starting a Cellular World: Investigating the Origin of Life, from Soup to Networks".

To some, the idea of an inorganic start to life is just silly--dismissed out of hand. If such a thing happened, we have a long way to go to understand it. Yet what has been done is tantalizing and adds to our understanding of the world, even if it does not explain life. One thing is for sure, we won't find it if we don't look for it. (Some people would prefer that, I'm sure.)

Continue reading...

John Pratt's Satanic Science

Justin Butterfield alerted me to John Pratt's latest article at Meridian Magazine titled, "Has Satan Hijacked Science?" The article describes the scientific method and then turns into an attack on materialism and the consequences that supposedly flow from it, such as: immorality, abortion, looting in the wake of hurricane Katrina, judicial decisions he disagrees with, and so forth. Of course evolution, though he never uses the word, is implied to be the chief bad-boy under the materialism umbrella. None of this is really that suprising. At least one of Pratt's previous articles was influenced by Phillip Johnson, and that seems apparent here as well. Johnson, of course, is the father of the latest intelligent design movement and is on an anti-materialist mission.

Continue Reading


The article makes assertions that have been dealt with elsewhere--I'll provide links. At first I was going to make a few arguments of my own, but I'm discarding them. I will just say that I think that this article will not improve people's understanding of science, rather it will breed mistrust of scientists and the scientific method.

I do want to highlight this passage:

How can Satan get away with avoiding the Scientific Method, while purporting to do science? He does it by focusing on the past and on the future, which are both areas beyond direct observation of the present, the realm of science.

Satan can fabricate all sorts of complete nonsense about the origins of the universe, the solar system, the earth and all of the creatures that live on it. None of these theories can be tested, but that does not stop him from proclaiming them as absolute truth.
There is a certain irony in the assertion that the past is not in the realm of science because much of Dr. Pratt's writing deals with using astronomical calendars to date biblical stories--religious chronology--and he occasionally uses retro-predictions to build support for his case. Is he discarding any notion that his chronologies are scientific? If not, why is his work different from that of the earth and life sciences?

Here are responses to just a few of the issues that Dr. Pratt raises.

First, is my defense of naturalistic assumptions in science.

The rest are from Talk.Origins:

Survival of the fittest implies might makes right.

Crime rates etc. have increased since evolution began to be taught.

Evolution teaches that we are animals and to behave as such.

Evolution has not been proved.

Evolution does not make predictions.

Interpreting evidence is not the same as observation.

Naturalistic science will miss a supernatural explanation.

Continue reading...

Thursday, November 10, 2005

Dusting of the Feet Over Dover

Eight out of nine school board members, of Dover, PA, were voted out and replaced with Democrats this week. Presumably, this is fallout over the intelligent design debacle. (Well, the judge hasn't rendered a decision yet, but many doubt it will go the school board's way.)

The Rev. Pat Robertson is not ammused.

"I’d like to say to the good citizens of Dover. If there is a disaster in your area, don’t turn to God, you just rejected Him from your city. And don’t wonder why He hasn’t helped you when problems begin, if they begin. I’m not saying they will, but if they do, just remember, you just voted God out of your city. And if that’s the case, don’t ask for His help because he might not be there."
(Watch the video clip if you don't believe it.)

I guess if there is a correlation between what it taught in science class and God's help during disasters, Kansas is the place to be. On the other hand, given the prevalence of tornados, that could be considered tempting God.

I wonder what the mormon-man-on-the-street-of-Dover take is on all of this.

Continue reading...

Wednesday, November 09, 2005

Would You Call This A Mandate?

Political victors like to think they have a mandate--even when the victory is by narrow margins. However, I think this might be an actual mandate. (Hat tip to Last Lemming for the link.)

Continue reading...

Tuesday, November 08, 2005

Noah's Flood

Speaking of the Black Sea hypothesis and Noah's Flood, I recommend Duane Jeffery's article on the topic from the October 2004 issue of Sunstone Magazine. It is freely available here and I will add a link to it on my sidebar.

The article is structured in three parts:

Continue Reading


(I) history of interpretation, (II) the Black Sea hypothesis, and (III) the Mormon perspective. While the Black Sea hypothesis is interesting to think about, I think most of the value is in parts I and III. Jeffery raises some interesting questions to consider--especially in the Mormon context. I also recommend the endnotes, which contain much additional information and discussion.

Note #28 brings up a question of particular interest to me: "Did Noah and his family carry all the known human disease pathogens, one wonders?" This question is only the tip of the iceburg of microbiological questions a global flood raises.

Consider:

1. Many disease-causing organisms have a limited host range. Smallpox, measles, and poliovirus are all exclusively human pathogens. Furthermore, immunity to these diseases is long-lasting. How could the few number of people on the ark (and after) maintain these organsisms? The same question applies to many animals with their specific pathogens.

2. It is not uncommon for a cross-species transmission of a disease to be highly lethal for the new host. (In a human context, SARS and Ebola come to mind, or the mass seal die-off that occured when a dog virus entered a seal population.) With all of those animals concentrated together, what stopped epidemics and mass casualties from taking place? Did rabies make it through?

3. Many microbes and parasites have complex life-cyles, infecting and continuing development in several different hosts. Were these life-cycles maintained?

I suppose it could be argued that these diseases came into existence after the flood, or that they were miraculously dormant during the flood--but that raises more questions.

Anyway, you can read a creationist defense of a global flood here. Also see FAIR's resources, including an Ensign article defending a global flood and Nibley's "Before Adam."

Continue reading...

Geomythology

In the latest Science there is a news article highlighting geomythology, a relatively new use of geology.

Continue Reading


Some geologists have taken an interest in the connection between folklore and science. The idea is that stories that have been passed down for generations within ethnic/cultural groups may be based on natural disasters such as earthquakes, volcanoes, tsunamis, etc. This approach has produced some fruitful results. For example, Native American folklore in the Seattle area places the location of ground-shaking spirits in a way that correlates well with faults running through the area.

The movement traces in part to the 1980s, when scientists realized that the slow march of geologic time is sometimes punctuated by biblical-scale catastrophes, such as the giant meteorite that wiped out dinosaurs 65 million years ago. After this was accepted, some (usually those with tenure) felt freer to wonder if near-universal myths of great floods and fires implied that such disasters also have punctuated human time. In the 1990s, Columbia University marine geologists Walter Pitman and William Ryan argued that rising Mediterranean sea levels following the last deglaciation topped what is now the Bosporus Strait and roared into the Black Sea 7600 years ago, serving as the original inspiration for the biblical flood. Their work triggered sharp criticism and a torrent of research, resulting in growing acceptance of some sort of Black Sea flooding. Whether the book of Genesis somehow grew from this is a further step, admits Ryan, who presented his latest findings at the International Geoscience Program in Istanbul, Turkey, in early October.


Of course, caution is warranted.
The pendulum may have swung too far in favor of accepting myths, says social anthropologist Benny Peiser of Liverpool John Moores University in the U.K., who runs the Cambridge Conference Network, an Internet clearinghouse for catastrophist theories. Now that more people are willing to listen, he says, too many scientists are invoking myth "left, right, and center to explain everything." In a paper at a late-October workshop on natural catastrophes in the ancient Mediterranean, he asserts that no major myths have yet met scientific standards, although he does credit some regional ones, such as the Pacific Northwest earthquakes. "That's not all bad," he says. "This is all so new, you expect more speculation than hard evidence. The refinements can come later."

You might call this an example of Mormon geomythology. If you know of others, please do tell. (Note: I am not implying that the Book of Mormon is not historical.)

Continue reading...

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP