We're Better Off With Blinders On
Some people, such as those at the Discovery Institute, believe that methodological naturalism limits the discovery power of science. After all, if we rule out supernatural explanations from the beginning, how will we ever find them? They argue that we need to take our blinders off.
Alright, let's take our blinders off for a moment and investigate the supernatural with a thought experiment. Now we believe that we are the true church right? If miracles (no philosophical arguments about whether miracles are "supernatural" are needed for this discussion) actually occur, of all people, we should be able to produce them. What kind of miracles should we look for? How about those associated with priesthood blessings, specifically the healing of the sick?
Continue Reading
Does this strike you, in your gut, as a bad idea? If so, it is probably because you have hit our first overriding assumption. And that is that God is willing to "play our game". When exercising the priesthood we are actually using His power, so in order for this study to be successful, we need His cooperation. Can we safely assume that He doesn't view this whole operation as sign seeking, the equivalent of giving in to the temptations of Jesus, and an abomination? Well for purposes of discussion, let's pretend that Pres. Hinckley has given us approval.
Now we get into the logistical problems. How are we going to set this thing up? We have several variables at play: the faith and righteousness of those administering the blessing, the faith and righteousness of the recipients, and the will of the Lord. We have no reliable way to determine any of these. Should the blessings be combined with medical treatment? How will we measure outcomes? Should we compare the outcome with the wording of the blessing? How long should we follow the status of the recipient of the blessing? How will we control for the placebo effect?
You can see we have a lot of problems with designing the study. But for the sake of argument, let's say that we figure something out and we see that people who have blessings do much better than people who don't. The next question to look at is what exactly happens. Can we only detect priesthood power by its effects, or can we measure something like electromagnetic waves? How are the cells of the body affected? What kind of changes in gene expression and physiology occur? We're entering into molecular biology here, which we can't really study in humans in any practical/ethical kind of way. We're going to have to move to either animal models, or perhaps tissue culture. Will moving the study away from humans ruin the whole thing? Do blessings only work on people? Maybe we could step back a bit and just "command the elements." What kind of "commands" will we give to animals or cell culture?
By now you are probably tired of this whole exercise--I think my point is made. There are a great number of places our experiments might fail--would we then conclude that blessings have no miraculous effect? For the believer, a more prudent conclusion would probably be that the tools of science are of limited use in this area. Spiritual phenomena are quite personal and generally not open to external study and verification. In fact this seems to be what the scriptures have taught all along. We've now wasted a lot of time and money.
So perhaps we are better off with our blinders on after all.


5 comments:
A common phrase of the graduate student goes something like this, "It is better to spend two hours in the library than two months in the laboratory." This refrain is frequently repeated as we frequently violate it.
I would commend you to the well written article on this topic in Acad Med. 2001 Aug;76(8):791-7 by Halperin EC. This is an excellent review of prior studies addressing the power of prayer and the pitfalls in trying to measure divine efficacy.
Of particular note is the first study in the 19th century by Galton who found that prayer did not seem to help.
"Galton considered that, of all classes of English society, he groups most prayed for were the Royal Family and the clergy’s children. If prayer is effective, he reasoned, these people should live longer than other persons exposed to similar health risks. Galton, therefore, compared the average lifespans of kings with those of lords and the lifespans of children of clergy with those of children of other professional men. He found, contrary to the hypothesis, that much prayed-for persons had slightly shorter lives than did those with whom he compared them. Galton also assessed the frequency with which ships carrying missionaries experienced disaster at sea compared with the frequency of this event with other ships. He found that missionaries sank slightly more often and with greater loss of life." (p 792).
Einstein suggests there are two forms of knowledge, those gained using measurement, and those that cannot be measured. He places greater value on the former, but does not deny the existence of the later. Faith, by definition, falls into the latter.
A few more brief thoughts:
A Pubmed search with “intercessory prayer” yields 52 papers suggesting a rising genre in medical literature. The literature studying intercessory prayer is now sufficiently broad to contain a satire on the subject (Leibovici, L Effects of remote, retroactive intercessory prayer on outcomes in patients with bloodstream infection: randomised controlled trial BMJ. 2001 December 22; 323(7327): 1450–1451). The satire is silly, but noteworthy because it appears in the Christmas issue of the , which, for those of you who have not been introduced to it, contains the most outlandish, humorous and satirical scientific writing since the Journal of Irreproducible Results was disbanded. Among the best writing includes a satire of Evidence Based Medicine (and yes EBM is sufficiently worshipful to necessitate capitalization) titled “Parachute use to prevent death and major trauma related to gravitational challenge: systematic review of randomised controlled trials” BMJ 2003;327:1459-1461 and the brilliant randomized controlled trial interrogating risk factors developing an ice-cream headache “Ice cream evoked headaches (ICE-H) study: randomised trial of accelerated versus cautious ice cream eating regimen” BMJ 2002;325:1445-1446.
Back to prayer. As the initial post above and Halperin point out, outcome based studies on the effect of intercessory prayer are fraught with difficulty and confounding variables: the worthiness of the person praying, the worthiness of the infirmed, the religion of the prayer, the “goodness” of an improved outcome in God’s eyes, etc, etc. However, there are other studies suggesting that people who pray may have improved coping skills and may have more positive responses to illness in themselves or family members. (Williams JR Jr South Med J. 2005 Jan;98(1):90-5, Dapueto JJ, Servente L, Francolino C, Hahn EA Cancer. 2005 Mar 1;103(5):1072-81, Weaver AJ, Flannelly KJ South Med J. 2004 Dec;97(12):1210-4 etc.)
On a more anecdotal level, I have been very surprised at my patients’ overwhelming response when I, as their doctor, suggest they have faith in God’s healing power and that I too am praying for them. I’m in the mid-west now, which is a pretty religious place in general. In California, I rarely brought up faith. But here, it is a regular part of my patients’ conversation, so I’m much more comfortable continuing the dialog once they engage religious rhetoric. Each time this topic has come up, my patient has been genuinely grateful to have a believing physician. They all have expressed a belief that medicine and religion should blend together, but that no other physician has suggested that he or she believes or that God might play a role in the healing process. Has it changed my patient’s outcome? I don’t know. Maybe not. But it has always helped transform my doctor-patient relationship from pill pusher toward healer, and that was why I got into this business in the first place.
John,
Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I'm certainly not against people combining religion with medical treatment. I'm sure it is helpful in one (or more) of several ways.
Mostly I was trying to show that complaints that science seeks natural explanations are hot air. This particular aspect of our faith is the most likely to generate outward, physical results. Yet to convincingly show it (in a non-anecdotal way) would be a huge problem.
Thanks for the Halperin article. It seems to me that studying priesthood blessings would avoid some of the pitfalls he describes, but there are still significant ones.
You might be interested in this news story on a recent prayer study.
http://www.cnn.com/2006/HEALTH/03/30/prayer.study.ap/index.html
Coincidentally, I just put up a post.(Here)
Thanks for the tip. And I'm impressed that you remembered this particular thread.
Post a Comment