How Did That Get Into the Ensign?
I was doing some searching on LDS.org and quite accidentally came across an article in the Ensign written in 1975 by the recently passed Davis Bitton. The title is "Mormon Media", wherein Bitton provided a listing of (then) recent works on Mormon history. I was surprised to see this sentence:Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought recently included Davis Bitton and Gary L. Bunker, “Phrenology Among the Mormons” (Spring 1974) and Duane E. Jeffery, “Seers, Savants and Evolution: The Uncomfortable Interface” (Autumn 1974).
Two surprises there. First, as a matter of policy, Ensign does not reference articles in Dialogue. Evidently this policy went into place around 1980, because a search turned up only four articles with such references, and all pre-date 1980. And second, Hello!..."Seers, Savants and Evolution"?? Interestingly, only three months later (then) Elder Ezra Taft Benson denounced Jeffery's article in a speech at BYU. It is tempting to speculate that Bitton's Ensign article is what ultimately drew Benson's attention to Jeffery's article. The fact that Benson's speech was about trends in the historical treatment of the nation, founding fathers, and the Church only adds fuel to my speculation. (For more on this episode, see here.)
My search for other articles referencing Dialogue also led me to "Line upon Line", by James Allen. It covers doctrinal development of the Godhead and Zion, as well as the ending of rebaptism and the law of adoption. Ensign ought to re-print it.
As I typed in the title of this post, it occurred to me that it might make for a fun occasional series of posts--ie. interesting stuff dug out of Church magazine archives. Many would not be related to science, but that's okay. Anybody interested?
P.S. I previously posted on phrenology here.

7 comments:
I mentioned this to you two years ago at Mormons and Evolution:
-------------- quote --------------
For the past thirty years, Duane Jeffery has been a de facto spokesman for Mormon evolutionists. His well respected and often referred to article, Seers, Savants, and Evolution: The Uncomfortable Interface (hereinafter SSE) was published in Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought 8 [Autumn-Winter 1973], 41-75.
"SSE was announced to the whole Church in the Ensign (Dec. 1975, 71) and to the academics in the Church in BYU Studies (Vol. 15, No. 4, Summer 1975, 532). It's respectability is enhanced by the fact that it appears in many Bibliographies, including four Encyclopedia of Mormonism articles."
-------------- end quote --------------
The Line Upon Line article is a great one. I try to share it with as many people as possible, since it teaches the principle so well AND introduces people to some real LDS history.
Thanks for the link to the Line Upon Line article. It's a masterpiece. It explains why most members have no problems when historical teachings differ from current teachings. The LDS Church is founded on the principle of continuing revelation.
Throughout my life I have seen people struggle with new direction from church leaders, especially when it challenges practices that have become deeply ingrained in the culture.
A few days after the 1978 revelation on extending the priesthood was announced I ended up spending a whole day with a group of retired people (all members of the church). Some of them had serious problems with the revelation.
I have a number of acquaintences that currently have a lot of heartburn over President Hinckley's directive to discontinue traditional missionary farewell and homecoming meetings.
It is good to remind ourselves of the doctine of continuing revelation.
Gary,
Apparently my memory is not as good as yours. Do you keep a database of all of your comments or is it just raw brain power?
Thanks for the reminder.
The link to "Mormon Media" is faulty.
Jared,
I have a copy of most posts on which I've commented. Two years ago, you also wondered whether my then new blog represented "a long-term committment to blogging." Has that question been answered? Regarding "interesting stuff dug out of Church magazine archives," I'd say go for it!
Thanks, Justin. The link is fixed.
Post a Comment