Thursday, May 31, 2007

Mormon and Evangelical Youth: Similar, But Different

A new book looks at religion, teenagers, and sex morality chastity. As reviewed in Slate:

Evangelical teens are actually more likely to have lost their virginity than either mainline Protestants or Catholics. They tend to lose their virginity at a slightly younger age—16.3, compared with 16.7 for the other two faiths. And they are much more likely to have had three or more sexual partners by age 17...
Sheesh.

Definitely out of the question is an Asian-American who attends church weekly—84 percent of them are virgins. A Mormon is a long shot. They are unlikely to have sex and if they do, they don't tend to repeat the experience.
Can't think of a suitable witty reply, so moving on...

After controlling for all factors (family satisfaction, popularity, income), religion matters much less than religiosity. ...The ideal conditions are a group of pledgers who form a self-conscious minority that perceives itself as special, even embattled.
We've had that down since---1830?

When evangelical parents say they talk to their kids about sex, they mean the morals, not the mechanics. In a quiz on pregnancy and health risks associated with sex, evangelicals scored very low.
And that ignorance--apparently--has consequences.


The book is Forbidden Fruit: Sex & Religion in the Lives of American Teenagers by Mark Regnerus.

(via Red State Rabble)


6 comments:

Clark Goble,  6/01/2007 12:57:00 PM  

The interesting difference among Mormons is that women, not men, tend to be more sexually active. This is the inverse of everyone else. (Unless the stats have changed the last 10 years significantly)

Feminists have had a field day with that statistic arguing that its due to our "patriarchal organization" that conditions women to do what men say. I don't buy that, but it is an interesting statistic.

Anonymous,  6/01/2007 02:08:00 PM  

Actually, as a woman, that does make sense.

Focuses for young men are to go on a mission and get an education so they can provide for the dependents. They have sexual urges that must be supressed, so they are given lots of tools to do that with.

Young women can go on a mission if they don't find a husband. They need an education 'just in case'. Their primary focus is that they will be having babies and raising them. That equals sex. While they might have sexual urges to control, their focus is in not getting the poor boys riled up.

What happens if a young man dates a young woman with looser morals? He probably doesn't know it at first, but when he does he'll be more able to remove himself from the temptation.

What happens if a young woman dates a young man with looser morals? Like the young man, she may be naive at first but once she finds herself in the situation, she is not as skilled at surpressing sexual urges. Since her narrative structure revolves around sexuality anyway (having children) and being a helpmeet, it is harder for her to resist urges that include nurturing.

Anonymous,  6/01/2007 02:36:00 PM  

Ami, without any data, I am going to say that your explanation is simply one unlikely hypothesis.

Perhaps we roll in different circles, but the Church teaches that women should get as much education as they can. period. With 55% of the folk leaving BYU unmarried, it is good counsel (for both sexes). I think there are a number of factors that could account for the disparity, but without real data, it is simply speculation.

Matt,  6/01/2007 05:08:00 PM  

"The ideal conditions are a group of pledgers who form a self-conscious minority that perceives itself as special, even embattled."

Does this imply that it is at times easier to be a Latter-day Saint outside of Utah where Mormons really are a minority? In Utah, the pledgers are not in the minority. Maybe I'm just naieve.

Anonymous,  6/01/2007 10:55:00 PM  

Stapely,

The church does teach that women need an education, and it is emphasizing that more and more. But then we also need to stay home with our kids. Our job will be in the home, taking care of the children. Therefore, many feel like the education is a 'just in case' proposition. This isn't taught in church. It is just the way girls may react to what is taught. The ones most likely to react that way are probably those at the highest risk of a lapse anyway.

We LDS women are in an odd position. Even though we can do anything we want, we have been taught by the prophets that we should stay home withour children. And I totally agree with that. But then that limits what careers are available to us. We simply don't have time to be doctors or lawyers, scientists, etc. It can be frustrating.

Jared*,  6/01/2007 11:15:00 PM  

Ami and Watercat are both new names to me. I think--or maybe it has jut been a while. Anyway, Welcome both.

I grew up outside of Utah. I really don't know, though. I think it really depends on the situation, such as quality of parenting and peers. There are screw-up both in and out of Utah, but I would probably agree that I was more self-conscious about the image I projected than I otherwise would have been.

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP