Book Finished: Man, His Origin and Destiny

I finished reading Joseph Fielding Smith's Man, His Origin and Destiny. I thought it would provide some good blogging material, but now I find that I don't really have the steam for it. I think there are several reasons for this:
1. It is a long book; it has many extended quotations and the arguments tend to wander. You would be better off reading the "Evolution" entry in Mormon Doctrine for the main points, and I and others have had a go at that already.
2. It was published in 1954; a lot has been discovered since then. It would be quite time consuming to address the scientific issues raised, and for what? To say that we now know many things that he didn't?
3. Although the book is available on Gospelink, it has been out of print for decades. I think most people don't even know the book exists; surely even fewer have read it. So why spend time on it?
4. To be fair, I think he makes some good points from time to time. Unless I want to look like I just enjoy beating up on dead prophets, I would need to dig out some of those points. But see #1. Another problem is that good and bad can be so intertwined that it is hard to cut out the bad without at least appearing to reject the good as well.
Let me add that one valuable thing about this book--for the time it was printed--is that it has a nice collection of material in one book. Included are (i) the 1909 First Presidency statment on the origin of man [1], (ii) 'The Father and the Son: A Doctrinal Exposition by the First Presidency and the Twelve', (iii) a First Presidency letter to Samuel Bennion regarding Adam-God teachings, and (iv) accounts of Heber C. Kimball and company's demonic confrontation.
So overall, I think it best to defer to Henry Eyring's diplomatic review. This is not to say that I won't draw on the book for blogging at all, but it will probably be limited.
1. As pointed about by Duane Jeffery (see note 41 here), the 1909 statment incorrectly reads, "primal parent of the race" rather than the correct reading, "primal parent of our race."

3 comments:
Perhaps surprisingly, I mostly agree with you regarding President Smith's book.
1. I agree that 579 pages is a long book. I also agree that the long quotations from LDS sources are more helpful to us today than the extended quotations from the science of his day. Chapter 19, "Testimony of Early Brethren," for example, provides valuable insight into the 10th Article of Faith. I agree that Bruce R. McConkie provided a concise summary of President Smith's arguments in Mormon Doctrine.
2. You correctly point out that the science of today is different than the science of 1954. But in saying this, you are admitting that science has advanced—or changed—a lot in the past 53 years. I believe that equally significant advances—changes—will occur in science during the next 53 years. I believe knowledge that doesn't change comes from Him who is "the same, yesterday, today, and forever." [1] It is found in "the scriptures and the words of modern prophets." [2] "And if it were in perfect agreement with the science of today, it would surely be out of line with the science of tomorrow." [3]
3. I agree that most people don't have a copy of President Smith's book and haven't read it. Yet Church leaders and gospel scholars are still quoting from it in General Conference and other Ensign articles and Church curriculum materials. Man, His Origin and Destiny is also listed among the additional resources recommended on the Church's official web page about President Joseph Fielding Smith.
4. Agreed. Of course, you already know how I feel about beating up on prophets, living or dead. And, as pointed out in the preceeding paragraph, others are using some of those good points in Church published material.
Let me add that the book never claimed to be an official publication of the Church. Responding to a certain private letter which states that the book "was not published by the Church, and is not approved by the Church," Boyd K. Packer has emphasized that "letters [from Church leaders] to individuals are not the channel for announcing the policy of the Church." [4] Even so, I don't think you can get a clear sense of the controversy surrounding President Smith's book without carefully reading Harold B. Lee's letter, written in October 1973 just weeks before he died. [5]
Notes
[1] 2 Ne. 2:4; 27:23; 29:9; Alma 31:17; Morm. 9:9; Moro. 10:19; D&C 20:12; 35:1.
[2] Spencer W. Kimball, Ensign, May 1993, p. 14.
[3] Of All Things!: Classic Quotations from Hugh Nibley, comp. Gary P. Gillum, 1993, p. 245.
[4] Boyd K. Packer, "The Law and the Light," The Book of Mormon: Jacob through Words of Mormon, to Learn with Joy, Provo, Utah: Religious Studies Center, BYU, 1990. p. 23; emphasis in original.
[5] See The Origin of Man & Organic Evolution, as downloaded 9/4/2004 from BYU-Idaho.
Gary,
I would be very careful about offering the arguments you present in 2. Whenever I presented them in the past (as I did a couple of times) I always felt like I was pulling a fast one in some way. Here is how I was:
A) The specific conclusions of science have changed. Not much, but they have. However, the affirmative conclusions of science are insignificant. What matters is their position regarding the claims embodied in NDBF. Science has NOT changed their conclusions in this regard at all. In fact, their conclusion has only become more and more supported as evidence comes in and they refine their positive affirmations. This might offer hope you where this refining process approaching NDBF in any way, but its not.
B) What matters in not whether God's opinions change, but whether our interpretations of God's opinions change. They do. In this, prophets are no different than are scientists in their interpretation of nature, for nature does not change. It cannot be truthfully said that dinosaurs lived on the earth one day and on the next day truthfully said that they did not exist. Facts do not change over time, and all we can do it interpret facts, whether the facts be nature or God's opinion of nature.
C) Nevertheless, as I'm sure you would agree, the idea that whatever science says it true must be is completely bogus. However, the idea that what science says is false must be, while not being entirely true, is certainly a safer position than you give it credit for.
Thanks for the link on agreeing to disagree. It offered some very good insights.
Post a Comment