Monday, April 25, 2011

Smoking Guns

I finally finished reading Nonsense on Stilts: How to Tell Science from Bunk by Massimo Pigliucci. Pigliucci is an evolutionary biologist turned philosopher of science who is one of the main participants in the fine podcast Rationally Speaking. It turns out that science and bunk cannot be distinguished by hard and fast rules, but there are some guidelines. Along the way he examines examples of controversial science, clear pseudoscience, and other auxiliary phenomena such as the rise of think tanks and postmodern critiques of science.

The second chapter deals with the notion that there are so-called 'hard' sciences (e.g. physics) and 'soft' sciences (e.g. sociology). Physics, with its exactness and predictive power, is often held up as the ideal to which all other sciences should aspire. However, Pigliucci argues that the sciences are heterogeneous because they deal with different problems of different complexity, and that their methods reflect those differences. In this view, physics is not somehow better than, say, biology, it's just different.

Early in the chapter he discusses the concept of strong inference. This is where a crucial experiment can be used to rule out one or more mutually exclusive hypotheses. Essentially you set up a situation where either X or Y is true, and then perform an experiment to unambiguously rule one of them out. This kind of approach can work well in physics. However, although it is a very logical way to proceed, not all scientific questions are amenable to this method because of the complexity of the subject matter and because not all answers are black and white. (For example, you might find that many people with a disease show improvement with a particular drug. It's not a cure vs. no cure, nobody vs. everybody dichotomy.)

He then goes on to discuss historical sciences (e.g. geology, paleontology) which are sometimes maligned as having untestable theories. In this view, experimental findings are privileged above all else, and since you cannot perform experiments with past occurrences, those occurrences must remain unverifiable. (This is a common argument made by creationists seeking to cast doubt on evolution or anything else that contradicts their interpretation of the Bible). However, as Pigliucci points out, science is about more than doing experiments (e.g. astronomy), and drawing on work by Carol E. Cleland he argues that historical hypotheses can indeed be verified with a high degree of certainty. It's worth spending a moment on this.

A difference between historical and experimental sciences is captured in the philosophical (and certainly philosophical-sounding) term, asymmetry of overdetermination. This term simply refers to the difference in our ability to know cause and effect when looking into the future vs. the past. Cleland uses the example of a house fire: someone investigating a house fire may be able to determine that it was caused by a short circuit. This is because of all of the clues left behind after the event. However, that knowledge does not translate into the ability to predict whether a particular future short circuit will result in a fire. Similarly, police investigating a crime often have many clues with which to reconstruct what happened, but they cannot predict how and when a future crime might occur. On the other hand (my own interpretation), an instructor at a fire fighting school might be able to arrange things such that a short circuit reliably causes a fire, but this is because the instructor has eliminated variables that might prevent the fire from starting and constrained conditions to give a reliable result.

Historical sciences rely on the fact that historical occurrences leave behind many clues, only a few of which may be needed in order to establish the reality of the occurrence. Scientists in this mode of investigation look for 'smoking guns' from which they can infer what happened. Experimentalists, on the other hand, seek to limit variables that might interfere with the experiment in question--trying to eliminate false negatives and false positives. These constrained conditions allow them to make more precise predictions and measurements, but that precision can quickly disappear in a more complex context. It's also worth pointing out that these two approaches can be employed together such that they inform one another.

Cleland summarizes:

When it comes to testing hypotheses, historical science is not inferior to classical experimental science. Traditional accounts of the scientific method cannot be used to support the superiority of experimental work. Furthermore, the differences in methodology that actually do exist between historical and experimental science are keyed to an objective and pervasive feature of nature, the asymmetry of overdetermination. Insofar as each practice selectively exploits the differing information that nature puts at its disposal, there are no grounds for claiming that the hypotheses of one are more securely established by evidence than are those of the other.





Further reading:

Cleland, Carol E. (2001). "Historical science, experimental science, and the scientific method," Geology 29, pp. 987-990.


Continue reading...

Monday, April 18, 2011

Well, I'll Be Darned

The first I ever heard of Richard Sherlock, a professor of philosophy at Utah State University, was when I purchased the book, The Search for Harmony: Essays on Science and Mormonism. His historical chapters treating the spectrum of reactions to evolution and the B.H. Roberts/Joseph Fielding Smith/James E. Talmage argument were among the best of the book. Later I was a little disappointed when he defended intelligent design in the FARMS Review, which I took issue with on this blog. I was also a little disappointed when, in his founding essay for Square Two, he came out strongly against embryonic stem cell research. "Well," I thought, "I guess we disagree on some things, but those evolution essays were great." Meanwhile I saw his name pop up here and there, such as at FAIR, etc.

Now I see that Sherlock has converted to Catholicism. Another curve ball in life, I guess. I hope he finds fulfillment in his choice, but for not otherwise knowing him from Adam, I have to admit that I'm a little disappointed.

So once again, I guess we disagree on some things. But those evolution essays were great.


Continue reading...

Thursday, April 14, 2011

If I Had a Side Blog

1. A fitting summary of Glenn Beck's time at Fox News.

A low-lights reel of Beck’s worst moments on Fox would take hours to watch, but it would offer a useful seminar on the politics of incitement and near-mainstreaming of conspiracy theories in the Obama era. A talented broadcaster, Beck used his perch to echo old narratives straight out of the paranoid style in American politics—sinister plots to impose one-world government, the intentional subversion of the Constitution, the oppression of the faithful at the hands of a secular socialist elite hell-bent on replacing the American experiment with tyranny. “The Glenn Beck Show” is the closest the John Birch Society has ever come to having their own national program, reaching millions and poisoning political debate in the process.

2. When ground-breaking scientists go bad: Lynn Margulis edition.

3. Tennessee leads the nation in trying to get creationism back into schools. Texas and Florida follow close behind.

4. A skeptic of climate science finds that the experts may have been right all along; tells Congress.

5. Food for thought: "The rise of the Tea Party and its anti-intellectual, anti-establishment, anti-elite worldview has brought both a mainstreaming and a radicalization of antiscientific thought."

6. If you like popping zits, you'll love this. [Not for the easily disgusted.]


Continue reading...

Tuesday, April 05, 2011

Peak Oil

I've been casually reading a little bit about the issue of 'peak oil'. It seems like this topic doesn't get much attention--or as much as it, perhaps, deserves. The general concept is pretty simple: The easy sources of oil have mostly been found and the rate of their discovery is declining. When a new oil field is discovered and developed, the rate of oil production increases from zero to a certain point where oil cannot be extracted any faster. And then the rate of production begins to fall. You haven't run out of oil, but you can't produce it as quickly any more.

Here's a little analogy that helps me to think about this. Imagine a towel soaked with water. As you begin to wring it out, the water flows increasingly fast until it pours out at a maximum rate, then begins to decline. You rest a moment, and then try again. A lot of water comes out, but not as quickly as before, and each subsequent attempt yields less and less. Your rate of water production from the towel has peaked, and although you can continue producing water, the rate of production is diminishing.

This basic scenario applies on a global scale. When you aggregate all global oil fields together and consider that the rate of discovery of easy sources is declining, you are set up for the worldwide rate of production to peak, and then decline. This is a problem if demand for oil continues to increase, as it is expected to as the world population increases by billions and India and China become more prosperous, because supply will not be able to keep up with demand.

The main tricky part is uncertainty of timing because there usually isn't much warning that an oil field's peak is coming, so you don't know that you've hit the peak until after you've already passed it, and the same applies on a global scale. Although it remains uncertain, a lot of forecasters see the world hitting peak oil within the next 20-30 years. The rate of oil production in the continental U.S. peaked in the 1970s, and in the U.K. it peaked in 1999. A news article in the March 25 issue of Science opens with this:

Five years ago, many oil experts saw trouble looming. In 10 years or so, they said, oil producers outside the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) would likely be unable to pump oil any faster and OPEC would gain an even stronger hand among the world's oil producers. Five years on, it appears those experts may have been unduly optimistic—non-OPEC oil production may have been peaking as they spoke. Despite a near tripling of world oil prices, non-OPEC production, which accounts for 60% of world output, hasn't increased significantly since 2004. And many of those same experts, as well as some major oil companies, don't see it increasing again—ever.
Those major oil companies include Shell and ExxonMobil. In fact a graphic from the article (shown below) comes from an ExxonMobil energy outlook report.



Now for a little perspective. How much of the world's produced oil does the U.S. use? Answer: about 22%, with a little over half of that coming from imports, as shown in this graph [source]:



At this point you might think (aside from, "Hey, that looks like Pac-Man!"), "Well, we better pull out all the stops and drill everywhere we can in the U.S." Aside from the negative side-effects such an approach might have, there is one little problem which is illustrated with this graph:



As you can see, U.S. oil reserves are diddly-squat compared to the rest of the world--about 1.4% [source]. Here is another way to look at it [source]. (Click for large):




This, then, is what it means to say that we cannot drill our way out of the problem of oil dependence.




Further Reading:

For more, see the Hirsch Report, published in 2005 at the request of the Department of Energy. The summary version [PDF] is quite readable.


Continue reading...

Thursday, March 31, 2011

Science and the Word of Wisdom

When it comes to scripture being ahead of science, the Word of Wisdom (WofW) (D&C 89) is one of the first examples that comes to mind, in part, because of its iconic status. The ill effects of alcohol and tobacco are well established, and the prescription of grains, fruits, vegetables, and limited meat are in line with modern recommended dietary guidelines. It seems like a slam dunk example of scripture leading science, and it is often touted as such. However, it's a little more complicated than that.

As a historical matter, the Word of Wisdom was not really revolutionary for its time. It came amidst a temperance movement that made similar recommendations. Further, Lester Bush [1] has shown that it also matched the leading medical opinion of the time quite well. This is not because the physicians of the time suspected that, say, tobacco could cause cancer (a claim not made by the WofW either), but because the cause of disease was understood differently and the proscribed substances were thought to be contributing factors.

It might be argued that the endorsement of fruits and vegetables, with moderation in meat, was ahead of its time, but I don't think this is necessarily the case for two reasons. First, this counsel also matched medical opinion of the time (particularly the emphasis on seasons), but for reasons different than one would think today. Second, well, what else were the Saints going to eat? The dietary guidance of the WofW was basically what most of humanity had been doing since its beginning (or at least since the invention of agriculture).

There are also a couple of places where the WofW does not match current science, or does so tenuously. Tobacco is an interesting case. Long used in Native American folk medicine, it became a prominent medicinal treatment in European and colonial American medicine. In fact, it came to be viewed by some as a panacea and the list of ailments that it was alleged to cure--including bruises--was long. Although its use had been controversial for some time, the tide of enthusiasm for it began to turn in earnest in the nineteenth century. Nicotine was chemically isolated by chemists Posselt and Riemann in 1828 (five years before the WofW) and thereafter it's medicinal use came under sustained attack [2].

As for its endorsed uses, a search of Pubmed for references to tobacco and bruises did not turn up any relevant articles. Apparently BYU professor Rulon Francis found that bruises in rats treated with tobacco juice healed 20% faster. This finding was highlighted in the New York Times (Apr 28, 1981), but the story appears to end there. Although Francis published his method for bruising the rats, he does not appear to have published his tobacco findings. Thus the evidence for bruise-healing properties of tobacco is preliminary at best. The WofW also directs the use of tobacco for "all sick cattle," which is quite an inclusive category and recalls the reputation of tobacco as a panacea. Bush found that, historically, the use of tobacco in cattle was much less common than its use in horses. At any rate, whether or not tobacco would effectively treat any cattle ailments, a literal interpretation holding that tobacco is good for all sick cattle just isn't tenable.

Finally, the WofW prescribes various grains for livestock, including "rye for the fowls and for swine." However, as Steve Peck brought to my attention in his post, No death before the rye, chickens do not do well on diets heavy in rye. A little Internet searching turns up the reason: rye contains substances that interfere with digestion. Additionally, both swine and poultry find rye to be less palatable than other grains.

Before ending I should clarify that the question of whether the WofW was scientifically novel is largely a separate question from whether it was inspired. At the time it was given there were already socially and medically-based reasons to think that the proscribed substances were "not for the body, neither for the belly," and that grain and fruit were good. In most of these cases our modern knowledge has added to or replaced the old reasons, magnifying the inspiration in our eyes. Further, the WofW does not spell out any reasons for its recommendations other than that it is given "in consequence of evils and designs which do and will exist in the hearts of conspiring men in the last days."

So to summarize, although portions of the WofW have been borne out by modern science in a dramatic way, the WofW was not scientifically novel for its time and cannot be said to have--to paraphrase John Walton--offered a novel scientific perspective at the time. In coming to this conclusion, it's important to recognize that we are addressing a narrow question that has little to do with its revelatory basis and relevance today.


Notes:

1. Lester Bush (1981), The Word of Wisdom in Early Nineteenth-Century Perspective [PDF].

2. Grace G. Stewart (1967), A history of the medicinal use of tobacco 1492-1860.

See also:

Anne Charlton (2004), Medicinal uses of tobacco in history.

Word of Wisdom in the Encyclopedia of Mormonism

Michael Ash (2000), Up in Smoke: A Response to the Tanners' Criticism of the Word of Wisdom



Continue reading...

Sunday, March 27, 2011

John Walton on Scripture and Science

In the Lost World of Genesis One, John Walton argues against concordism--the attempt to make science and scripture match. In the course of his discussion of scientifically outdated beliefs that can be found in the Bible (existence of a firmament, entrails as the seat of thought, etc) he makes this provocative statement (p. 19):

Through the entire Bible, there is not a single instance in which God revealed to Israel a science beyond their own culture. No passage offers a scientific perspective that was not common to the Old World science of antiquity.
Is Walton right? And is this also true for our other scriptures? In the next few posts I plan to explore this a little more, especially as it pertains to our additional scriptures.

I should note that there are at least two ways to argue against Walton's statement without having to provide a clear counter-example. First, you can say that science hasn't caught up to scripture, or that scientific data are not interpreted correctly, so that such a judgment is premature. The other is to claim that of course the ancients understood the scientific truth of the matter. It was the intervening apostates who obscured that understanding in the scriptures. However, while there may be substance to these arguments, they both rely on unknown information. In the meantime, we can discuss some of the things that we do know.


(I am assembling a list of topics to explore. Here is your chance to make suggested additions: In what ways have the scriptures been ahead of science?)


Continue reading...

Tuesday, March 22, 2011

Prophets, Scripture, and Science

I've been doing some thinking about the relationship between prophets, scripture, and science. I think that I have enough material for a loosely cohesive series of posts. Much of what I will present represents continued exploration, so I hope to get some outside input. To start things off, I want to juxtapose two quotes. The first is from Hugh Nibley's The World and the Prophets (p. 134), and is one you may have seen before.

The words of the prophets cannot be held to the tentative and defective tests that men have devised for them. Science, philosophy, and common sense all have a right to their day in court. But the last word does not lie with them. Every time men in their wisdom have come forth with the last word, other words have promptly followed. The last word is a testimony of the gospel that comes only by direct revelation. Our Father in heaven speaks it, and if it were in perfect agreement with the science of today, it would surely be out of line with the science of tomorrow. Let us not, therefore, seek to hold God to the learned opinions of the moment when he speaks the language of eternity."
Now let's look at a passage from Conrad Hyers' book, The Meaning of Creation (p. 30-31). You may recall Hyers, formerly a professor of religion at Gustavus Adolphus College, from a previous post. The book was published in 1984 and is an extended argument for rejecting concordist assumptions about the creation account.
Again and again in the history of modern science, efforts have been made to correlate the Bible with the newest scientific data and theory in geology, paleontology, biology, physics, chemistry, and astronomy. If Genesis, however, were to be harmonized with the prevailing science of any particular generation, it would necessarily be out of harmony with the prevailing science of every other generation....To effect a "reconciliation" of science and Scripture at any one point in history would be a dubious achievement. To try to discredit some prevailing scientific theory and discount scientific evidence on the grounds that they will eventually be proved wrong and the Bible proved right is to keep matters of faith in everlasting suspension. Biblical affirmations are in harmony with the science of every period and culture, not because they have been harmonized by enterprising souls, but precisely because they have little to do with science.
These passages strike me as remarkably similar. Now for some discussion questions.

Is Nibley correct to say that revelation is the last word? Actually, he says that the last word lies with "a testimony of the gospel." Is that different?

What does Hyers mean when he says that assuming science will eventually be proved wrong and the Bible right "is to keep matters of faith in everlasting suspension"? Does this apply to our additional scriptural works?


Continue reading...

Wednesday, March 09, 2011

111

Sorry for the radio silence. Life has been busy and I haven't felt much motivating fire to post. And even when I have, I've felt it would be material that would weary you dear readers. So here is a little diversion.

I am told that people on Facebook have discovered a cosmic mystery associated with the number 111. (I don't have a Facebook account, myself). The basis for this mystery is the following:

Take your age in 2011 (e.g. say, 47).
Now add the year you were born (e.g. '64).
Low and behold, you get 111...and in the year 2011! And the crazy part is that this works for everyone born before the year 2000! (But even those born after 2000 get 11!) [Cue Twilight Zone music.]

People, this is not mysterious. Think about it this way:

2011 - 47 = 1964

1964 - 64 = 1900

2011 - 1900 = 111

A person that I explained this to was a little disappointed. They said my explanation kind of took the mystique out of it.

There are relationships among numbers that have a legitimate kind of mystique about them. This is not one of them.

Sorry if I ruined your day.


Continue reading...

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP