NRO, Expelled, and Dishonesty
(via The Panda's Thumb) -- John Derbyshire of National Review Online has written a column critical of the movie, Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed, wherein he laments the dishonesty of today's creationists and says that the movie is anti-Western civilization. A couple of money quotes:My own theory is that the creationists have been morally corrupted by the constant effort of pretending not to be what they are. What they are, as is amply documented, is a pressure group for religious teaching in public schools.
------------I think this willful act of deception has corrupted creationism irredeemably. The old Biblical creationists were, in my opinion, wrong-headed, but they were mostly honest people. The “intelligent design” crowd lean more in the other direction. Hence the dishonesty and sheer nastiness, even down to plain bad manners, that you keep encountering in ID circles. It’s by no means all of them, but it’s enough to corrupt and poison the creationist enterprise, which might otherwise have added something worthwhile to our national life, if only by way of entertainment value.
He also links to another NRO column by Discovery Institute fellow David Klinghoffer. I am not a regular reader of NRO, but this is not the first time I have read opinions of Discovery Institute fellows there.
Klinghoffer, as if to make Derbyshire's point, recently was shown to have quote-mined a historian, and in the linked column he either quote-mines or near-quote-mines Darwin three times. The second and third Darwin quotes are dealt with here and here, respectively.
As to the first: Klinghoffer says that Darwin thought morals came from natural processes rather than God and quotes him as follows:We may, therefore, reject the belief, lately insisted on by some writers, that the abhorrence of incest is due to our possessing a special God-implanted conscience.
Read in context, Darwin makes the point that,The nature and strength of the feelings which we call regret, shame, repentance or remorse, depend apparently not only on the strength of the violated instinct, but partly on the strength of the temptation, and often still more on the judgment of our fellows.
Darwin then relates examples of such peer-pressure, such as a man that felt compelled by duty to kill an innocent woman of another tribe. Darwin also notes that incest, which he refers to as an example of "real and great crimes," is often--but not universally--taboo, and that different cultures make different moral judgments. The offending quote then follows.
Now you could argue that Klinghoffer was correct; that Darwin saw morals as outcomes of natural processes. Fine. What is missing is that Darwin based his view in part on the behavior of humans. Indeed, Darwin might ask Klinghoffer, if "the abhorrence of [murder] is due to our possessing a special God-implanted conscience," why were the Nazis so successful at it?
Furthermore, if Klinghoffer looked further on in the chapter he would find passages like this:As man advances in civilisation, and small tribes are united into larger communities, the simplest reason would tell each individual that he ought to extend his social instincts and sympathies to all the members of the same nation, though personally unknown to him. This point being once reached, there is only an artificial barrier to prevent his sympathies extending to the men of all nations and races. If, indeed, such men are separated from him by great differences in appearance or habits, experience unfortunately shews us how long it is, before we look at them as our fellow-creatures. Sympathy beyond the confines of man, that is, humanity to the lower animals, seems to be one of the latest moral acquisitions.... This virtue, one of the noblest with which man is endowed, seems to arise incidentally from our sympathies becoming more tender and more widely diffused, until they are extended to all sentient beings. As soon as this virtue is honoured and practised by some few men, it spreads through instruction and example to the young, and eventually becomes incorporated in public opinion.
Or this:The moral sense perhaps affords the best and highest distinction between man and the lower animals; but I need say nothing on this head, as I have so lately endeavoured to shew that the social instincts,- the prime principle of man's moral constitution - with the aid of active intellectual powers and the effects of habit, naturally lead to the golden rule, "As ye would that men should do to you, do ye to them likewise"; and this lies at the foundation of morality.
Hitler probably missed those passages as well.
Klinghoffer concludes,Yet it is surely of interest that, at the very heart of his message, Hitler appealed to Germans primarily as devotees of modern biological science. He could have framed his pitch in any terms he liked. He chose evolutionary terms. No one knows what he believed in his heart, if he had one. But we know what he judged would stir up fellow Nazis and ordinary citizens to commit themselves to his movement. In that, he judged correctly.
The Discovery Institute, too, knows a thing or two about framing its pitch in terms of modern biological sciences in order to stir people up.

