The God Delusion
I finished reading The God Delusion, by Richard Dawkins. I do not want to add my voice to those of his critics who obviously miss his point or offer up lame counter-arguments, nor am I equal to the task of taking him on. And yet I feel like I ought to write something. I have mixed feelings about the book; Dawkins is clearly a smart person, and I think a great writer as well. He brings a number of issues into sharp focus and puts forth some strong arguments.
If you seriously consider what Dawkins has to say, I think that you are likely to come away with increased respect for atheists like Dawkins, even if you don't ultimately agree with him. Perhaps paradoxically, many Mormons may find that they can walk farther down the road with him than perhaps many other religious people can. Mormonism's history of throwing off traditions and creeds while espousing notions considered heretical to mainstream Christians (not to mention Jews and Muslims), I think, gives Mormons extra latitude to agree with Dawkins. Lincoln Cannon of the Mormon Transhumanist Association, for example, has written some interesting reviews of The God Delusion wherein he finds (what may seem surprising) agreement with Dawkins.
In his discussion of the ontological argument for God, Dawkins quotes Bertrand Russell as saying, "It is easier to feel convinced that [the ontological argument] must be fallacious than it is to find out precisely where the fallacy lies." Similarly, although I found much to agree with (at least provisionally), I'm not convinced that Dawkins's argument is air-tight, even if I have not identified all of the problems.
Seeking out truth--no matter what the source--is an ideal that I try to live by, and there are some hard truths in The God Delusion. But I am not convinced that it represents the whole truth, and nothing but the truth.


3 comments:
Thanks for the comments on the Dawkins book. Sounds like it is two cuts above the recent Sam Harris offerings, which are best described as a complete embarrassment to atheism as an intellectual endeavor. Dawkins has better credentials but still comes across as too shrill in the media these days. Maybe he tones it down a bit in this book.
I have not read Harris so I can't compare them. It is certainly a frontal assault on religion. However, since it is a book he can take the care and time to explain himself clearly.
It is possible that I am too charitible in my reading of him.
I haven't read his book, but I heard him interviewed on public radio a few weeks ago. It seems his major argument (at least the one they focused on in the interview) is that it is foolish to believe in something for which you have no evidence, and irresponsible to teach it as truth to your children.
I can see your point that Mormons should be more able to be accepting of that view than many religious people. We do believe that evidence is very important in discovering what is true. Were I, and most Mormons, would disagree with him is regarding what counts as "evidence." He includes only scientific evidence, but I would include personal spiritual evidence. I blogged about my argument here if you want to read the longer version.
I thought most religious people would feel likewise, but I was actually surprised that most of the people calling into the show had pretty weak and predictable arguments that really played right into his theory. It made me wonder if he might be right, at least in regards to many religious people.
Post a Comment