Understanding Widtsoe, Talmage, et al
Reading through the writings of some of our earlier brethren regarding evolution, one finds some strange passages. These passages are found in the writings of John A. Widtsoe, James E. Talmage, Sterling Talmage, and even Joseph Fielding Smith. Rather than try to catalog them, a couple of examples may suffice.
In Evidences and Reconciliations, John A. Widtsoe wrote, "The law of evolution or change may be accepted fully. It is an established fact so far as human power can determine. It is nothing more or less than the gospel law of progression or its opposite."
In Can Science Be Faith-Promoting (pg. 154) Sterling Talmage wrote:...the scientists who have followed Darwin and tested out his theories have found that natural selection has some bearing on the minor changes but that the great changes come about through mutations or the relatively sudden appearance of characteristics that cannot be ascribed to either heredity or environment. Many of these mutations seem to prepare the species for a succeeding environment in a way that suggests a foreshadowing of function.... The cause of mutations is as mysterious as is the origin of life; but many scientists are ascribing it to the design of some controlling intelligence, and the strict materialists are losing ground in scientific circles.
Two concepts are represented in the above passages: First, that evolution is a form of progress, and second, that mutation is more important than (and even refutes) natural selection. (As an aside, notice also Sterling Talmage's God-of-the-gaps comment on mutation. Alas, the materialists lived to fight another day.)
Most people probably would not notice such passages, however, they should seem strange to anyone familiar with evolution. What in the world are they talking about? How are mutations antagonistic to natural selection? The answer is in the history of science and in forthcoming posts I will briefly discuss that history.
Other posts in this series:
1. LDS Commentators and the Eclipse of Darwinism
2. Ontogeny, Phylogeny, and the First Presidency


0 comments:
Post a Comment