Francis Collins in National Geographic
Francis Collins, the man who headed the public side of the human genome project, has written a book about science and his faith in God titled, The Language of God. There is an interview with him in the current National Geographic. Below are a couple of passages that caught my eye.
Continue ReadingHorgan: The problem I have with miracles is not just that they violate what science tells us about how the world works. They also make God seem too capricious. For example, many people believe that if they pray hard enough God will intercede to heal them or a loved one. But does that mean that all those who don't get better aren't worthy?
I was a bit surprised by that answer. You would think (or at least I did) that an evangelical Christian physician and scientist would have at least one or two stories of the potentially miraculous.
Collins: In my own experience as a physician, I have not seen a miraculous healing, and I don't expect to see one. Also, prayer for me is not a way to manipulate God into doing what we want him to do. Prayer for me is much more a sense of trying to get into fellowship with God. I'm trying to figure out what I should be doing rather than telling Almighty God what he should be doing. Look at the Lord's Prayer. It says, "Thy will be done." It wasn't, "Our Father who art in Heaven, please get me a parking space."Horgan: What do you think about the field of neurotheology, which attempts to identify the neural basis of religious experiences?
I don't think you can say that without taking the science to the next step. And that is, why does the temporal lobe light up? Speaking from the background of Mormon materialism, there must be a physical reason.
Collins: I think it's fascinating but not particularly surprising. We humans are flesh and blood. So it wouldn't trouble me—if I were to have some mystical experience myself—to discover that my temporal lobe was lit up. That doesn't mean that this doesn't have genuine spiritual significance. Those who come at this issue with the presumption that there is nothing outside the natural world will look at this data and say, "Ya see?" Whereas those who come with the presumption that we are spiritual creatures will go, "Cool! There is a natural correlate to this mystical experience! How about that!"


8 comments:
Francis Collins said: "In my own experience as a physician, I have not seen a miraculous healing, and I don't expect to see one."
Jared* commented: "You would think ... that an evangelical Christian physician and scientist would have at least one or two stories of the potentially miraculous."
If Collins is a successful physician, he has seen numerous miraculous heaings. President Kimball taught that every time anyone recovers from illness or injury it is a miracle:
-------------------- quote --------------------
"It must be remembered that no physician can heal. He can only provide a satisfactory environment and situation so that the body may use its own God-given power of re-creation to build itself. Bones can be straightened, germs can be killed, sutures can close wounds, and skillful fingers can open and close bodies; but no man yet has found a way to actually heal. Man is the offspring of God and has within him the re-creating power that is God-given. And through the priesthood and through prayer, the body’s healing processes can be speeded and encouraged. Again, how grateful we are for the skill and patience and understanding of our great men who are trained to give us such marvelous service.
"There are many who run to the doctor first and then go later to the elders when all other hope is gone. Elders are often called to the hospital to administer after the medical profession has done all it can. Then when the ill one is on his way to recovery, his recovery is credited to the scientist; or in case of death, some wonder why the priesthood did not heal him. It must be remembered that whether the Lord sees fit to heal instantaneously or gradually, whether it be through surgery and treatment or without it, the healing is still the Lord’s miracle. While the profession has worked hard to gain the accumulated knowledge of today, it must be remembered that He who created our bodies has known since the beginning how to remodel, re-create, and repair them....
"I went into surgery a few years ago [and] as a result of the blessings of the Lord, healing followed.... The skeptic might have other answers." (New Era, Oct. 1981, p. 45; emphasis added.)
------------------ end quote ------------------
In this context, is Collins a believing Christian or a skeptic?
.
I'm reading his book right now. I've only just begun, but I really like it.
Gary,
I think your quote is missing some important context. That said, I guess it depends on how you want to define a miracle or where you set the bar. This particular passage sets the bar pretty low, but other passages in Kimball's article set it higher, and I understand Collins to be saying that he has not experienced the higher standard.
a believing Christian or a skeptic
Perhaps that's a false dichotomy.
.
Jared*,
1.
Thanks for the link to President Kimball's 1981 New Era article. He contrasted believers with skeptics in the last paragraph: "Let not the skeptic disturb your faith." More recently, President Monson made a similar contrast when he said "faith and doubt cannot exist in the same mind at the same time." (Ensign, Feb. 2001.)
"There can be no faith without belief," said President McKay. (Ensign, Apr. 1975.) The dichotomy between belief and skepticism is real and I think asking whether someone is a believer or a skeptic is a valid question.
You say Collins is "an evangelical Christian physician." Doubtless some of his patients recover. And President Kimball declared all such recovery to be "the Lord's miracle" so in that sense Collins is a skeptic who doesn't see God's hand in his success as a physician.
2.
Reading President Kimball's article together with Priesthood Lesson 6 for that year (see below) leads to the conclusion that he believed man's physical body "is the offspring of God and has within [it] the re-creating power that is God-given."
I believe Elder Talmage was also talking about man's physical body when he stated that "man is ... born in the lineage of Deity, not in the posterity of the brute creation." ("The Earth and Man," pp. 13-14.)
3.
I never did tell you how much I appreciated your comments last year when we discussed the 1980-81 Priesthood Lesson 6. You were right when you said the manual doesn't constitute an official Church statement.
Whether or not it was so in the 1980s, current practice is the First Presidency and the Twelve review priesthood manuals before they are printed. Either way, the above cited article suggests President Kimball agreed with what was taught in Lesson 6 about man's physical body.
.
Gary,
It seems a little unfair to judge Collins by Pres. Kimball's view of healing. However I agree with you as to what Pres. Kimball probably believed about the origin of the physical body, though I must point out that in terms of healing there is nothing particularly unique about the human body. Most life-forms on this earth have healing mechanisms. Indeed, by studying theirs we better understand ours.
As James Talmage wrote in Jesus the Christ, "The human sense of the miraculous wanes as comprehension of the operative process increases."
.
Jared*,
Talmage spoke as a true believer and in the very next paragraph he said the natural growth of grapes with which to produce wine is no less a miracle than Jesus changing water to wine. Perhaps we can just agree that Collins measures miracles differently than Kimball and Talmage.
.
Maybe so. Talmage begins that section by writing that a miracle is "a phenomenon not susceptible of explanation, far less of demonstration, by what we consider the ordinary operation of natural law."
I think Collins would say that much of healing falls under "ordinary operation of natural law."
It occurs to me that Pres. Kimball's argument can be turned around to make ordinary disease, itself, a miracle. "It must be remembered that no [scientist] can [cause disease]. He can only provide a satisfactory environment and situation so that the [germs] may use [their] own God-given power of re-creation to [infect the body and] build [themselves]."
My original point was that I was surprised that Collins didn't have a story or two to tell. I'm not arguing that miracles do not occur, though I think attributing all healing to the miraculous (as distinguished from wonderous) empties the word "miracle" of meaning.
I was also surprised about Collins' comment about miracles. But it seems clear that he believes a miracle to be something that majorly departs from the natural course. I examined Horgan's interview with Collins in this post. I particularly enjoyed Collins' take on the roles of human evil and natural tragedy.
Post a Comment