Michael Ash on Lineage Histories
[This is part of a series of posts I initiated with Book of Mormon Scholarship as an Elias for Evolution.]
Readers of this blog might enjoy Michael Ash's column at Mormon Times, a website run by the Deseret News. Of particular interest in this series of posts is something he wrote about the Book of Mormon being a lineage history in Why aren't other peoples mentioned in the Book of Mormon? As you read the following quote, think about how this can apply to Adam and Eve, etc.
While dynastic histories claim to tell the entire story, they actually only deal with the story as it relates to a particular dynastic family. And unlike modern scholarly histories, ancient accounts often served as propaganda to support a particular leader or group. "Others" are peripheral to the main story. In traditional tribal narratives, no one else exists unless it was necessary to mention them with regard to interaction with the tribe.

2 comments:
interesting connection
Sorry to be a wet blanket, but I didn't find Michael Ash's arguments very satisfying. The only specific example of a lineage history/tribal narrative that he gives outside the BoM is the Bible, and that lineage history mentions "others" a lot. Of course the BoM mentions "others" as well; the problem is that it only mentions semitic "others." The BoM is a dynastic history all right, but that's hardly an argument for historical accuracy.
The BoM differs from typical tribal narratives in a few important ways. For one, tribal narratives are usually third person accounts delivered centuries after the fact (the Bible being a typical example). Michael Ash mentions Ebla as being absent from the Bible narrative; the Bible was written down long after Ebla's heyday, and the writers may well have been ignorant of its existence. Even if tribal narratives are eventually written, they usually depend at least in part on oral tradition, which accounts for some historical inaccuracy. In contrast, the BoM is supposed to be based on first person, contemporaneous written accounts. And frankly, I'm a little tired of apologists confidently asserting that contacts with non semites were not important enough to BoM writers to mention. Nephi finds the discovery of goats, horses, asses, and oxen important enough to mention. But humans? What use are other people?
Lineage histories tend to contain historical inaccuracies. Even Michael Ash notes that one of their functions is to propagandize. Biblical lineage history is used to explain the supremacy of Judah over other tribes, Israel over the Canaanites and Edomites, descendants of Moses over descendants of Aaron, one group of priests over another group of priests, etc. My favorite Biblical propaganda is the story of the origin of Israel's traditional enemies, the Moabites and Ammonites. So if the Bible is a tribal or dynastic history, then it's likely to contain some historical inaccuracies, particularly as it reaches farther back in time. It's quite plausible that Bible writers were simply ignorant of people before Adam.
Post a Comment