Sunday, June 06, 2010

Before Adam

[This is part of a series of posts I initiated with Book of Mormon Scholarship as an Elias for Evolution.]


The groundwork for the argument that Genesis is an ethnocentric account was laid by Hugh Nibley in his "Before Adam," which was published in Old Testament and Related Studies, the first volume of The Collected Works of Hugh Nibley, and was based on a speech given in 1980. If you are not familiar with this article you should take some time to read it. However, you'll need to take his comments on science with a grain of salt. As FAIR puts it, "The science has advanced substantially since Nibley's article, and so its scientific claims should no longer be considered current. However, his theologic and historic perspective is still useful."

Nibley stressed the importance of keeping in mind the limited perspective of the people involved in the scriptural accounts. As we read we must keep asking ourselves what exactly was seen and understood. I would add that we should also pay attention to how words are used and their potential alternative meanings. For example, the Hebrew word for 'earth' can refer to the whole planet, or a limited area (i.e. 'land'). The Book of Mormon repeatedly uses the phrase 'the whole earth' in a context that clearly does not mean the whole earth (see 3 Nephi 8 for several examples), and at one point the Book of Moses explicitly notes that Moses "beheld many lands; and each land was called earth," (Moses 1:29).

Nibley also explored questions raised by the narrative. We'll look at some of those later. For now let's look at his conclusion.

Do not begrudge existence to creatures that looked like men long, long ago, nor deny them a place in God's affection or even a right to exaltation—for our scriptures allow them such. Nor am I overly concerned as to just when they might have lived, for their world is not our world. They have all gone away long before our people ever appeared. God assigned them their proper times and functions, as he has given me mine—a full-time job that admonishes me to remember his words to the overly eager Moses: "For mine own purpose have I made these things. Here is wisdom and it remaineth in me." (Moses 1:31.) It is Adam as my own parent who concerns me. When he walks onto the stage, then and only then the play begins. He opens a book and starts calling out names. They are the sons of Adam, who also qualify as sons of God, Adam himself being a son of God. This is the book of remembrance from which many have been blotted out. They have fallen away, refused to choose God as their father, and by so doing were registered in Satan's camp. "Satan shall be their father, and misery shall be their doom." (Moses 7:37.)
In reading Nibley again, I was struck by this next part. Again, we run into the ANE context of Genesis.
Can we call them sons of Adam, bene-Adam, human beings proper? The representative Egyptians, Babylonians, Greeks, and Romans, to name only the classic civilizations of old, each fancied themselves to be beings of a higher nature, nearer to gods than others who inhabited the land with them (and before them), or who dwelt in other lands. And yet they did not deny humanity to them.



20 comments:

Anonymous,  6/07/2010 12:31:00 AM  

I'm really digging this series. Thanks for writing this. I haven't seen an entirely graceful possible reconciliation of Genesis and evolution yet but I have high hopes for this.

Syphax,  6/07/2010 12:35:00 AM  

That comment wasn't meant to be anonymous, sorry. Anyway, keep it up.

Unknown,  6/07/2010 12:50:00 AM  

Wow, I read "Before Adam" just within the last couple months and I completely missed those passages. Thank you for this series. But I'm a little confused by the first passage. Is it to be interpreted as the pre-Adamic hominids were somehow rejectors of the Gospel and, therefore, not worthy of redemption, etc.?

Anonymous,  6/07/2010 02:46:00 PM  

Never liked the whole "Before Adam" by Nibley. I think it subscribes too much to a view inconsistant with the scriptures. The scriptures state that man was the first man of "all men". The scriptures also state that the temporal age of the earth is some 6000 years old, far too young for what the "arm of man" states it as being. Whom am I to believe- the word of God or the arm of man?


The evidence for some pre-human is shotty at best. No one knows for sure on that matter. All they have is some bones similar to both a human and an ape. Before Adam there was no life- that is what the scriptures state.

rob osborn.

Tim,  6/07/2010 06:33:00 PM  

Rob Osborn, are you LDS? I was told on my mission by a General Authority that the earth wasn't necessarily 6000 years old--that the "days" spoken of in Genesis weren't necessarily days or even a thousand years, but could have been "periods of time."

Jared*,  6/07/2010 11:28:00 PM  

Syphax,

I'm glad you are enjoying it, but don't get your hopes too high.

D.H.,

I don't get any sense that Nibley was passing judgment on them. He's basically just saying that God has his own purposes.

Rob,

Whom am I to believe- the word of God or the arm of man?

Hmmm. Are we talking Pee-wee Herman or Arnold Schwarzenegger?

Before Adam there was no life- that is what the scriptures state.

I guess James E. Talmage and B.H. Roberts missed that part.

Tim,

Rob was talking about the number of years since the Fall.

Anonymous,  6/08/2010 01:16:00 AM  

One of the basic principles of our doctrine is the fall. The fall in LDS doctrine is an event that effected all living things. I have never seen someone able to reconcile evolution with this event- it just doesn't work. Some have stated that the garden and the world were two different conditions- one having no death while the other had death abounding. But that isn't supported by scripture. Others have stated that the fall only effected Adam and Eve, but again, it is not supported by scripture.

Even still, as Nibley and others have stated, death abounded upon the earth for long periods of time but then the advent of Adam and Eve caused a new condition where no death was thus found- again, not supported by scripture. In fact, the only viable scenerio that the scriptures supports is the one where there is no death of any living thing until the fall happens ushering death into the entire creation.

Nibleys "Before Adam" is just what he states it is- a play- a fictional fairytale where once pondered and paraded across the imagination, disappears into fairyland stuff and then we wake up to the reality of the truth- no death before the fall.

rob osborn.

Jeff G,  6/08/2010 02:30:00 PM  

Rob,

I'm curious how you would respond if somebody ran Jared's model of a historical Adam and my model of a historical fall from heaven at the same time:

http://www.newcoolthang.com/index.php/2005/10/monkey-man/151/#comment-6140

Anonymous,  6/09/2010 12:00:00 AM  

Jeff G,

You see, I do not view evolution as ever happening. I also do not look upon the earth and see vast countless ages long past now seen as rock layers. I see a relatively young earth with some great catastrophes in its recent past- namely the largest- the global flood in Noah's day. So, the way i view it is that with the flood being an actual historical catastrophe in Noah's day, it really leaves no room for finding any evidence for long ages or for evolution to occur.

After all, if the flood really did happen and cover the entire earth, it would account for the vast sedimentary layers trapping billions of living things in their layers- exactly what we see.

rob osborn

Stan,  6/09/2010 01:16:00 AM  

"After all, if the flood really did happen and cover the entire earth, it would account for the vast sedimentary layers trapping billions of living things in their layers- exactly what we see."

Rob, those layers of Igneous rocks, intermixed with your sedimentary rocks all laid down at once, with their pesky atomic decay all jumbled up in time, are satan's tool just to fool us. Adam? He had all kinds of time to name the other 90% of all life forms we see encased in those Noastic sediments besides the 10 million or so that are still around today. Especially the beetles... 200,000 known beetle species came from all over the world for Adam to name them. It was a good thing too cause they would have to repeat the journey to load up on the ark. The sediments, filled with the extinct species that missed out on the ark, which also destroyed the beetle's unique and sensitive habitats? No problem, they adapt quickly. Oh, wait... that's too close to evolution. Hmm... Well some kind of miracle happened!

Rob Osborn, you rock! It takes some serious cajones to flaunt ignorance with such style and flair.

Clark Goble,  6/09/2010 01:19:00 AM  

Rob - how do you interpret the scriptures about Adam and Eve being cast out of Eden with an angel guardian the entrance to ensure they couldn't get back in? It sounds like the idea that the garden was the whole world and everything fell just isn't supported by scripture.

Also to say the evidence for humans prior to 4000 BC is shoddy is...well it makes me wonder what you count as evidence. The evidence is so overwhelming it's like saying the sky is red during the day rather than red.

To say there was no life prior to Adam also is not scriptural. Adam was not the first creation according to Genesis. One can debate how to take Gen 2 vs. Gen 1 but one would hope you'd recognize that it is hardly clear.

Jeff G,  6/09/2010 03:04:00 AM  

What I am curious about is where Rob thinks Jared's reasoning goes wrong. He spends an awful lot of time in the nacle telling people that they've reached the wrong conclusions, but he rarely slows down to point out which premises and/or fallacies are leading people like us astray. If he could say a little more about the content of the post, I'd be interested to hear it.

Anonymous,  6/09/2010 09:20:00 PM  

Jeff,

I have often told people where I think their reasoning is wrong. For starters, explain how exactly the sediment layers we see in the grand canyon formed? I have explained the fallacies of common thoughts on how it formed but would love to hear how you explain it.

Unknown,  6/10/2010 02:09:00 AM  

Rob,
I am having a debate with a friend that perhaps you could help me out with, since you seem so level-headed. My friend has this crazy notion that the earth is round and if we were in, say, Spain or Portugal and wanted to sail to the Indies we could sail West to arrive in the East. I believe you say it best when you said the evidence is shotty(sic) at best. we both know the earth is flat and if we were to sail west to go east, we would fall off the turtle's back, wouldn't you agree?

Jeff G,  6/10/2010 03:26:00 PM  

Rob,

I think you misunderstand me. I don't doubt for a second that you have shown people THAT they are wrong, or WHERE you think they are wrong. What I'm wondering is where you think their reasoning goes astray?

We all know that you think Jared's conclusions are wrong. But do you think this is a result of some logical fallacy (if so, which one?) or rather the product of some false premise which he accepts (if so, which one?)

Since Jared doesn't mention anything about floods and the like, your response wasn't really what I was hoping for.

Jared*,  6/10/2010 09:24:00 PM  

Jeff,

I've always liked the fall-from-heaven idea. It's much more applicable to each of us.

(As I recall, I was independently thinking along the same lines as you, but you got it out there first.)

Unknown,  6/11/2010 02:22:00 AM  

Jeff,
So are you theorizing that the A&E story is more allegorical to each of our departures from the pre-mortal existance and arrival on earth, or do you also believe their is some literal-ness to the A&E story? (I'm really curious as to this concept. On the surface I like the idea, but I still hold to the belief that A&E were literally the first mortal man and woman). Thank you

Jeff G,  6/11/2010 03:33:00 AM  

DH,

I think each person can decide for themselves how they want to take it. Personally, I don't like calling my reading of it "symbolic" or something like that, because I think it should be read as a temple text: each of us (portrayed by Adam and Eve) actually and literally left heaven to come to earth. There was also an actual Adam and Eve who we could call the first people on earth who had come from Father's presence. The details on this last part are a little iffy for me, but I think Jared's doing a great job putting forward a more detailed account.

Anonymous,  6/13/2010 07:41:00 PM  

I like Clark's implication that Adam and Eve were moved to a new place or sphere and could not return to the old -- the "old" being the Garden in which there was no death.

Jack

Unknown,  6/13/2010 07:54:00 PM  

Jeff:
Thank you. That clarification really helps. I like how you look at it like a temple text. That makes a lot of sense.

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP