Adam and Eve: Reading Between the Lines
[This is part of a series of posts I initiated with Book of Mormon Scholarship as an Elias for Evolution.]
We turn now to the narrative about Adam and Eve and their posterity, where we will look for clues for the potential existence of others. Below I simply describe or quote the relevant part of the story and ask questions about it.And Adam and Eve blessed the name of God, and they made all things known unto their sons and their daughters. And Satan came among them, saying: I am also a son of God; and he commanded them, saying: Believe it not; and they believed it not, and they loved Satan more than God. And men began from that time forth to be carnal, sensual, and devilish. (Moses 5:13.)
If Adam, Eve, and their children were the only people on earth, why did the children have such a hard time believing their parents? Who would tell them otherwise? Were they really having conversations with Satan? Is it possible that there were, in fact, other people influencing Adam and Eve's children? Could Satan's declaration, "I am also a son of God" actually be a reference to surrounding competing religions where, as Nibley noted, claimed ties between humans and gods were not uncommon.Speaking of Noah, God promised Enoch "that he [God] would call upon the children of Noah; and he sent forth an unalterable decree, that a remnant of his seed [Enoch's through Noah] should always be found among all nations, while the earth should stand; and the Lord said: Blessed is he through whose seed Messiah shall come." (Moses 7:51-53.) Methuselah boasted about his line as something special. (Moses 8:2-3.) Why special if it included the whole human race? These blessings have no meaning if all the people of the earth and all the nations are the seed of Noah and Enoch.
Most of these elements can be given mundane interpretations consistent with Adam and Eve as the only people on earth. The point is not to suggest that an alternate interpretation is more natural or obvious. Rather, now that we have abundant evidence from archaeology and genetics, does the text contain possibilities that have been previously unappreciated?

34 comments:
Fun read. I've also wondered if the bit about relations between the "sons of god" and the "daughters of men" might imply something similar to what your saying -- the implication that on the one hand you have the seed of Adam and Eve and on the other everyone else.
Jack
One of the fundamental questions is what was unique about Adam?
Was it intelligence?
Writing?
Knowledge of how to do things?
Or, something else?
Wow! I'm absolutely loving this series! thank you. (btw, interesting insight Jack about the "sons of god" and "daughters of men") Sooo...could the "giants" spoken of in the scriptures have been neanderthals then? (please tell me I'm not the only one that wondered that when reading this part)
I don't know about "unappreciated." BYU professors have been teaching these possibilities for at least twelve years.
If you're right, it's a pity that the revelations weren't more explicit about the existence of extra-adamic lineages. There are practical implications to misunderstanding these things. The priesthood ban partially depended on force fitting a simplistic understanding of human origins to the existence of different races. Some clarity in revelation might have helped us avoid that.
Once I realized that African ancestry preceded a putative Cain or Ham, the notion that all black people descend from Cain or Ham and all white people don't lost all its plausibility.
Of course, it's not too late for a little more revelation. As recently as five years ago, missionaries teaching a black investigator in my home explained that the priesthood ban had to do with Cain/Ham's descendants not being able to hold the priesthood until 1978.
To start-
Methusaleh bragged of his loins because the promise was extended through his seed only. At that time on the earth there were probably millions or even hundreds of millions of peoles on the earth. The flood was predicted while all of these millions were still on the earth. Only one chosen blood line would thus be saved and allowed to repoulate the earth after the flood. It is no wonder then that Methusaleh would brag about this, after all, every prophet in our day is a direct lineal descendent of Methuselah. It even includes every soul on the face of the earth today- we are all Methuselah's direct descendents.
Second-
Adam was the "first man of all men". End of story on there being any others.
third-
The sons of God marrying the daughters of men is in reference to those holding the holy priesthood (read Moses) marrying outside the covenant. As we join the church we become the sons and daughters of God whereas before that we are just the sons and daughters of men.
fourth and final-
No scripture supports the silly notion of there being any other race of men other than that coming from Adam and Eve.
End of story, end of debate.
rob osborn.
"End of story, end of debate."
Rob Osborn, you put a smile on my face.
While I can't help but smile at Rob's pulpit pounding self-assurance, I think he does have some pretty good points.
Don't get me wrong, I have no doubt whatsoever that there were pre-Adamites. I do have my doubts that the creation accounts support this hypothesis.
My own sense is that the biggest mistake made in treating the scriptures as a history of the world is that they are the history of one people -- predominately Israelites.
More importantly, the Bible was not dictated word for word from deity, otherwise much does not make sense.
Around 1000 b.c., give or take a few hundred years, the first five books of the Pentateuch were written. Much of the included material was from oral traditions. Perhaps portions was from some of the early patriarchs.
But, what was conveyed was the history of one particular people in the broader Middle East. And, of course, they exaggerated.
That is why you have the exodus involving hundreds of thousands of people in an event that probably involved a few hundred or few thousand.
That is why a world-girdling flood was set forth when there is no evidence of even a significant region-wide event. But, there is evidence of smaller, localized events (most predominately the Black Sea).
And, creation myths are important in most societies. That is why we get one describing a series of events that are not reflected in the Earth's geologic or paleontological history.
Adam & Eve is interesting.
My own guess is they existed. But, their role could be radically different. Perhaps they were the first to have writing. Or, the first to have direct communication with God to prompt civilization forward.
The temple experience is symbolic. Is it surprising the scriptures also include non-literal symbolism?
P.S. This is my take. I believe that God's role in mankind is significant. Just not as intrusive as some literalists believe.
One of the problems I see is that people only recognoze the bible and it's events within the understanding of knowledge they have gained from mans "educated" teachings.
We could discount every major event in the bible as being symbolic or allegorical or even mythical or imagination. When we do this it thus places God's word as second nature to mens educated understanding. As we do this however, we must resolve though to do it accross the board. We can thus state that Jesus was just a mortal- a great prophet in his day who used magic or other black arts to perform his perceived miracles. Perhaps his miracles just need a more rational explanation.
For instance- when he walked on water he was really just walking on rocks barely below the surface. His turning water into wine? Perhaps he knew some advanced chemistry and while no one was looking (or maybe they were) he added a substance that quickly turned into a different taste- kind of liek a Kool-aid packet.
As for resurrection- ha, it's just a myth, no one has really ever witnessed it anyway. Near death experiences- they are just the reaction of consiousness at certain times when the heart begins to waver.
You know what- perhaps man just made up God and he doesn't really exist! After all- do you know anyone who has actually met him?
Do you get the point?
As LDS we must assume on faith that Adam and Eve were our literal ancestors- our first parents on this earth created by our Father in heaven. We must also assume on faith that they were the only men- the first of our race upon this earth just as the scriptures attest to this reality.
We must also assume through faith that the world became wicked and corrupt and that a great prophet named Noah was sent into all parts of the earth to warn them the floods were coming and that they needed to repent. We must also assume that during this time a portion of the livable planet was taken away from our planet and Enoch and his followers left on this smaller portion to live closer to where God now dwells.
We must also assume through faith that earth that then existed was utterly destroyed by the flood of waters prophesied by Noah and that all flesh died upon the "whole" of the earths surface save it was Noah and his family.
We musta also assume that from Noah, sprang all of the current nations of the earth, and that every living soul can trace his lineage directly to the literal seed of Noah.
We must also assume through faith that all of Jesus miracles were actual miracles and that not only is resurrection possible, it's inevtiable and will defy everything we now know about biology and how it supposedly works.
Why must we assume all of this? because that is what makes us believers in Gods holy word- its what makes us his followers, believeing in all of his miracles that seem to fly in the face of all of mans understandings. Thats why we are LDS.
rob osborn.
Rob, all kidding and taunting aside, I appreciate your dedication to the scriptures and the teachings of the leaders of the church. That being said, according to your argument, any world view one may have that is not explicitly stated by the scriptures or church leaders is not valid. For example, are you not relying on man's "educated" teachings when you accept that the Grand Canyon was formed by the flood? That fossils were laid down in the sediment of the flood? The only world view you can hold, to be consistent with your argument, must stem only from scripture and church leaders. Everything else is the learning of man and according to your argument, completely unreliable. Otherwise, where do you draw the line? What teachings of man will you accept or not accept and what is your criteria? Do you only reject the teachings of man when they apparently conflict with scripture? Why do you hold to a specific interpretation of scripture when the church as a whole is more open minded? What makes mans teachings valid when dealing with medicine, technology, art, music, relativity, quantum mechanics etc but selectively invalid when it comes to geology?
My point is that your argument favors ignorance and arbitrary selective criteria. This is fine for you, but you must understand many of us are not satisfied with that.
Very well put, Stan! Thank you.
Stan,
I see geology with open eyes and see it logically. Nothing I study is done with an ignorance for one side. I look at all the available information and draw my own conclusion. The GC sedimentary layers were clearly not laid down in the method they described. Trust me on this. I drew it over and over again and made all the necessary calculations and, frankly, it just doesn't add up. There are way to many sedimentary layers with a lot of layers to be acconted for a shallow sea coming and retreating and depositing what must have been a never ending mountain chain of sediment. I have asked some of the best minds to draw it up on paper and no one will do it.
Lets face it, the layers in the GC were not formed over hundreds of millions of years with a shallow sea coming and retreating slowly depositing what must have been a mountain the size of Canada. In this case, "the present is the key to the past" is a giant no-show- it didn't happen the way they said it happened. Any somewhat intelligent person can figure that out.
So, before you say I am in ignorance perhaps you can describe in your own way how exactly the GC did form.
Rob,
Let's just say that your right about the Grand Canyon. What about all the many, many other sources of evidence which point to not only an ancient earth, but ancient human inhabitants as well? There is a reason why ALL geologist believe as they do, and it's not conspiracy related.
"I look at all the available information and draw my own conclusion."
You are entitled to that. Why you give your own conclusion so much more weight than trained geologists who spend their lives studying the issue is puzzling.
My point, however, is that if you dismiss the learning of men as being unreliable, you must also include your own learning. The scriptures say nothing of the grand canyon, the strata, the origin of fossils, yet you make bold claims regarding them and seem to be quite proud that it is indeed your own learning. At the same time you dismiss several fields of science with the same confidence. This is inconsistent. To be consistent you would have to admit yourself that you do not know how the Grand Canyon formed or why the strata is as it is. You are replacing the theories of men with your own theories of a man.
btw, Rob, I don't think an explanation of how the Grand Canyon was formed will help you any. You've read the science, dismissed it and replaced it with your own theory. No more explaining will change that. You are most welcome to keep your belief as it is.
Stan,
I am not surprized that you couldn't offer a truly valid explanation for the formation of the GC, no one has been able to do it with the learning and reasoning of current geologic models.
The GC sediments were obviously laid rather quickly along with some volcanic activity happening at the same time. Now whether the GC sediments were formed at the Flood of Noah or some time after when flood waters were receding off the land it doesn't matter. What is important is that there was a massive flood carrying trillions of tons of sediment and as the water receded the flood sediments layered themselves rather uniformly parallel forming what we now see in the GC- the sedimentary layers.
It is not rocket science to understand that the layers found in the GC were laid relatively at the same time.
I'll take up the challenge on how the Grand Canyon was formed.
It was formed by a variety of methods.
One can find layers that were deposited in fairly deep ocean, mostly limestone. There are layers that are mudstones and silt from rivers, etc. Other layers are petrified sand dunes.
Of note, the plant and animal remains layer with simple on the bottom and more complex as one rises up.
None is consist with a single flood.
A single flood wouldn't include sandstone from sand dunes. Nor would it layer thousands of feet of limestone (from shells and other animal remains). Nor would it include hundreds of feed of mud.
More importantly, it would be an interesting flood to layer with very simple plants lowest down followed by increasingly complex animal life.
Creationists have to gloss over the fossil and geologic record because their claims can withstand even minimal scrutiny.
The Earth is of great age with life developing with increasing complexity. That is the reality.
Rob,
I'm confused. This is what it sounds like you are saying:
1000's of floods could not have made the grand canyon. Therefore 1 flood must have done it.
I can't believe that this is what you actually think, so maybe you could clear it up for me?
Jeff,
The reason thousands or even hundreds of floods could not have formed the layers is quite simple. You first have to have a sea of some sort- coming and going. When it is present it is depositing and when it is gone it is eroding. In the GC case, over a period of hundreds of millions of years it was depositing more than it was eroding. This means that somewhere these deposits were coming from some "source" higher in elevation and then being carried downstream and deposited in the shallow sea.
So, the problem we have is that somewhere higher up in elevation we have what would seem to be a never ending chain of mountains upthrusting and then eroding away into nothing over and over again. But wait... Once a mountain wa seroded it is gone. So, you have this paramount problem of creating a "source" for all of these sedimentary layers, all of which differ from each other in their composits. What, did the GC area become the final resting spot for all the rising mountains eroded away from every region? No, because this is seen pretty much everywhere in the world.
The problem with thousands of separate flood events is that the process of erosion works in a rather quick way to continually redistribute the same material over and over again. What we see in the GC is not this process. No, what we see is an event that redistributed the majority of the layers at the same time. Since then we have not seen much if any "new deposits" because no sea has been present since it's redistribution. But we have witnessed the great erosion taking place carving out the canyon we see today. Now, if the "present is the key to the past", a common principle of geologists "uniformatarianism", then what we should see in the GC is a massive yet chaotic random placing of erosion and deposits happening over and over again in the canyon walls. The truth is, we see exactly the opposite. We see a bunch of pretty much parallel layers with a river carving out the gorge we see. We do not see any witness of deposit and erosion happening over and over again- after all, it must have happened at least a thousand times over the course of hundreds of millions of years.
The rocks don't lie, they tell a story consistenet with a catastrophic flood event- the scale of which no modern man has ever witnessed. The rocks are a testament of God's words- that testimony being that God really did destroy the ancient earth in Noah's day with a massive and catastrophic flood. A flood so massive that the earths entire topography was destroyed, redistributed and changed. To sign off as a witness and yet also a blessing, God caused the new topography to be uplifted showing the flood lain sediments on every continent, to every people in every dispensation of his almighty power.
And what has the cause of man declared? That there was no flood?
The testament is there. The flood did occur as the Bible states. The evidence is very very clear.
rob osborn
Rob,
You are just dead wrong.
The Grand Canyon is part of the Colorado Plateau.
The layers are not all flat across the region or even in the area of the Grand Canyon.
They very dramatically. Some are at angles. Some are parallel. Some are, the former sand dones, small humps. The reason for the variability is that the area has been deposited from multiple sources at multiple times and, on occasion eroded.
It wasn't one mountain range that created the deposits. It is multiple mountains that have done that job over many millions of years.
Again, the layers reflect, on the bottom, simple life. The upper layers are far more complex. But, most importantly, you never find more complex, more modern life on the lower levels. How could a single flood do that? It couldn't.
It is possible to find evidence of the same depositing process on the continental shelves and, even, in the deep ocean. It is not unusual to find sediments that are thousands of feet deep. But, the more modern deposits have more complex life.
The science is clear.
I believe the post started examining whether the biblical account could be interpreted as allowing for pre-Adamites. it can be demonstrated scientifically that humans predate the biblical Adam, using mt DNA studies for example. This has forced me to look for new interpretations of the scriptures, as I believe Jared attempts to do with his site. Truth is truth, no matter where it comes from. In some instances we need to forget what we used to teach as "doctrine" because that was based on ignorance. I don't blame the former prophets for that! We now have the tools and collective knowledge to build a new interpretation of man's history on this planet. I think Jared does a sterling job putting it all together. I admire the traditionalists, like Rob, who do their damnedest to hold onto the past. This blog is not going to resolve the argument. It needs to be presented in peer reviewed journals so that all aspects can be put on the table. Geology and localised events are only one contributor to the overall study.
"To sign off as a witness and yet also a blessing, God caused the new topography to be uplifted showing the flood lain sediments on every continent, to every people in every dispensation of his almighty power."
And while God was at he, he altered the laws of physics to make water droplets refract light, so that rainbows could testify of the covenant that he wouldn't do it again. Then he made Care Bears to slide down the rainbows and sprinkle fairy dust over the inhabitants of the earth so they could all be happy and gay for ever after.
I guess it all comes down to how one interprets the rocks.
For one thing, nowhere on earth at this present time is the earth being redeposited to form what we see has happened in the sedimentary layers in the GC. The sediments carried out in rivers into the ocean are not layering down sedimentary layers like we see in the GC- not even close in scale. One would think that if that is how the GC sediments fromed, we should see the same exact process happening today....only, that is anything but what we see. It is easy for a traditional geologist to say "oh ya, it is definately happening" just because a river carries sediments slowly out to sea. What they however can't explain is how a single layer hundreds of feet thick as found in the GC could have possibly spread out so thick and uniformly over hundreds of thousands of square miles. I can guarentee that no river slowly carring small deposits is going to redistribute itself that thick and uniform on the bottom of the ocean floor!
Like I said, no one can explain this geologic anomaly in any rational traditional geologic way. For them it is all fairytale sold at the tune of- "millions of years and anything will happen".
The problem with trying to reconcile all of mens understandings with the revealed word of God is that sooner or later, we either have to chalk up the majority of the scriptures to fairytale or chalk up the majority of men's understandings as fable and fairytale. As for me, I will trust in the God who gave me breath.
Moses has a grandson who divides the land with the gentiles, according to their languages, long before Babel.
So, at that point they are meeting strangers who do not speak their language.
Very clear, very much in the scriptures.
Above is some considerable misunderstanding of geologic process.
A couple messages above, the claim is made that there are not contemporary sediments of substantial depth.
Not true.
Worldwide, ocean sediment averages 400 meters deep. But, near deltas, that number jumps to kilometers deep.
The same processes that built the Colorado Plateau sediments are evident worldwide.
The bit of confusion is that the entire Plateau was not laid down at the same time. Parts were laid down at different times. That makes sense because different areas would have different deposition activities at different times.
Remember, the entire area was a series of layers of sediment, like much of the continental U.S. today. Then, they were raised up thousands of feet by tectonic and other forces. The canyon was then cut by erosional activity over the last few million years.
"Above is some considerable misunderstanding of geologic process."
I have a door knob at home that I have explained these processes to... it understands completely. I've been working on Rob for some time now... no such luck. =:)
One key evidence of the antiquity of the Grand Canyon is the different types of rock layers.
There are 40 different types of rock layers. Each represents a different type of depositation . . . deep ocean sediments, deltas, sand dunes, small rivers & streams onshore, etc. A full 40 different kinds. That, in and of itself, indicates great age.
Plus, there are 14 layers where deposits stopped. Often for great periods of time (one can tell because of big jumps in the fossil record, ie. from simple plants to complex life forms.
In addition, the rock layers don't always cover the entire region, often just parts.
The Grand Canyon contains some of the best studies rock formations on the planet. None of the scientists buy the idea it was laid down in one, massive event.
"None of the scientists buy the idea it was laid down in one, massive event."
You are attempting to reason with a man who gleefully eschews reason, logic, and science. Who has plugged his ears, stiffened his neck, and wears his child-like stubborn belligerence as a badge of honor. It's obvious Rob sees himself as the great "defender of the faith" in the midst of apostate "intellectuals" who fail to comprehend HIS literal interpretation of scripture as the only true path to authentic LDS-ness. Abandon all reason ye who enter herein. One suspects he has already packed up his magic chalk board and is on the bus with the one true prophet of the latter-days, headed for the promised land of Glennbeckistan, where climate change "alarmists" and Darwinists have already been dispatched by firing squad, to atone for the blood and sins of this generation.
Rich,
You are probably right . . . it is likely a hopeless exercise.
But, perhaps, a few facts will prevent others from absorbing the anti-scientist invective.
I think silence often gives these fringe views life. That is my theory why so many conspiracy theories circulate --- folks are afraid to confront them when they surface.
Wow, what a bunch of comments! I have to say that I would have expected them on my post from a couple of weeks ago.
Thanks for the geology lesson, Anon.
Rob,
You won't get any criticism from me about where you think you need to draw your line of faith. Just keep in mind that when you justify that line on scientific grounds, you open yourself to legitimate challenge.
Jared:
You're right, we need to get back to the original topic of pre-Adamites. For example, how do Hobbits fit into it all. :-)
(Sorry, I couldn't resist the reference. I'm fascinated by the semi-recent discovery, especially since I'm currently re-reading the book)
That wasn't a call to get back on topic. I was just expressing amusement.
I've always loved The Hobbit.
It's confusing to read these comments because "Anonymous" is actually several people. It would be helpful if people would use Name/URL instead of Anonymous and use a unique alias for the name.
Post a Comment