Playing Who's God?
You have probably heard by now that a method of obtaining stem cells that does not involve embryos looks promising. I think it's great, although it does not change what I think about the obstruction of embryonic stem cell research (I guess because I'm what's wrong with America). But stem cells are peripheral to this post.
The New York Times has an article on the influence of religion on people's worries about scientists "playing God." Here is the sum up:
Christians: God dispenses souls to humans, so don't mess with them. Do what you want to animals and plants, because (a) they don't have souls and/or (b) humans have been given dominion.
Western post-Christians: Not that worried about embryos, but don't screw up Mother Nature (eg. genetically modified crops).
Asian religions: There is no master plan for the universe, what matters is karma, and reincarnation happens. So, less objection to human, animal, and plant research.
These clashing perspectives produce friction.It is not so easy, though, to defend supposedly self-evident truths about human nature that are not evident to a large portion of humanity.

1 comments:
"...supposedly self-evident truths ...that are not evident to a large portion of humanity."
Oooo, I like that!
I was a bit confused by the article's conclusion about religion. A colored map of the world showing laws regarding cloning puts Spain, England, Belgium, and Sweden in the same category as India, China, Japan, and South Korea. Thus, I'm not convinced that there is a religious pattern.
Post a Comment