PBS NOVA: Judgement Day, ID on Trial
PBS NOVA will air a program on the Dover, PA court case from 2005 dealing with Intelligent Design in public schools. The program received a positive review in Nature. This case was a big loss for ID, and if you did not follow the case at the time, you should watch this program to see why. The program airs tomorrow--Tues, Nov 13--at 8 pm (check local listings to be sure), but will be available on the website for viewing as well.
Some ID proponents refused to participate. As the senior executive producer explains:
However, Michael Behe, Scott Minich, and other ID proponents affiliated with the Discovery Institute declined to be interviewed under the normal journalistic conditions that NOVA uses for all programs. In the midst of our discussions, we even offered to provide them with complete footage of the interviews, so that they could be reassured that nothing would be taken out of context. But they declined nonetheless.
In some sense, though, we do hear from both Behe and Minich in the program through our recreated trial scenes; the words that our actors speak are taken verbatim from the trial transcripts. And of course we hear directly in the program from lawyers for the defense—Richard Thompson, Patrick Gillen, and Robert Muise—as well as from Phillip Johnson, who is often credited as "the father of intelligent design." [italics added]

3 comments:
The ID side did not fare very well on the program, and the refusal of several proponents to participate in the show did not help.
Justin,
Thanks for checking in.
The program left out some choice bits, like when it became clear that the thorough peer review that Behe claimed for his book (Darwin's Black Box) actually amounted to, in one example, a 10 min discussion with the publisher about whether the book was a good idea.
I was actually kind of sad after watching it. The part where Bonsell talks about lying under oath---"I never thought that a one-minute statement..."---it made me sad that a man would go against his religion to defend his religion. I'm not condemning him---we are all sinners and live duplicitous lives---just feeling sorrow for his mistake.
I also thought the scientists missed driving home an important point: theories allow us to make predictions. For example, if tetrapods came from fish ~370 million yrs ago (or something like that), then we should find a transitional fossil in 370 million yr-old rock. And that's what was found. Prediction made, prediction accurate, theory validated. It was sort of in there, but not spelled out like it should have been.
Post a Comment