Opposition Bias or Lehi's Law
Confirmation bias is the tendency to seek confirmation of one's beliefs or ideas, and to ignore or not seek refuting evidence. For example, I have heard--although I don't know how common it is--that Emergency Room staff or police sometimes believe that a full moon = busy night (the lunar effect). Apparently most studies have failed to find an actual correlation, so why would someone think such a thing? The answer seems to be that once they are led to believe it is true, a person will tend to notice the chance correlation of a busy night with the full moon (or perhaps, nearly full), but fail to notice exceptions (ie. a slow night with a full-moon, or an equally or more busy night without a full moon). The same kind of principles can apply to racial stereotypes, or the ubiquitous invocation of "Murphy's Law" when an inconvenient problem arises.
I was reminded of this recently at church when someone said that good things in life are always opposed by problems/bad things. We have all heard such sentiments and supportive stories--such as cars breaking down on the way to the temple, etc--and 2 Nephi 2:11 is often cited for support.
First of all, I think that is a mistaken--if dominant--interpretation of scripture. But more to the point: Do we remember or account for all of the cars that made it to the temple without trouble, or the other times we made it to the temple without incident?
I do not dispute that good and evil struggle for domination, and that struggle may play out in ways I don't appreciate or understand. I do hypothesize that much of the invocation of what we might call "Lehi's Law" is actually confirmation bias.

5 comments:
Yep, I agree.
It's not just the ER that gets the crazies around full moon time. According to my girlfriend who's a non-ER nurse, they show up all over the hospital. One of her coworkers has started logging the incidents of crazy patients to see if the correlation is statistically significant.
Soren,
I would be interested to hear the results.
Jared,
I agree with the concept of confirmation bias. Though I have to disagree with your example from church.
Are you trying to suggest that he is using confirmation bias to prove 2 Ne 2:11 as a true scripture? If "Lehi's Law" is stating that without oppostition you would not recognize the good in life, as I think most people would interpret it (rather than a literal meaning that each good thing must be directly preceded/correlated with a bad thing), the refuting evidence would be that without any opposition we could still recognize the good. As far as I know, there is no evidence (possible or ignored) to suggest that without opposition we can still appreciate the good.
So, he can't be using confirmation bias because he isn't ignoring any refuting evidence and it is impossible to seek such evidence. He is merely giving supporting evidence that opposition in his life helped him appreciate the good.
Don't get me wrong, I think there are plenty of other examples, but there has to be an opposing hypothesis that can be tested or has existing data to be ignored.
Doug
Doug,
Nobody was using confirmation bias to prove anything. I thought someone was stating something that showed confirmation bias.
My point was that people sometimes use Lehi's Law to mean, as you state, "a literal meaning that each good thing must be directly preceded/correlated with a bad thing." (Usually they don't mean *every* little good thing.) I think that idea is a product of confirmation bias.
Post a Comment