The Buoyant Jaredites
I was recently reading the account of the Jaredites and their preparation to cross the sea, and came upon a passage that seems like a nice little case study in the intersection of scriptural interpretation and science. Most people probably pass right over it in their reading, and it doesn't have the mountain of commentary associated with other passages, so perhaps we can approach it with a little more objectivity.
The Jaredites were commanded to build barges which are described as "tight like unto a dish" and "light upon the water, even like unto the lightness of a fowl upon the water." From further description, they don't seem to be the kinds of barges we think of; they seem more like contained boats, similar to submarines. Later, during the discussion about how to light them, God says (Ether 2:24),
For behold, ye shall be as a whale in the midst of the sea; for the mountain waves shall dash upon you. Nevertheless, I will bring you up again out of the depths of the sea; for the winds have gone forth out of my mouth, and also the rains and the floods have I sent forth.Archimedes is given credit for having first articulated the principles of buoyancy, and today we would say it is just a result of density and gravity. If the weight of the volume of water displaced by an object is greater than the weight of the object, then the object will float. Or, more simply, if something is less dense than water, it will float--no divine intervention needed. Further, the barges were already described as light on the water, which suggests that they floated, plain and simple. Yet, here we have God speaking as though his direct intervention is needed to bring the barges back to the surface. So is this literal or figurative? On what basis should we decide?
If they notice the sentence at all, most people probably just consider it a figure of speech. Floating is an ordinary phenomenon that we observe on a regular basis, and the idea of submarines coming to the surface is familiar to us. Also, the second part of the sentence speaks of wind coming out of God's mouth, which is also taken to be figurative because (i) we understand the cause of wind and (ii) the picture of God blowing on the earth like a birthday cake just strikes us as silly. But we might imagine some zealous defender of scripture assuring us that God chooses his words carefully, says what he means, and that therefore his intervention really was needed to bring the barges back up. This defender might concede that the wind coming out of God's mouth is an obvious metaphor, but still insist that the first part is literal and challenge us to explain why God would take credit for something he didn't actually do.
The non-literal nature of the sentence might be explained by one or more of the following:
- God sometimes uses metaphors and figures of speech. He expects us to be smart enough to understand that. Get over it.
- God adapted his explanation to the level of Jaredite understanding. In ancient Near Eastern culture the sea was associated with chaos and monsters, and both the sea and the wind were ruled by gods. God adopted their cultural background in his communication with them.
- God didn't really say what is attributed to him. Ancient writers embellished the dialogue in a way that reflects ancient conceptions of the sea and wind. Revealed texts are not necessarily precise transcriptions of God's words.
- God simply meant that he would protect them and intervene if necessary.
The approach one takes to this verse is influenced by culture, experience, assumptions about God, prophets, and scripture, and some quick mental calculus to determine how the answer affects the integrity of these. Most of the decision probably occurs unconsciously and reflexively.
How one interprets this verse is probably inconsequential. However, if I am right in my guess that most people don't think that God literally had to pull those barges out of the water, then maybe this verse can be useful in discussions of scriptural literalism and science.
Continue reading...


