Thursday, November 11, 2010

The Buoyant Jaredites

I was recently reading the account of the Jaredites and their preparation to cross the sea, and came upon a passage that seems like a nice little case study in the intersection of scriptural interpretation and science. Most people probably pass right over it in their reading, and it doesn't have the mountain of commentary associated with other passages, so perhaps we can approach it with a little more objectivity.

The Jaredites were commanded to build barges which are described as "tight like unto a dish" and "light upon the water, even like unto the lightness of a fowl upon the water." From further description, they don't seem to be the kinds of barges we think of; they seem more like contained boats, similar to submarines. Later, during the discussion about how to light them, God says (Ether 2:24),

For behold, ye shall be as a whale in the midst of the sea; for the mountain waves shall dash upon you. Nevertheless, I will bring you up again out of the depths of the sea; for the winds have gone forth out of my mouth, and also the rains and the floods have I sent forth.
Archimedes is given credit for having first articulated the principles of buoyancy, and today we would say it is just a result of density and gravity. If the weight of the volume of water displaced by an object is greater than the weight of the object, then the object will float. Or, more simply, if something is less dense than water, it will float--no divine intervention needed. Further, the barges were already described as light on the water, which suggests that they floated, plain and simple. Yet, here we have God speaking as though his direct intervention is needed to bring the barges back to the surface. So is this literal or figurative? On what basis should we decide?

If they notice the sentence at all, most people probably just consider it a figure of speech. Floating is an ordinary phenomenon that we observe on a regular basis, and the idea of submarines coming to the surface is familiar to us. Also, the second part of the sentence speaks of wind coming out of God's mouth, which is also taken to be figurative because (i) we understand the cause of wind and (ii) the picture of God blowing on the earth like a birthday cake just strikes us as silly. But we might imagine some zealous defender of scripture assuring us that God chooses his words carefully, says what he means, and that therefore his intervention really was needed to bring the barges back up. This defender might concede that the wind coming out of God's mouth is an obvious metaphor, but still insist that the first part is literal and challenge us to explain why God would take credit for something he didn't actually do.

The non-literal nature of the sentence might be explained by one or more of the following:
  • God sometimes uses metaphors and figures of speech. He expects us to be smart enough to understand that. Get over it.

  • God adapted his explanation to the level of Jaredite understanding. In ancient Near Eastern culture the sea was associated with chaos and monsters, and both the sea and the wind were ruled by gods. God adopted their cultural background in his communication with them.

  • God didn't really say what is attributed to him. Ancient writers embellished the dialogue in a way that reflects ancient conceptions of the sea and wind. Revealed texts are not necessarily precise transcriptions of God's words.

  • God simply meant that he would protect them and intervene if necessary.

The approach one takes to this verse is influenced by culture, experience, assumptions about God, prophets, and scripture, and some quick mental calculus to determine how the answer affects the integrity of these. Most of the decision probably occurs unconsciously and reflexively.

How one interprets this verse is probably inconsequential. However, if I am right in my guess that most people don't think that God literally had to pull those barges out of the water, then maybe this verse can be useful in discussions of scriptural literalism and science.


Continue reading...

Wednesday, November 03, 2010

Steve's Primordial Soup: Teleology

[This post is a continuation of a discussion (begun here) of Crawling Out of the Primordial Soup: A Step toward the Emergence of an LDS Theology Compatible with Organic Evolution" (PDF), by BYU biologist Steven Peck.]

That God created some features of the earth and life upon it through acts of direct intervention cannot be disproved. We have such limited information relative to the size and age of the planet that we cannot definitively exclude God's intervention. However, as scientists have come to understand the composition of this earth, life upon it, and the processes that occur in both, the apparent need for God's intervention has diminished, and positive evidence for such has not been forthcoming (Intelligent Design notwithstanding). Further, the picture we get from natural history differs markedly from the picture painted by Genesis. These considerations have led many to conclude that God's direct influence on the character of this planet has been minor, if such influence exists at all. However, if God's direct intervention has been minimal, how is he able to achieve his purposes?

Steve speculatively suggests that God acts in the physical world by communicating with the minds of conscious beings, who carry out the physical work.

When I read the scriptures, I see a God who makes arrangements for irreplaceable records to be kept, preserved, and maintained through conscious effort. He implies that, if they are not, this knowledge will be lost and not brought back through His intervention. I see the Lamanites languishing in unbelief until the sons of Mosiah are inspired to go among them. Angels bear messages to other consciousnesses but do not seem to manipulate the world in interventionist ways. Almost all of the scriptures can be reinterpreted as acts of consciousness acting in the world.
This view of God's actions seems consistent with President Spencer W. Kimball's statement that, "God does notice us, and he watches over us. But it is usually through another person that he meets our needs." It also complements the view expressed by Hugh Nibley that most miracles are simply a matter of timing. In this view, God anticipates natural events and directs his prophets in a way that capitalizes on the circumstances. It is a view of miracles that appeals to the rational part of me.

However, although Steve acknowledges that the miracles of Jesus seem to be an exception, when I read the scriptures I also see disciples who cannot be kept in prison, prophets who can initiate and end drought, people who are healed from disease, and men who stand in a furnace but remain unharmed. It may be true that God generally acts through consciousness-mediated action (in order, I suppose, to maximize the use of personal agency), and I am not suggesting that every miracle should be taken at face value, but the apparent exceptions keep the underlying questions alive. And surely God has access to technology at least as advanced as ours!

Some of the difficulty may yet again lie in our own narrow perspective of what God's purposes are, and our limited understanding of the possibilities inherent in the universe. God may simply find it generally unnecessary to intervene, and here we again return to the issue of efficiency and Nibley's reminder that God can have multiple purposes. After all, who can look at the way the plan of salvation has been implemented in this world and claim to see a model of efficiency? It may be that processes are just as much a part of God's purposes as final goals--the journey as much as the destination. Or perhaps God values different efficiencies than we do.

My criticism of Steve's idea should not be taken to mean that I think it is false or worthless. On the contrary, I think that in many cases it is probably correct and is worth further consideration. However, although I am willing to believe that God has limitations, I am skeptical of attempts to pinpoint what they are. Rather than serving as an absolute explanation, I view Steve's proposal as one line of reasoning that is potentially useful in grappling with these kinds of questions.



Continue reading...

Monday, November 01, 2010

Amber Fossils, T. Rex, and YECs


A collection of 50 million-year-old amber fossils from India were in the news last week (see here). Resin secreted by certain plants can trap and preserve insects, microorganisms, plants, and even (rarely) small vertebrates. Some of these amber fossils have survived hundreds of millions of years.

Seeing these amber fossils reminded me of something I had been thinking about regarding how young earth creationists view science. For them, the earth is about 6,000 years old and everything must be interpreted in that light. They claim that they and scientists share the same facts, but simply differ in interpretation. This strategy is especially effective for scientific findings that superficially support their view.

A perfect example of such a finding was published in 2005 in the journal Science. Paleontologist Mary Schweitzer described the recovery of soft tissue from the femur of a fossilized Tyranosaurus rex. This was a surprising finding that the atheist conspiracy failed to suppress, since the fossil was 65 million years old. Moreover, they were later able to recover and sequence some fragments of collagen protein (not DNA). Nobody knew that such preservation was possible, which is why YECs have had a field day with it. They argue that such preservation isn't possible, which is why this finding supports a young earth. They emphasize how delicate biological molecules are and how quick and pervasive decay processes are. Any other interpretation is just evidence of an unwillingness to face the plain facts. In contrast, mainstream scientists consider the age of T. rex to be pretty solid, supported by an array of evidence. To them, the remarkable preservation of the tissue represents nature teaching us that such preservation is possible under the right conditions, even if unexpected.

Same facts, different interpretation, right?

If Schweitzer had simply cracked open the bone and found soft tissue, we might have a legitimate problem. However, putting it in such simple terms distorts reality. There is a whole discipline of science that studies how fossils are formed, called taphonomy, and there are several types of preservation. Some of these involve replacement of minerals or the infusion of minerals into empty spaces. In the case of T. rex, although the precise mechanism of the preservation is not yet known, minerals obviously played an important role in preventing decay because the tissues had to go through an extensive demineralization process in the laboratory. So although the preservation was unexpected and is not fully understood, it isn't totally detached from prior understanding, either [1]. When considered in the context of all of the supporting evidence for the ancient age of the fossil, it is more parsimonious to conclude that such preservation can occur, rather than that it can't and that all of the supporting evidence is wrong too.

This brings me back to the amber fossils. YECs certainly do not believe that such fossils are millions of years old, but as far as I have seen they don't argue their case on the basis of preservation--that it is impossible--like they have done with T. rex. There seems to be an implied admission that if amber fossils actually were ancient, the degree of preservation would still be believable. It seems, then, that their objection is not to preservation per se. Further, they argue that fossilization can take place rapidly, which undercuts their argument that the T. rex preservation is impossible.

So what about DNA--can it be recovered from amber fossils? It depends on the age. A 2005 review article I found does a nice job of explaining the difficulties of working with ancient DNA [2]. Over the last couple of decades there have been a handful of studies that have claimed to recover DNA from samples tens of million years old, some of them from amber fossils. However, according to the authors there is a theoretical/empirical limit of DNA survival on Earth of about one million years, and in each of these cases the results either could not be replicated or were found to be from contaminants. Their Figure 2 summarizes many of the ancient DNA publications over the last couple of decades. (Click to enlarge. Note that the Y axis is actually log scale.)



The YEC view of the earth is compressed enough to fit well within the theoretical limits of DNA preservation. If scientists can get DNA from a mammoth and Neanderthal, they should also be able to get it from a dinosaur--or certainly a comparably aged amber fossil--without much more trouble. We wouldn't want to say that scientists will never recover such DNA because, just as in the case with T. rex, the possibilities in nature can surprise us. Indeed, subsequent to this review article there have been additional claims of DNA recovery from amber fossils older than the theoretical limit, though the reliability of these reports remains to be determined. However, given that deep time inversely correlates with the technical feasibility of recovering ancient DNA, YECs need to explain the disparity in DNA recovery if deep time is actually an illusion.

They have creative minds. I'm sure they will think of something.



Notes:
(Both articles are freely available.)

1. Mary Schweitzer et al., Soft tissue and cellular preservation in vertebrate skeletal elements from the Cretaceous to the present, Proc. R. Soc. B 22 January 2007 vol. 274 no. 1607 183-197.

2. Eske Willerslev and Alan Cooper, Ancient DNA, Proc. R. Soc. B 7 January 2005 vol. 272 no. 1558 3-16.


Continue reading...

Wednesday, October 27, 2010

An Agent of Misery Dies a Quiet Death

In case you missed it--and you probably did--Rinderpest virus has been eradicated. Rinderpest is a disease of cattle that is extremely deadly--killing upwards of 90% of infected animals. It is closely related to--and thought to be the origin of--Measles virus. If it wasn't one of biblical plagues, it certainly could have been. As explained by the New York Times (Virus Deadly in Livestock Is No More, U.N. Declares),

Rinderpest is thought to have originated in Asia and spread through prehistoric cattle trading; it was in Egypt 5,000 years ago. It never became established in the Americas (though there was a small outbreak in Brazil 90 years ago), nor in Australia or New Zealand. Cattle infected with it would have started dying aboard ship and the herd would be slaughtered or quarantined on arrival.

But it reached Africa in the late 19th century, with devastating consequences. The near total destruction of herds meant widespread famines; in one of those, a third of the population of Ethiopia died, according to the Food and Agricultural Organization.

It was apparently introduced to Abyssinia, which is now Ethiopia, in cattle from India imported by the Italians during their campaign to conquer Abyssinia, said Dr. Jeffrey M.B. Musser, a rinderpest expert at Texas A&M’s veterinary school. Some experts believe it was deliberate, as a form of biological warfare, he said, while others contend that it was accidental.
As a result of a sustained international vaccination campaign, rinderpest has not been detected in the field since 2001. Field surveillance will now cease and the eradication officially declared complete later this spring. This is only the second virus to be eradicated from the earth--aside from remaining frozen laboratory stocks--the first being smallpox.

Thank you, science!


Continue reading...

Tuesday, October 19, 2010

Steve's Primordial Soup: Natural Evil

[This post is a continuation of a discussion (begun here) of Crawling Out of the Primordial Soup: A Step toward the Emergence of an LDS Theology Compatible with Organic Evolution" (PDF), by BYU biologist Steven Peck.]

If God used evolution as a method of creation, then we are faced with questions of natural evil. Why would a kind and loving God use such an inefficient and wasteful process, with all of the attendant pain and suffering, in order to produce humans? Why wouldn't he use a more direct method? Drawing on an essay by David Paulsen (Joseph Smith and the Problem of Evil), Steve suggests that for some unknown reason, natural selection is a necessary natural law. He then proposes that a spirit is required for conscious thought and that the Fall of Adam and Eve marked the embodiment of spirits. Life forms before the Fall were not conscious beings, and therefore did not experience pain.

Perhaps they cannot be fully divorced, but I think it would be useful to consider pain and inefficiency separately. First, I will focus on pain. I do not wish to minimize the pain experienced by the Earth's inhabitants, but I also do not think it should be inflated, either. As far as we can determine, physical pain requires a nervous system and brain of a certain level of complexity. I doubt that we can draw distinct lines, and the ability to feel pain may come in degrees, but I think we can safely rule out the perception of pain in plants and simple animals, for example.

The same kind of issues apply to emotional pain. And, in fact, there is feedback between our emotions and our perception of physical pain. So if we are going to ask how a loving God could use a process involving so much pain, we should recognize that many life forms apparently do not feel physical and/or emotional pain. Further, it should be made clear that natural selection is not a process that adds pain to mortal life. It is simply the outcome of differential survival and reproduction of offspring. It is a result of mortal conditions, not an additional cause.

Whatever the merits of the above, does rejecting evolution solve the problem? For the sake of argument, let's suppose that evolution is all wrong and that pain and death entered the world through the Fall about 6,000 years ago. In his book, River Out of Eden, Richard Dawkins wrote this memorable passage:

The total amount of suffering per year in the natural world is beyond all decent contemplation. During the minute it takes me to compose this sentence, thousands of animals are being eaten alive; others are running for their lives, whimpering with fear; others are being slowly devoured from within by rasping parasites; thousands of all kinds are dying of starvation, thirst and disease.
All of that in a minute. Multiply that by the 6,000 years of the Ussher time line, and then multiply that by whatever number of mortal inhabited worlds exist in this universe. If mortal conditions are a necessary part of God's plan in "one eternal round," then we are still faced with vast amounts of pain and suffering (if such things can be quantified). Can we suppose that the creatures of this (or any) earth suffer the absolute minimum amount needed to fulfill God's plan, and no more? Further, under this scenario God is the creator of the many methods animals have for inflicting pain, and for the sensory systems needed to feel it in the first place. It is hard for me to see how evolution poses any significant problems for the nature of evil that are not already contained, and sometimes magnified, in traditional creationism viewed through a Mormon lens.

All of this forms part of the reason why I am not a fan of Steve's proposal that pain did not exist in the world until the Fall brought consciousness to Earth's life forms, though I appreciate his creative thinking. Not only does it seem to me like a theological just-so story invented to explain away the uncomfortable, it ultimately leaves the problem of suffering in place since the process is presumably endlessly repeated. As Steve notes, it also deprives any pre-existing humans, such as Neanderthals (or even other Homo sapiens), of consciousness in spite of the fact that they "had religious practices, created art, and made intricate tools." It just isn't clear to me that this idea gains us much, never mind the question of whether it's true.

At the same time, Steve's thoughts about a participatory fall are similar to my own. Whatever the historical truth behind Adam, Eve, and the Fall, the rest of us apparently fall simply by being born, which, we are taught, is the means by which our spirit leaves the presence of God and is joined to this mortal existence. We are also taught that we agreed to this. I don't know why suffering must be such an integral part of this world, but I take some comfort that for any individual organism, suffering is temporary and finite, and will ultimately be recompensed.

Finally, let's briefly return to the issue of inefficiency. Why use such a long process to produce humans when humans are the goal? On the one hand, we can posit that such long periods are nothing to God, and anyway this is a slippery slope because we can always imagine how things could be more efficient and wonder why God would let it be otherwise. On the other hand, perhaps it is fallacious to assume that the existence of humans is the only important goal. This sentiment was expressed by Hugh Nibley ("The Geological Problem" in Ancient Documents and the Pearl of Great Price):
John Chrysostom said that the sole purpose of the stars was to guide sailors at sea. There's no other purpose; therefore, why should there be life on other worlds? The stars have fulfilled their purpose if they just guide sailors at sea. Well, they do guide sailors at sea, but is that their only purpose? This is the thing we have to keep in mind here. So never forget this pluralism, this multiple use of the earth. It's not made for us alone. We are allowed to share it with God's other creatures, and we are told in the seventy-seventh chapter of the Doctrine and Covenants that other creatures have just as much right to the earth as we have. Not only that, but they have spirits and will be resurrected in their own world in their own time. We mustn't interfere with them in their proper places.
None of this really solves the basic question as to why God would use evolution. We may never be able to give a fully satisfactory answer, but the evidence is that he did, and I think it is important that we continue to engage with the question. I appreciate Steve's attempt to do so, even if I'm not convinced that he has uncovered the answer.



Continue reading...

Wednesday, October 13, 2010

Church Radio Deals Dose of Skepticism

A recent episode of "Legacy," a production of the Church's radio channel, featured a discussion of some prominent Mormon myths and urban legends by several members of the Historical Department. They discussed some of the reasons these myths survive (people want to feel part of something momentous, the stories vindicate belief, etc.) and urged people to be more skeptical about such circulating stories. I thought it made for a nice lesson in critical thinking. The fact that it came from people in the Church's Historical Department on a Church-sponsored program was an added bonus!

Below I summarize the myths covered in the hour-long program. Several of these myths were new to me, and a few of them were still categorized as true in my mind.


1. False: On 9/11 a missionary zone conference at the World Trade Center was miraculously cancelled.

Truth: No such zone conference existed.

2. False: The Mormon Battalion made the longest march in history.

Truth: Myth can be attributed to a hyperbolic statement by one of the leaders.

3. False: Those involved in the murder of Joseph Smith met terrible fates.

Truth: Most of them went on to lead normal and successful lives.

4. False: Brigham Young directed that large shafts be incorporated into the Salt Lake temple. Later, they were found to be just the right size for elevators.

Truth: The interior of the temple was designed after Brigham Young was dead. Although the design did include such shafts, that was because they were specifically intended for elevators.

5. False: According to a Church leader (usually Boyd K. Packer), today's youth were generals in war in heaven, and will be treated with hushed awe for having living during the presidency of Gordon B. Hinckley.

Truth: The Church has specifically repudiated this rumor.

6. False: Members of the Mormon Battalion discovered gold in California, initiating the gold rush.

Truth: Although some former members of the Battalion were present, they were not the discoverers.

7. False: John Taylor's pocket watch saved his life by stopping a bullet.

Truth: Although the watch was damaged and John Taylor thought it had stopped a bullet, the damage is not consistent with a bullet.

8. False: Angry about polygamy, Emma Smith pushed Eliza R. Snow down the stairs.

Truth: The story originated in an anti-Mormon publication and appears to conflate two separate stories.

9. False: Women in Kirtland ground up their fine china to help decorate the walls of the Kirtland Temple.

Truth: Broken dishes and cookware (i.e. garbage) were collected and recycled for decorative use.

10. False: A Japaneese bomber in WWII tried to bomb the temple in Hawaii, but the bomb would not release. He later found out what the temple was, joined the Church, and eventually became a General Authority.

Truth: Neither of the two Japaneese members who have been General Authorities were bombers for the Japaneese army. One was from Hawaii and fought for the U.S. and the other was a child at the time. The origin of the story cannot otherwise be determined.

11. False: Brigham Young wanted the tower of the St. George temple changed, but the residents of St. George refused. After Brigham Young died, lighting struck the tower and it burned down and had to be replaced. Thus, Brigham got his way.

Truth: The origin of this story was a joke told at a fireside. Brigham didn't like the construction of the tower, but did not demand a change. If he had, there is every reason to believe the builders in St. George would have complied. However, the tower was struck by lighting and eventually replaced.

12. False: The White Horse Prophecy

Truth: Joseph F. Smith and other leaders specifically repudiated this alleged prophecy of Joseph Smith.

13. Pioneers were building a meeting house, but didn't know how to build the roof. An immigrant shipbuilder advised them how to build the roof by using plans for a ship and turning them upside down.

Truth: There were plenty of skilled carpenters and written resources on how to build roofs.

If this one sounds familiar, it is probably because Elder L. Tom Perry told essentially the same story about the building of the Manti temple in the October 2009 General Conference. One possible source for Elder Perry's story is the book, Before Zion: An Account of the 7th Handcart Company, which attributes the story to Sanpete County tradition. Although this particular version of the story was not specifically addressed in the program, the general discussion casts doubt on it. Further, the architect for the Manti temple was William H. Folsom, who had worked closely with Truman O. Angell (both men served for a time as Church Architect) and had also served as the architect for the Tabernacle, as well as other significant projects. The idea that he would farm out the design of the temple roof to a group of people who didn't know anything about building roofs seems highly doubtful on its face.

14. False: Most of the pioneers pushed handcarts.

Truth: Although the handcart has become an icon symbolizing the pioneer trek west, only a fraction of the pioneers came in handcart companies. Further, although trek re-enactments by youth throughout the Church often have a point were the boys are taken away for the Mormon Battalian, leaving the girls to push handcarts by themselves, there is no historical connection between the Mormon Battalion and the handcart companies. The Mormon Battalion was formed 10 years before the handcart pioneers crossed the plains. It is recommended that leaders inform trek re-enactment participants that their experience is based on a composite of pioneer history.


(H/T, BCC.)


Continue reading...

Monday, October 11, 2010

Abraham's Allegorical Astronomy

Several years ago I highlighted three chapters from the FARMS book, Astronomy, Papyrus, and Covenant. One of the chapters, "'And I Saw the Stars': The Book of Abraham and Ancient Geocentric Astronomy," by John Gee, William J. Hamblin, Daniel C. Peterson, argues that the Book of Abraham (specifically, chapter 3) is best read in the context of a geocentric astronomy. I've felt that this chapter is an important example of putting scripture into an ancient context that does not fit with modern science, and it is done so by LDS scholars of unquestioned faith.

This week I came across an article that takes this a step further. In his 2009 article, Encircling Astronomy and the Egyptians: An Approach to Abraham 3, BYU Associate Professor of Ancient Scripture and Egyptologist, Kerry Muhlestein, argues that the astronomical paradigm is irrelevant to the meaning of the Book of Abraham.

I think we stumble when we attempt to understand Abraham’s vision in terms of astronomic paradigms. It is quite likely that the Lord was describing astronomy and the heavens allegorically in order to teach doctrinal, not astronomical, principles. While attempting to understand astronomical principles has merit...and while there may be an understandable cosmic paradigm to be teased out of the narrative, it seems that the allegorical teachings are the weightier matters as far as the gospel classroom is concerned.
Muhlestein goes on to explain the importance of the planets and stars to the Egyptians and how, in chapter 3, God was preparing Abraham to be able to teach the Egyptians using astronomy as basis for communication.

I was slightly surprised to find that this thesis--a rejection of scriptural literalism and concordism--was published by the Religious Studies Center, an arm of the BYU Religion Department. Good on them. As I have noted on several occasions, other Christians have been taking this basic approach with the creation scriptures for a while now. I know of only a couple of attempts by LDS authors to do similarly, but most Church members would probably consider them unorthodox at best.

Muhlestein's article gives me hope that what's good for Abraham chapter 3 will also be good for chapters 4 and 5.


Continue reading...

Wednesday, October 06, 2010

Steve's Primordial Soup: An Embodied God

[This post is a continuation of a discussion (begun here) of Crawling Out of the Primordial Soup: A Step toward the Emergence of an LDS Theology Compatible with Organic Evolution" (PDF), by BYU biologist Steven Peck.]

One of our most distinctive doctrines is that God the Father has a tangible body of flesh and bone, in the form of a man. To say that man was created in God's image has literal meaning in Mormonism. The conflict with evolution on this point seems acute. After all, chance and contingency play a large role in evolution. That evolution produced us, who look like God, seems beyond coincidence. It is as if we were told that the official language of heaven has always been King James English. How can this be explained except by direct intervention? My favorite part of Steve's paper is his brief exploration of this issue. Below I summarize his discussion and extend it a little bit.

The coincidence of our physical likeness may be more likely than we might think. As Steve explains, this might be an example of convergent evolution. Given similar environmental constraints, the laws of physics, etc, it is not uncommon for independent lineages to produce similar forms. (Think of fish and dolphins.)

Another way to think about this is to ask the question, if we were to make contact with aliens, what are the chances that they would look like us--more or less? In his column in Scientific American, Michael Shermer expressed doubt that aliens would look like us. However, he quoted correspondence with Richard Dawkins as follows:

I would agree with [Shermer] in betting against aliens being bipedal primates, and I think the point is worth making, but I think he greatly overestimates the odds against. [University of Cambridge paleontologist] Simon Conway Morris, whose authority is not to be dismissed, thinks it positively likely that aliens would be, in effect, bipedal primates.
Dawkins went on to position himself between Simon Conway Morris and Michael Shermer. Simon Conway Morris is a well-known paleontologist who is also a Christian, and his views on convergent evolution have been criticized as serving the purpose of reconciling science with his faith. Nevertheless, in addition to the fossil record, the quote from Dawkins shows that there is a secular case to be made for such a convergence.

Now let's look at the other side of the equation--God's body. At first appearance, this would seem to be a non-negotiable topic. However, at this point Steve draws on an interesting paper, Divine Embodiment and Transcendence: Propaedeutic Thoughts and Questions, by BYU philosopher, and Richard L. Evans Chair of Religious Understanding, James E. Faulconer. Faulconer writes:
The bodies of flesh and bone with which I am familiar do not shine, have blood, cannot hover, can be wounded and die, must move through contiguous points of time-space--in short, they are not at all like the bodies of the Father and the Son. So what does it mean to say that the Father and the Son have bodies? In fact, does it mean anything at all? When I use the word body in any other context, I never refer to something that shines, can hover, is immortal, and moves through space seemingly without being troubled by walls and doors. Given the vast difference between what we mean by the word body in every other case and that to which the word refers in this case, one can legitimately ask whether the word body has the same meaning in this case that it has in the others.
Further, in a passage not quoted by Steve, Faulconer makes this intriguing statement:
I believe that, rather than a positive statement of doctrine, the earliest latter-day discussion of divine embodiment is best understood as a rejection of traditional Christian doctrine concerning God and the metaphysics that makes that doctrine possible and perhaps even necessary. Joseph Smith's most clear statement of God's embodiment comes as part of a denial of Nicean trinitarianism: "That which is without body, parts and passions is nothing. There is no other God in heaven but that God who has flesh and bones" (Teachings 181).
Fauloner's statement has indirect support in history. Joseph is commonly said to have learned of God's corporeal body from the First Vision in 1820. However, the historical record suggests otherwise. Although the exact time line is debated, in the words of Richard Bushman [1],
Joseph's concern about nothingness can also be seen in his views of God. By 1841, he had moved from a traditional Christian belief in God as pure spirit to a belief in His corporeality.
Faulconer notes that we cannot help but imagine what God's body is like by extrapolating from our own experience. Given how little has actually been revealed, it seems to me that it is easy to fill in our ignorance with inference and analogy.

To summarize, the correspondence between the human body and God's body may be a matter of convergence. However, we don't really know much about how God's body works, its properties, or its history. We may therefore be artificially narrowing the parameters of correspondence, making the problem of evolution seem more acute than it actually is.

Notes:

1. Richard Bushman, Joseph Smith: Rough Stone Rolling, p. 420. For more information on the development of the doctrine of the Godhead, see Thomas G. Alexander, "The Reconstruction of Mormon Doctrine (PDF)" and James B. Allen, "Emergence of a Fundamental: The Expanding Role of Joseph Smith's First Vision in Mormon Religious Thought." For an alternate view, see Robert L. Millet, "Joseph Smith and Modern Mormonism: Orthodoxy, Neoorthodoxy, Tension, and Tradition" as well as Thomas Alexander's response, "Afterwords."



Continue reading...

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP