Thursday, July 08, 2010

The First Man

[This is part of a series of posts I initiated with Book of Mormon Scholarship as an Elias for Evolution.]

It's time to wrap up this series. Any attempt within LDS circles to accommodate human history as revealed by science must sooner or later deal with the following fact: the scriptures refer to Adam as the 'first man' several times. In my opinion the most important one is the one most often quoted--Moses 3:7--so we will concentrate on it.

Moses 3:6-8

6 But I, the Lord God, spake, and there went up a mist from the earth, and watered the whole face of the ground.

7 And I, the Lord God, formed man from the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living soul, the first flesh upon the earth, the first man also; nevertheless, all things were before created; but spiritually were they created and made according to my word.

8 And I, the Lord God, planted a garden eastward in Eden, and there I put the man whom I had formed.
The first thing to notice is the strange choice of wording. The reference to 'man' is rather generic. God "formed man," and "man became a living soul, "the first man." Why doesn't it use the name of Adam, or refer to the man, as it does in the next verse? This oddity may or may not have any relevance to the overall discussion, but it is worth noting.

One other thing should be noted up front. This passage from the Book of Moses comes from Joseph Smith's revision of the Bible--the 'Joseph Smith Translation' (JST). Although some parts of the JST are entirely original material, it is clear that this passage is grounded in the Biblical (KJV) text. I don't think it out of bounds to suggest that this passage may reflect Joseph's understanding based on Biblical tradition more than the actual words of God. In Joseph's day, it was obvious that Adam was the 'first man,' so it seems unlikely that this passage was intended to bear such theological weight as it has now come to. However, many people would undoubtedly reject this idea, and I'm not ready to defend it, so I won't press it further.

One popular way of dealing with this passage is to play with the meaning of the word 'man.' The usual argument is that although there were many anatomically modern humans on the planet, the first 'man' was the one into whom God put a spirit that was one of his spirit children. I don't like this argument and I don't think it really solves any problems. In fact I think it actually creates potential for racism. I mention it simply because it is popular.

Alternatively, we can focus on the meaning of the word 'first.' Sterling Talmage, son of Apostle James E. Talmage, argued as follows [1]:
Such use of "first," as indicating preeminence instead of chronological precedence, is well established as an acceptable idiom in other languages as well as English. This usage does not lack other scriptural warrant; for instance, the firstling of the flocks, demanded for the Mosaic sacrifices, were the finest of the lambs not the oldest of the rams.

With this thought in mind, it has always seemed to me that the expression quoted, designating Adam as the "first flesh upon the earth, the first man also," was simply the fulfillment of the fiat in the preceding chapter regarding the preeminence of man among created beings: "Let them have dominion over the fishes of the sea, and over the fowl of the air, and over the cattle, and over all the earth."
Talmage's argument has real-world support. In a post from a couple of years ago I pointed out that someone once referred to Galielo as "the first man in the world," something that may sound strange to our ears but clearly did not denote chronology. I also suggested that Henry Eyring seemed to have an alternative meaning in mind when he wrote, "Adam was the one whom God recognized as presiding over the first dispensation and as such, with Eve his wife, became our first parents."

On the other hand, a lineage history has to start with someone, and that someone would necessarily be the chronologically first person in the story. It seems clear that the prophets of the scriptures really did think Adam and Eve were the first people (chronologically) on Earth. What reason would they--or Joseph Smith, for that matter--have to think otherwise? None, unless God told them so.

This brings us to a third option--that the creation scriptures serve a purpose other than science and history. The statement that 'man' became "the first flesh upon the earth, the first man also," comes in the midst of a largely figurative story, and within the confines of the story it makes perfect sense. It was only following scientific discoveries, and in retrospect, that the statement and its meaning became significant. But what if God did not intend the statement to be universally definitive? What if his purpose was more literary, helping to tell a story sufficient for the Israelites' needs (such as explaining what made them and their God superior to the surrounding empires)? I'm reminded of the words of Aslan in The Horse and His Boy, by C.S. Lewis.
"Child," said the Voice, "I am telling you your story, not hers. I tell no one any story but his own."
Returning to the figurative nature of the story, the very same verse says that God "formed man from the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life," something that even Joseph Fielding Smith and Bruce R. McConkie did not take literally [2]. It seems fair to question whether such micro-dissection of the text--dividing a single verse between literal and figurative--is warranted.

To summarize the argument sketched out in this series of posts: Just as science has required us to re-evaluate the popular understanding of the scope of the Book of Mormon, it also requires us to re-evaluate the place of Adam and Eve in human history. As far as we know, Adam was the first prophet and holder of the priesthood. The story of Adam and Eve and their descendants is a lineage history. As such, it ignores those who lived before or contemporaneously with Adam because, as far as the gospel (and Israelite superiority) is concerned, the story begins with him. Scriptures that indicate that Adam and Eve were the first humans can often be interpreted in alternative ways that are still consistent with scripture. Others can be attributed to the cultural context of the writers. Further, the early chapters of Genesis/Moses contain occasional odd elements that may hint at the presence of outsiders.

I enjoyed writing this series. I hope it was enjoyable to read and found to be useful.

Notes:

1. Sterling Talmage, Can Science Be Faith-Promoting?, p. 168-169
2. The meaning of 'first flesh' is also problematic, something I will take up in a post outside of this series.



Continue reading...

Saturday, July 03, 2010

The Family of Adam

[This is part of a series of posts I initiated with Book of Mormon Scholarship as an Elias for Evolution.]

The phrase 'family of Adam' occurs in the scriptures exclusively in the Book of Mormon, where it is used twice as a reference to all people. For example:

Mormon 3:20

And for this cause I write unto you, that ye may know that ye must all stand before the judgment–seat of Christ, yea, every soul who belongs to the whole human family of Adam.
Before moving on, let's pause and consider the aboriginal inhabitants of the island of Tasmania. Archaeologists place the first inhabitants of the island at no later than 35,000 years ago. Except for back then it was not an island; it was a piece of Australia. Then around 10,000 years ago at the end of the last Ice Age, sea levels rose and cut off Tasmania from Australia. With no evidence of seafaring technology, it appears that the Tasmanian Aborigines were isolated from all other people until the arrival of European explorers. This scenario places some difficult constraints on the timing and placing of Adam if the Tasmanian Aborigines are literal descendants of Adam.

However, there is more than one way to become the family of a prophet. Two examples from scriptures should suffice to make the point.

D&C 84:33-34
For whoso is faithful unto the obtaining these two priesthoods of which I have spoken, and the magnifying their calling, are sanctified by the Spirit unto the renewing of their bodies. They become the sons of Moses and of Aaron and the seed of Abraham, and the church and kingdom, and the elect of God.
Mosiah 5:7
And now, because of the covenant which ye have made ye shall be called the children of Christ, his sons, and his daughters; for behold, this day he hath spiritually begotten you; for ye say that your hearts are changed through faith on his name; therefore, ye are born of him and have become his sons and his daughters.
Familial relationships in the scriptures clearly extend beyond literal lineal ancestor-descendant relationships, and in the early years of the Church it was not uncommon for otherwise unrelated people to be sealed to Church leaders in order to be linked in kinship. In the two scriptural examples above the relationship is established by covenant. However, when it comes to being the family of Adam and Eve, no covenants are needed since all people are their family by default. We might say that just as anybody who is redeemed from sin by Jesus becomes his seed, anybody who needs redeeming is considered the seed (or family) of Adam and Eve.

Of course all humans are ultimately related to each other anyway, making all of them the 'family of Adam.' Rather than viewing the whole human family as a tree descending from Adam and Eve, it might be better to think of it as a network or web of relationships that extends forward and backward in time, with Adam and Eve presiding over all. However, viewing the family of Adam in this way naturally raises the question of how far back this linking could extend. This concern was expressed by President Boyd K. Packer:
The sealing authority with its binding of the generations into eternal families cannot admit to ancestral blood lines to beasts. Let me repeat: An understanding of the sealing authority with its binding of the generations into eternal families cannot admit to ancestral blood lines to beasts.
This objection can be answered in at least two ways. The first is unsatisfying but true: There are many areas of life and religion where black and white rules are applied to gray situations. We ultimately trust God to determine where to draw the line. Second, on the other hand, perhaps God doesn't need to draw a line because it is a matter of self-selection. The binding of families together is associated with the making of covenants. As we look at humanity extending into the ancient past in a post-mortal context, it may be that there comes a point where people (or whatever) have no interest in entering such covenants and a natural (if fuzzy) line of demarcation emerges.

In this view, whether or not the pre-1800 Tasmanian Aborigines (or any of us) are literally descended from Adam and Eve makes no difference. By virtue of being human we are all the 'family of Adam,' and God's invitation is open to all who will accept it, either in this life or the next. The point here is not to claim that any of this represents a definitive answer to the issues raised. Rather, it is to suggest that the scriptures themselves provide some of the flexibility needed for an alternative interpretation of the place of Adam and Eve in history that is consistent with science.


Continue reading...

Thursday, July 01, 2010

Penn State Clears Michael Mann of Any Wrongdoing

The Penn State investigation of climatologist Michael Mann--of 'hockey stick' fame--is over. After having already partially cleared him, the Investigatory Committee has unanimously cleared Dr. Mann of any wrongdoing.







Continue reading...

Friday, June 25, 2010

Amazongate-gate

On the heels of 'Climategate' came the revelation that buried in the 2007 IPCC report was an erroneous statement to the effect that Himalayan glaciers could disappear by 2035. This was dubbed 'glaciergate,' and was a ding in the credibility of the IPCC. Then came the allegation that the IPCC report also contained a fabricated claim that "up to 40% of the Amazonian forests could react drastically to even a slight reduction in precipitation." This was predictably dubbed 'Amazongate.'

The British newspaper the Sunday Times picked up on this and published a story that said that the 40% claim was unsubstantiated and came from a non-scientific environmental organization, and quoted tropical forest and climate change expert Dr. Simon Lewis in support. It was beginning to look like the IPCC was making all kinds of things up.

The only problem was that the 'Amazongate' controversy itself was entirely made up. You can read the sordid details here:

Newsweek - Newspapers Retract 'Climategate' Claims, but Damage Still Done

The Guardian - Sunday Times admits 'Amazongate' story was rubbish. But who's to blame?

Climate Progress - Sunday Times retracts and apologizes for shameful and bogus Amazon story smearing IPCC

After the mob rush to smear climate scientists and the IPCC last winter, sober analysis continues to largely vindicate them.


Continue reading...

Thursday, June 24, 2010

Michael Ash on Lineage Histories

[This is part of a series of posts I initiated with Book of Mormon Scholarship as an Elias for Evolution.]

Readers of this blog might enjoy Michael Ash's column at Mormon Times, a website run by the Deseret News. Of particular interest in this series of posts is something he wrote about the Book of Mormon being a lineage history in Why aren't other peoples mentioned in the Book of Mormon? As you read the following quote, think about how this can apply to Adam and Eve, etc.

While dynastic histories claim to tell the entire story, they actually only deal with the story as it relates to a particular dynastic family. And unlike modern scholarly histories, ancient accounts often served as propaganda to support a particular leader or group. "Others" are peripheral to the main story. In traditional tribal narratives, no one else exists unless it was necessary to mention them with regard to interaction with the tribe.

Continue reading...

Sunday, June 20, 2010

Some First Parents Are More First Than Others

[This is part of a series of posts I initiated with Book of Mormon Scholarship as an Elias for Evolution.]

The phrase 'first parents' occurs exclusively in the Book of Mormon, and is used ten times to refer to Adam and Eve. So according to the Book of Mormon, Adam and Eve were our first parents, end of story. Right? Well, maybe not quite. Interestingly, the phrase is also used three times to refer to other people. Here are the three passages.

Jacob 4:3

Now in this thing we do rejoice; and we labor diligently to engraven these words upon plates, hoping that our beloved brethren and our children will receive them with thankful hearts, and look upon them that they may learn with joy and not with sorrow, neither with contempt, concerning their first parents.
Omni 1:22
It [the stone with engravings] also spake a few words concerning his [Coriantumr's] fathers. And his first parents came out from the tower, at the time the Lord confounded the language of the people; and the severity of the Lord fell upon them according to his judgments, which are just; and their bones lay scattered in the land northward.
Helaman 5:6
Behold, my sons, I desire that ye should remember to keep the commandments of God; and I would that ye should declare unto the people these words. Behold, I have given unto you the names of our first parents who came out of the land of Jerusalem; and this I have done that when you remember your names ye may remember them; and when ye remember them ye may remember their works; and when ye remember their works ye may know how that it is said, and also written, that they were good.
In each of these cases the phrase 'first parents' means something similar to what we might call 'founding fathers.' In fact, in the third passage there is no female component at all because it is actually a reference to Lehi and Nephi.

None of this is to suggest that the Book of Mormon prophets didn't think Adam and Eve were literally our first parents. They probably did. The point is to show another example where words that would seem to have a definitive meaning are demonstrably more flexible. If other people existed alongside Adam and Eve, by the Book of Mormon's own standards Adam and Eve can still be called our first parents.


Continue reading...

Sunday, June 13, 2010

Adam and Eve: Reading Between the Lines

[This is part of a series of posts I initiated with Book of Mormon Scholarship as an Elias for Evolution.]

We turn now to the narrative about Adam and Eve and their posterity, where we will look for clues for the potential existence of others. Below I simply describe or quote the relevant part of the story and ask questions about it.

  • Many of Adam and Eve's posterity rejected their teachings from the very beginning.
    And Adam and Eve blessed the name of God, and they made all things known unto their sons and their daughters. And Satan came among them, saying: I am also a son of God; and he commanded them, saying: Believe it not; and they believed it not, and they loved Satan more than God. And men began from that time forth to be carnal, sensual, and devilish. (Moses 5:13.)
    If Adam, Eve, and their children were the only people on earth, why did the children have such a hard time believing their parents? Who would tell them otherwise? Were they really having conversations with Satan? Is it possible that there were, in fact, other people influencing Adam and Eve's children? Could Satan's declaration, "I am also a son of God" actually be a reference to surrounding competing religions where, as Nibley noted, claimed ties between humans and gods were not uncommon.


  • Hugh Nibley also noted the following which, although specifically about a universal flood, has potentially broader application:
    Speaking of Noah, God promised Enoch "that he [God] would call upon the children of Noah; and he sent forth an unalterable decree, that a remnant of his seed [Enoch's through Noah] should always be found among all nations, while the earth should stand; and the Lord said: Blessed is he through whose seed Messiah shall come." (Moses 7:51-53.) Methuselah boasted about his line as something special. (Moses 8:2-3.) Why special if it included the whole human race? These blessings have no meaning if all the people of the earth and all the nations are the seed of Noah and Enoch.

  • Enoch saw the city of Zion in vision, after which "Enoch also beheld the residue of the people which were the sons of Adam; and they were a mixture of all the seed of Adam save it was the seed of Cain..." Why does the text specify that the rest of the people were the 'sons of Adam'? Shouldn't that be obvious?


  • During Enoch's preaching, "there came a man unto him, whose name was Mahijah, and said unto him: Tell us plainly who thou art, and from whence thou comest?" (Moses 6:40.) Is it possible that Mahijah is an outsider, just as Sherem in the Book of Mormon seems to be?


  • Enoch and Noah both encountered 'giants', about whom nothing is known. In the Genesis text the giants are only associated with Noah. However, the Book of Moses adds a reference to them in connection with Enoch. Ancient traditions envisioned these giants (Nephilim) as the hybrid children of humans and fallen angels. However, I am not aware of any LDS commentator who accepts that interpretation.


  • Following the murder of Abel, Cain feared for his life. If Cain was really the first murderer among the very first family on earth, why would he be so worried about being killed himself, particularly since he would be leaving his homeland? Furthermore, in Genesis Cain goes to live in the land of Nod where he builds a city. Where did all the people come from to populate the city? The Book of Moses suggests that the inhabitants of the city were extended family members that Cain took with him. Did Cain really have enough sympathetic family members to build and populate a city? Is it possible that Joseph Smith added this detail because he also was puzzled by this issue? (Remember that in Joseph Smith's lifetime there was little reason to question the Ussher chronology, at least as applied to humans.)


  • Most of these elements can be given mundane interpretations consistent with Adam and Eve as the only people on earth. The point is not to suggest that an alternate interpretation is more natural or obvious. Rather, now that we have abundant evidence from archaeology and genetics, does the text contain possibilities that have been previously unappreciated?


    Continue reading...

    Sunday, June 06, 2010

    Before Adam

    [This is part of a series of posts I initiated with Book of Mormon Scholarship as an Elias for Evolution.]


    The groundwork for the argument that Genesis is an ethnocentric account was laid by Hugh Nibley in his "Before Adam," which was published in Old Testament and Related Studies, the first volume of The Collected Works of Hugh Nibley, and was based on a speech given in 1980. If you are not familiar with this article you should take some time to read it. However, you'll need to take his comments on science with a grain of salt. As FAIR puts it, "The science has advanced substantially since Nibley's article, and so its scientific claims should no longer be considered current. However, his theologic and historic perspective is still useful."

    Nibley stressed the importance of keeping in mind the limited perspective of the people involved in the scriptural accounts. As we read we must keep asking ourselves what exactly was seen and understood. I would add that we should also pay attention to how words are used and their potential alternative meanings. For example, the Hebrew word for 'earth' can refer to the whole planet, or a limited area (i.e. 'land'). The Book of Mormon repeatedly uses the phrase 'the whole earth' in a context that clearly does not mean the whole earth (see 3 Nephi 8 for several examples), and at one point the Book of Moses explicitly notes that Moses "beheld many lands; and each land was called earth," (Moses 1:29).

    Nibley also explored questions raised by the narrative. We'll look at some of those later. For now let's look at his conclusion.

    Do not begrudge existence to creatures that looked like men long, long ago, nor deny them a place in God's affection or even a right to exaltation—for our scriptures allow them such. Nor am I overly concerned as to just when they might have lived, for their world is not our world. They have all gone away long before our people ever appeared. God assigned them their proper times and functions, as he has given me mine—a full-time job that admonishes me to remember his words to the overly eager Moses: "For mine own purpose have I made these things. Here is wisdom and it remaineth in me." (Moses 1:31.) It is Adam as my own parent who concerns me. When he walks onto the stage, then and only then the play begins. He opens a book and starts calling out names. They are the sons of Adam, who also qualify as sons of God, Adam himself being a son of God. This is the book of remembrance from which many have been blotted out. They have fallen away, refused to choose God as their father, and by so doing were registered in Satan's camp. "Satan shall be their father, and misery shall be their doom." (Moses 7:37.)
    In reading Nibley again, I was struck by this next part. Again, we run into the ANE context of Genesis.
    Can we call them sons of Adam, bene-Adam, human beings proper? The representative Egyptians, Babylonians, Greeks, and Romans, to name only the classic civilizations of old, each fancied themselves to be beings of a higher nature, nearer to gods than others who inhabited the land with them (and before them), or who dwelt in other lands. And yet they did not deny humanity to them.



    Continue reading...

      © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

    Back to TOP