Friday, October 17, 2008

What Separates Humans from Egg-layers?


Part of what makes the platypus seem strange is that it lays eggs--like amphibians, reptiles, and birds--and yet it is a mammal. In contrast, like many other mammals we give birth to live young which receive nourishment during development by means of a placenta instead of from egg yolk. We have no need for the yolk protein vitellogenin; we don't make it, nor do we have the gene (or genes--there can be multiple copies) for it. The presence of vitellogenin sets egg-laying animals apart from us placentals. Or if you want to put it the other way, the absence of vitellogenin separates us from egg-layers. But there is more to the story, of course.

A quick digression: Did you know that when you 'delete' a file on a computer disk, what you have really done is tell the operating system not to recognize the file anymore? The data in the file remains on the disk until the space is overwritten by a different file. In fact there are programs that can find and resurrect deleted files.

Genomes can be like that and, wouldn't you know it, the remains of vitellogenin are in our genome, as well as the genomes of other placental animals. Genes that have become broken and degraded by mutation are called pseudogenes, and there are bits and pieces of between one and three vitellogenin pseudogenes in the human genome. (The number is debatable because two of the copies are degraded to the point of being difficult to statistically distinguish from background sequence.) Perhaps the clearest illustration of this is Figure S2 from Brawand et al, which shows an alignment of a portion of one of the vitellogenin genes (VIT1) from four species. (Click for larger view.)

Figure S2. Sequence Alignment of the VIT1 Exon 3 from Human (Homo sapiens), Dog (Canis familiaris), Armadillo (Dasypus novemcinctus), and Chicken (Gallus gallus). The alignment shows two indels that are shared between human, dog, and armadillo, indicating inactivation of these genes in the common ancestor of these species (see main text for discussion).

The figure shows an alignment of sequences from the genome of chicken, human, dog, and armadillo, with chicken as the standard of comparison (since it's VIT1 gene is in tact.) I added the green arrows to draw attention to the deletions shared by human, dog, and armadillo. That the deletions are shared by all three suggests that they occurred in common ancestors, and that this was a pseudogene before the lineages that gave rise to the three species diverged. The asterisks indicate positions where all four sequences are identical.

Now the genome is a big place, and you could argue that if you search hard enough you will find a spurious sequence that yields some alignment to the chicken vitellogenin genes. However, the authors also found alignment in the sequences flanking the VIT genes, which provides added support to the authenticity of the alignment. This is represented in Figure 2 as a dot plot comparing human and chicken sequence. (Click for larger view.)

Figure 2. Genome Alignment (Dot Plot Representing SIM Alignments) of Human/Chicken Syntenic Regions VIT 1-VIT3 Regions. The chain with the best cumulative score is shown. Alignment of flanking genes confirms the synteny of the aligned regions. The combined alignments of VIT1 coding sequences showed significantly higher alignment scores than the genomic background (introns and intergenic regions) in the chain, as assessed by a Mann-Whitney U test (p < 0.05). Thus, we can statistically exclude that detected VIT1 remnants from humans represent spurious sequence matches. The coding sequence matches for VIT2/3 may be too short to provide statistical significance or partially spurious.


Black dots represent identical sequence, and you can see--especially in the top panel--that there is some significant alignment with not only VIT1, but with ELTD1 as well. So not only do portions of the VIT genes align, but they are found in the same context relative to other genes. Again, this gives added support to their authenticity.

So the presence/absence of vitellogenin indeed sets us apart from egg-laying animals. But at the same time it paradoxically ties us together.


Reference:

Brawand D, Wahli W, Kaessmann H (2008) Loss of Egg Yolk Genes in Mammals and the Origin of Lactation and Placentation. PLoS Biol 6(3): e63



Continue reading...

Thursday, October 16, 2008

What Separates Humans from the Animals?

In 1857 the famous anatomist and opponent of Darwin, Richard Owen, claimed to have found a brain structure in humans that was missing in other apes. In his view this set humans apart and justified their classification in a separate genus. T.H. Huxley thought that Owen's claim was based on an artifact of poorly preserved specimens, and in a scientific meeting in 1860, Huxley humiliated Owen by presenting evidence that contradicted him. It turned out that Huxley was right; there was no such distinction in gross brain anatomy.

But humans are different in various ways from other animals, and in a coming series of posts I will highlight some distinguishing genetic features. However, whereas Richard Owen labored to discredit Darwin's hypothesis of common descent, the examples I have chosen support it, as I hope will be clear. These examples are drawn from the scientific literature and I hope that you will find them interesting. Enjoy!

Posts in Series:

1. What Separates Humans from Egg-layers?
2. What Separates Humans from Prosimians?
3. What Separates Humans from New World Monkeys?
4. What Separates Humans from Monkeys? (Resurrection Edition)
5. What Separates Humans from Orangutans?
6. What Separates Humans from Chimpanzees? (Part 1)


Continue reading...

Wednesday, October 08, 2008

The Time My Mother Made Duane Jeffery Nervous

Life has been busy lately, so it has been a little slow here. I have some good stuff in the works, but in the meantime here is a fun anecdote:

My parents met and married at BYU. Dad was on a sports scholarship and was sometimes on the road competing, so Mom would go to his classes and take notes for him. One semester Dad had a class from Duane Jeffery, and Mom dutifully attended as needed. When she showed up with a tape recorder, Dr. Jeffery was apparently concerned--enough to ask her what she was up to. Her explanation evidently satisfied him, because he said O.K. and that was that.

I don't know whether he was really concerned or not, but I wouldn't blame him if he was. Not many years previous Ernest Wilkinson had used students to spy on troublesome professors, and later on at least one occasion, comments allegedly critical of the Church that Dr. Jeffery made at an informal gathering were brought to the attention of "church officials," after which he was asked write "a letter reaffirming his commitment to the church."

For what it's worth, Dad has positive memories of Duane Jeffery, and he thinks he still has some of those recordings. (Sadly, I never had a class from Dr. Jeffery. In fact I don't think I even really knew who he was until after I graduated.)


Continue reading...

Wednesday, October 01, 2008

Pre-Columbian Chickens: More to the Story

In case you missed it...

Last year Proceedings of the National Academies of Sciences (PNAS) published a paper that claimed radiocarbon and DNA evidence for pre-Columbian chickens that were introduced from Polynesia. Here is the abstract [1]:

Two issues long debated among Pacific and American prehistorians are (i) whether there was a pre-Columbian introduction of chicken (Gallus gallus) to the Americas and (ii) whether Polynesian contact with South America might be identified archaeologically, through the recovery of remains of unquestionable Polynesian origin. We present a radiocarbon date and an ancient DNA sequence from a single chicken bone recovered from the archaeological site of El Arenal-1, on the Arauco Peninsula, Chile. These results not only provide firm evidence for the pre-Columbian introduction of chickens to the Americas, but strongly suggest that it was a Polynesian introduction.

Last July another paper in PNAS cast doubt on that. The abstract [2]:
European chickens were introduced into the American continents by the Spanish after their arrival in the 15th century. However, there is ongoing debate as to the presence of pre-Columbian chickens among Amerindians in South America, particularly in relation to Chilean breeds such as the Araucana and Passion Fowl. To understand the origin of these populations, we have generated partial mitochondrial DNA control region sequences from 41 native Chilean specimens and compared them with a previously generated database of ≈1,000 domestic chicken sequences from across the world as well as published Chilean and Polynesian ancient DNA sequences. The modern Chilean sequences cluster closely with haplotypes predominantly distributed among European, Indian subcontinental, and Southeast Asian chickens, consistent with a European genetic origin. A published, apparently pre-Columbian, Chilean specimen and six pre-European Polynesian specimens also cluster with the same European/Indian subcontinental/Southeast Asian sequences, providing no support for a Polynesian introduction of chickens to South America. In contrast, sequences from two archaeological sites on Easter Island group with an uncommon haplogroup from Indonesia, Japan, and China and may represent a genetic signature of an early Polynesian dispersal. Modeling of the potential marine carbon contribution to the Chilean archaeological specimen casts further doubt on claims for pre-Columbian chickens, and definitive proof will require further analyses of ancient DNA sequences and radiocarbon and stable isotope data from archaeological excavations within both Chile and Polynesia.

So we have a scientific dispute. There will be more to come, I'm sure.

References:

1. Storey AA, Ramírez JM, Quiroz D, Burley DV, Addison DJ, Walter R, Anderson AJ, Hunt TL, Athens JS, Huynen L, Matisoo-Smith EA. Radiocarbon and DNA evidence for a pre-Columbian introduction of Polynesian chickens to Chile. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2007 Jun 19;104(25):10335-9.

2. Gongora J, Rawlence NJ, Mobegi VA, Jianlin H, Alcalde JA, Matus JT, Hanotte O, Moran C, Austin JJ, Ulm S, Anderson AJ, Larson G, Cooper A. Indo-European and Asian origins for Chilean and Pacific chickens revealed by mtDNA. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2008 Jul 29;105(30):10308-13.


Continue reading...

Sunday, September 28, 2008

Making Truths Useful

Elder Dallin H. Oaks somewhat famously said, "Not everything that’s true is useful." Charles Darwin would agree with that, but for different reasons. In a letter he once complained,

About thirty years ago there was much talk that geologists ought only to observe and not theorize; and I well remember someone saying that at this rate a man might as well go into a gravel-pit and count the pebbles and describe the colours. How odd it is that anyone should not see that all observation must be for or against some view if it is to be of any service!
This pithy quote summarizes much about science--the importance of testing hypotheses and constructing the organizing framework of theories.


Continue reading...

Wednesday, September 24, 2008

Podcasts of Note

I've made a separate division for podcasts on the left sidebar. At the moment there are three listed; although I do listen to some others on a sporadic basis, these are my bread-and-butter podcasts. (Hint: you don't have to have an i-pod to listen to podcasts. Any mp3 player--including your computer--will do.)

The Skeptic's Guide to the Universe: If I were to recommend one podcast, this would be it. I've been listening for at least two years. It features several regular participants who discuss science and skepticism in an engaging way, and there is usually an interview with someone of interest to the science/skeptic community. After a while it's like listening to friends having a fun and lively conversation. I've subjected my wife to a few episodes while road-tripping, and even she liked it. I should warn you that the language can be PG-13, so if you are on a family trip in your car you will want to wait until the kids have fallen asleep.

Point of Inquiry: This podcast is produced by the Center for Inquiry, a secular humanist organization. It focuses on pseudoscience and the paranormal, alternative medicine, and religion and secularism. The format usually consists of an interview with an author of a book that treats one of these issues. You may be surprised by how often you agree with what you hear, but even when you disagree it is useful to hear another well-articulated perspective.

WNYC - Radiolab: This is a public radio program that takes (mostly) science topics and turns them into riveting radio. I suggest that you listen with headphones because it is also a rich auditory experience.

I'm always game for a good podcast, so please recommend your favorites.


Continue reading...

Thursday, September 18, 2008

Going to the ER is like eating cake.

In his op-ed column in the New York Times a couple of weeks ago, Paul Krugman blasted those who minimize the problem of people lacking health insurance by suggesting that all Americans have access to medical care via the emergency room. If I were a single man I would probably be in the group that Krugman criticizes. I'm generally as healthy as a horse: I rarely miss work because of illness, I rarely initiate a visit to a doctor, and the last time I had blood work done, my numbers were great. I do have a couple of health issues, but they are manageable and I get along just fine. If needed, the ER could serve as my source of health care, and I would assume the same for others.

Enter my wife. Although you would not know it by looking at her, modern medicine has been the source of her survival since she was in the womb--literally. I just made a list of her current health problems. Not counting her very poor (uncorrected) vision, or the gestational diabetes she had during her last pregnancy which required daily monitoring of blood sugar and insulin injections, I count six problems that actively require some kind of medication or other therapy. Actually, one of those is not much of a problem now because of successful physical therapy, but it isn't cured either, and hints at a comeback from time to time.

Of my wife's six health problems, none of them are candidates for ER treatment. Sure, if she had some kind of acute emergency then the ER would work, but really they are chronic problems that need sustained attention and monitoring by the appropriate health professional. Thank heaven that we have good health insurance through my job.

Recently we did make use of the emergency room. Although we did not know it at the time, our baby boy had pneumonia and we rushed to the ER (~1am) when he started having trouble breathing. They gave him several nebulizer treatments, did some blood work, and took chest X-rays. Initially they were going to admit him to the hospital, but when the pediatrician finally saw him he was discharged and all further treatment was managed by the pediatrician's office. For their services, the ER billed our insurance company over three thousand dollars, of which our insurance company agreed to pay several hundred, and we simply paid our co-pay (as well as our premiums, of course). Again, thank heaven that we have good health insurance. (And in case you were wondering, baby boy is just fine, thanks.)

I know that the problems with cost and administration of health care in the U.S. are complex, and I will not enter into what kind of policies would be best, or which political party has the best answer. However, one thing is clear to me: the ER is not the answer. When I think of my wife and those less fortunate than we are, "let them use the ER" sounds like "let them eat cake."




Continue reading...

Saturday, September 13, 2008

Everything I Know About Epistemology, I Learned From The Ensign

(Having never taken a serious interest in philosophy, that's probably pretty close to the truth.)

Elder Gerald Lund (of the Seventy) has the distinction of having written the only article for a Church magazine that uses the word "epistemology." The article is "Countering Korihor’s Philosophy" from the July 1992 Ensign (written before he became a General Authority). I originally found it as a missionary and have kept my copy since then.

The article first introduces some philosophical terms.

"Metaphysics is the branch of philosophy that deals with the nature of reality. It tries to answer the question 'What is real?'"

"Axiology is the study of ethics and values."

"Epistemology is the study of how we know what is real or true."

Elder Lund then lists and briefly explains some systems of epistemology: authoritarianism, rationalism, pragmatism, and empiricism. Of course he also adds revelation. He also explains that our metaphysics, axiology, and epistemology interact and inform each other.

Having provided this helpful primer, it's time to kick some Korihor rear-end. The article lays out Korihor's philosophical foundations and how Alma responded to them. It provides a fresh view of Alma's confrontation with Korihor, and I wish there were more of these kind of articles.

I do have two main reservations: First, in my opinion the swipe at humanists is not entirely warranted. I think that you can be a good Mormon and still find a lot of agreement with secular humanists. And if you are like me, you don't entirely disagree with some of the modern Korihor-like statements quoted in the article because they don't lend themselves to easy categorization of true or false.

Second, the article gives the impression that confounding Korihor-types is as easy as following the included chart.

No matter how clever, how sophisticated the philosophies of an anti-Christ may seem, they are not true. They are riddled with contradictions, errors, and false assumptions. The gospel, on the other hand, is truth—truth that has stood the test of centuries, truth that can withstand rational examination, truth that is pragmatic and practical, truth that can be confirmed through personal experience. A believer need not apologize for his or her beliefs, for these beliefs withstand every scrutiny much more efficiently than do the doctrines of Satan.
That sounds a little hubristic to me. If you think that you are going to destroy the arguments of a thoughtful atheist using this article, you are probably in for an unpleasant surprise. Imagine that Alma and Korihor were talking about UFOs, Zeus, or something else that you do not believe in (that others do) and you begin to see the problem. My point is simply that when push comes to shove, Mormonism does not rest on impeccable philosophical arguments and consistent logic. It has vulnerabilities that can only be shielded with faith. I am reminded of a statement by President Ezra Taft Benson:
Our main task is to declare the gospel and do it effectively. We are not obligated to answer every objection. Every man eventually is backed up to the wall of faith, and there he must make his stand.




Continue reading...

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP