Richard G. Scott on Truth
Yesterday I stumbled upon "Truth", a speech given by Richard G. Scott in 1978. Elder Scott presents two methods of determining truth, the scientific method and prayer. Elder Scott's praise for science has sincerity behind it, he having a nuclear physics background. And I was interested to see a slightly different version of a story he told in the May 2003 General Conference regarding a janitor that thought he and his colleagues were liars. Elder Scott goes on to discuss answers to prayer and provides some practical advice along with examples from his life.
Church-type speeches that discuss the scientific method usually use it as a foil for revelation. Elder Scott does not disappoint in this regard.The scientific method is a sound and most valuable way of arriving at truth. There are two limitations, however, with that method. First: We never can be sure we have absolute truth, though we often draw nearer and nearer to it. Secondly: Sometimes, no matter how earnestly and sincerely we apply that principle, we come up with the wrong answer.
I heartily agree with Elder Scott here. However it seems to me that these statements also apply to other ways of finding truth, including prayer and revelation. I think that Church history and doctrinal development bear that out. I guess you can't expect a Church authority to make that case, though. On the other hand, most of the examples Elder Scott gives of answered prayer have to do with personal circumstances rather than intellectual questions or ultimate answers.
Elder Scott does not discuss what to do when the two methods collide; it would be interesting to know whether he accepts radiometric dating of fossils older than 4,000 B.C.

