Tuesday, December 06, 2005

Duane Jeffery's SSE: A Continuing Dialogue

Duane Jeffery's article, "Seers, Savants and Evolution: The Uncomfortable Interface" is essential reading for anyone interested in the history of the relationship between science (especially evolution) and the Church. It appeared in Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought Vol. 8 No. 3, and is available here and here. What appears to be less well-known is that several issues later (Vol. 9 No. 3) another article was published titled, "Seers, Savants and Evolution: A Continuing Dialogue." (Available here.)

This second article consists of three letters responding to the first article followed by Duane Jeffery's response to the letters. Although written over three decades ago, much of the article is just as applicable now--some of it, perhaps, more so. It is worth reading and I am providing some of my favorite excerpts here along with a few comments of my own.

Continue Reading


Prophetic Infallibility

On all of the above issues [concerning creation scriptures] (and many others), no matter which interpretation one may accept, one is forced to reject at least some teachings of some prophets. The pain in that process stems purely from the erroneous doctrine of prophetic infallibility. Even Joseph Smith, whom we traditionally view as closest of all in his intimacy with God, openly rejected the idea. Others of his successors have done likewise (cf. "SSE," fn. 6). We must internalize the validity of that rejection; the doctrine of prophetic infallibility is foreign to Mormonism.


On the Atonement

Mr. Eatough represents that evolution (he does not qualify it; it appears that he means any form of it, fully-theistic or otherwise) negates the atonement. I have heard this assertion many times over the years; but for the first time I can now openly query the writer: why? Please reflect very carefully on what the atonement is and does, and then tell me why. But I serve warning in advance: the usual arguments given in LDS literature are not firmly based. Be very very careful of your steps; that originally solid-looking footing turns rapidly to a morass of quicksand.

As far as I am aware, Jeffery has never publically elaborated on this point. I would like to know his insight here, but I think I may have some idea as to what he means.

The Alternative, Design

Unfortunately...there are people, and they are not at all rare, who do deny that any form of evolutionary processes occur, who sincerely feel that if they admit the validity of even one tiny piece of evolutionary biology, they will have permitted into their religious values the tip of a wedge which cannot be stopped and which they view with near horror. (We have Church writings which bolster that belief!) Every semester I meet a number of students who are very uncomfortable with the development of pesticide resistance in mosquitoes, warfarin resistance in rats, etc. Though some person will assert that these incontrovertible developments via mutation and selection have nothing at all to do with real evolution, still these trivialities cause considerable discomfort to many of our people. It is a deeply sincere position. And what do such persons offer as an alternative to explain the incredible adaptation visible in nature? Design—pure, thorough, and simple. As before, I make no attempt to pursue that question in depth (cf. "SSE," p. 44, and fn. 10). The Snows appear cognizant of the limitations of the position, and specifically circumvent it; from their point of reference the word "capricious" is quite probably inapplicable. But I doubt that theirs is the prevailing belief in the Church; even our current Family Home Evening manual comes dangerously close to falling into the trap. For trap it is, and an old one. Indeed, it was right on this issue that Darwin the clergy candidate got his start on wondering about species—and, interestingly, his response provides an excellent case-example of the very kind of thing Brigham Young was extolling (in his quote, p. 49, fn. 36, "SSE"). Under those intense concepts of design, capriciousness is really a very mild word, even an understatement. Sociology and history, for starters, readily establish the point, without even beginning to invoke the detail of biology. It is the posit of intense design that bestows such problems, of course, and it was to that that my remarks were directed. I infer that the Snows find capriciousness in God to be intensely repugnant; I share their disdain. It seems time, then, that we eschew those peripheral doctrines which inescapably confer it on Him. Nature's adhering to a design by a benevolent being may well exist, but the concept seems to be not defensible on the level at which it is so often claimed.

Yes, that was all one paragraph.

On Understanding

...Eatough seems to feel that if I show any sensitivity at all to any form of evolution, I am thereby a fellow-traveller with, and a brazen champion of, the extreme anti-religious element, that I am demanding total and unconditional religious capitulation. That is his inference, not my implication, and totally contrary to the entire message of my article. Contrary to his assertion, I did not spell out any specific view of evolution in the entire article; other reviewers have rightly noted that point. I am a biologist, yes; a geneticist, yes, and I have access to all the flexibility of data interpretation that exists in those fields, but in this arena I am not bound by many of their limitations. The game we are playing in this search for truth is one of synthesis, not one contrived of extreme religionists on one hand and extreme anti-religionists on the other, each shouting epithets but never listening.


Explaining Facts

[W]hile I would not begin to claim that we can understand all of God's direct actions—indeed I assert that we cannot even identify them all—I do maintain that it is folly to characterize Him in such a way that He becomes duplicitous and/or irrational. And that is precisely what he becomes with virtually all of the anti-evolution arguments with which I am familiar. For, invoking a critical point not heavily made by the Snows, whatever method "God used" must eventually square with all the "factual" data...And when we adopt such a test (comprehensiveness of explanation, etc.) the superiority (n.b., I do not say "absolute truth,") of hypotheses which propose that some form of theistic evolution was involved becomes quickly apparent; the others, so far as I have observed, place God in an untenable position. For example, it seems to me quite reliable to "believe" that fossils exist. Their interpretation may well merit discussion; it seems to me that their legitimacy as remnants of previously-living organisms really does not. Evolutionary biology, of course, makes an attempt—a very good one—to explain them. Among others, one prominent anti-evolutionary commentator of high LDS rank had another explanation: "Well, of course we know that Satan just put those things there to deceive us." I cannot but wonder if persons who postulate this idea fully realize how widespread fossils are. They are found through and through virtually every major land mass known—if Satan really made all that, who then is the Creator of the earth? If nature indeed testifies of diety (a long-standing and still-in-vogue theological injunction), of which "diety" does it thus testify? And what is its testimony? For if the hypothesis be accepted, then God is a party to this by allowing such a monumental hoax, and indeed we have conferred on Him duplicity of truly staggering proportions! A witness of that sort, it appears to me, God can well do without.

Of course, the key claim of the Intelligent Design movement is that we can identify God's direct actions. Like Jeffery, I believe it to be a doubtful claim. But he makes a larger point here that is often lost: The "factual" data, not just from paleontology, but a number of fields including comparative genomics and developmental biology, must be accounted for somehow. LDS writers often invoke the Fall as somehow explaining what we see, but such an "explanation" is as vague as explaining the classical trinitarian God as a "mystery," nor does it come free from the problems with intense design mentioned above.

Continue reading...

Friday, December 02, 2005

BYU Scientists Convert Matter Into Mormonism

My brother sent me this article from the Onion. It's more silly than funny, in my opinion, but you might crack a smile.

BYU Scientists Convert Matter Into Mormonism

Continue reading...

Thursday, December 01, 2005

Mexican Footprints: Not Likely

Earlier this year some scientists claimed to have found footprints preserved in Mexico dating to 40,000 years ago. These would pre-date the accepted dates for the first humans in America by over 20,000 years.

A brief report in this week's Nature casts doubt on the footprints. Using two dating techniques, including argon isotope analysis, the actual volcanic ash that the supposed footprints were preserved in dated to 1.3 million years ago. This date pre-dates the earliest Homo sapien fossils (found in Africa) by over a million years. Apparently the first group of scientists used carbon dating on material above the footprints, which is not reliable past 40,000 years.

It is formally possible that the footprints were those of an early Homo species, but without further evidence it is considered unlikely. These authors conclude that most likely, they are not really footprints.

news@nature.com summary

Continue reading...

Tuesday, November 29, 2005

Highlights: Ice Core, Taste, and Development

Just a quick highlight of some science reading you might also enjoy.

Articles in the week's Science report on ice core data from Antarctica that extend the climate record to 650,000 years ago. (See Scientific American.com news summary.) Sum up: nowhere in the record have carbon dioxide levels been as high as they are now.

Carl Zimmer discusses a taste receptor that may help protect against malaria, but also is associated with alcoholism.

PZ Myers explains what the relatively simple Trichoplax can teach us about evolution and development.

Continue reading...

BYU Newsnet on Sen. Buttars

BYU Newsnet has an article about Sen. Buttars’ attempts to inject Intelligent Design into Utah schools. There’s nothing really new in the article, so I’m not adding it to my collection on the sidebar.

The article contains a couple of quotes from faculty, including Duane Jeffery.

“Intelligent design claims to be an alternate theory to evolution,” Jeffery said. “It cannot qualify as a theory.”

A scientific theory, Jeffery said, is a broad summation that pulls together massive amounts of data and gives direction for future testing. The problem with intelligent design is it cannot be tested for validation, he said.

“You can’t test anything with intelligent design,” he said. “There’s no way you can do science with it. Nobody has been able to.”

Continue reading...

Sunday, November 27, 2005

Church Policies: Beginning of Life and Embryonic Stem Cell Research

This is part of a series of posts containing information on Church policies on medical and scientific issues.

Beginning of Human Life:

"The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints has no official position on the moment that human life begins."
As I recall, the Church Handbook of Instructions also contains the following quotation from Brigham Young, "...when the mother feels life come to her infant, it is the spirit entering the body preparatory to the immortal existence." I welcome correction or confirmation in the comments.

Embryonic Stem Cell Research:
"[T]he Church has not taken a position on the issue of embryonic stem-cell research."

The above statments are taken from Comments on the News.

Continue reading...

Tuesday, November 22, 2005

Children Belong in Families

There is a brief article in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences that lends support to the importance of care given in infancy. The article is open acess, available here.

From PNAS:

Continue Reading


Alison Wismer Fries et al. report that a lack of typical care-giving in infancy is associated with altered oxytocin (OT) and arginine vasopressin (AVP) neuropeptide systems during childhood. The researchers studied 18 children raised in foreign orphanages for an average of 16.6 months immediately after birth and then adopted by American families. The comparison control group consisted of 21 children raised by their biological parents in a typical American home environment. The children engaged in an interactive computer game for 30 min while sitting on the lap of their mother and also an unfamiliar female. Baseline and posttesting urine samples were taken to measure levels of OT and AVP. Children who had experienced early neglect had lower overall levels of AVP than did family-reared children. Also, OT levels for family-reared children increased after physical contact with their mothers, but children who experienced early neglect did not show a similar response. The data indicate that the AVP and OT pathways are affected by early social experience. These results are consistent with the view that early experience plays a critical role in the development of brain systems underlying basic aspects of human social behavior.

From news@nature.com:
Scientists stress that the longer-term effects of neglect on children and their hormones remain unclear. But the results after a few years are significant.

"We don't want to reach the conclusion that this difference is permanent," says Seth Pollak, a developmental psychopathologist at the University of Wisconsin, Madison, who led the study. But he adds that the take-home message is that "children really need to be in families".

Pollak and his team measured the levels of two key hormones in 18 children adopted from Russian and Romanian orphanages. These resource-poor orphanages, where one adult may care for up to 40 infants, do not make it easy for newborns to form normal social attachments, says Pollak. The children left these orphanages about two or three years before the study, and have been living with adoptive parents in the United States.

The children, averaging 4.5 years in age, were asked to complete a 30-minute computer game while sitting on the laps of their adoptive mothers. The game directed children to engage with their mothers by, for example, tickling them or patting them on the head. For comparison, the researchers gave the same task to 21 Midwestern children who had been reared by their biological parents.

The researchers measured levels of oxytocin and vasopressin in urine samples before and after the game. Oxytocin has been nicknamed the trust hormone, and is known to facilitate social bonding in humans. The brain naturally produces the compound, and churns it out in certain situations, such as when being given a hug. Vasopressin has been shown to help animals recognize one another and bond.


A recent study found that people given a nasal spray containing oxytocin made them more willing to trust others with their money, which raises the possibility that maybe these kids could be helped by hormone treatment as they adjust to their new homes.

Continue reading...

Saturday, November 19, 2005

Welcome Tribune Readers! (If there are any.)

Saturday's Salt Lake Tribune had an article that listed a number of Mormon blogs.

Mormons jumped headlong into the world of blogging about three years ago. They created mini-communities organized around specific LDS topics such as history, politics or doctrine. Names like Times and Seasons, Approaching Zion, By Common Consent, Feminist Mormon Housewives, Millennial Star, Ministering Angels, Mormon Mommy Wars, Latter Day Liberation Front, LDS Science Review, and Mormon Metaphysics proliferated. (emphasis added)


I'm skeptical that I got much traffic from the article, but if you happen to be visiting as the result of it, welcome! Have a look around, feel free to drop me a line, and I hope you'll keep coming back.

Continue reading...

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP