Terryl Givens on Joseph Smith and Scientific Naturalism
Terryl Givens has been a rising star in Mormon studies for about ten years. He is a professor of literature and religion at the University of Richmond, and he got a lot of face time on the PBS program, "The Mormons".
Givens gave the keynote address at the recent "Parallels and Convergences: Mormon Thought and Engineering Vision" conference. His talk, "No Small and Cramped Eternities" is available online.
The talk itself is a little stuffy, but the Q&A is very interesting, IMO (starts ~min 34).
Among other things, Givens argued that Joseph Smith's departure from some traditional beliefs about Deity, particularly in the King Follett discourse, gives us a basis for building bridges with atheists and others dissatisfied with traditional religion, many of whom find religion distasteful for reasons that would be shared by Joseph and other early leaders. (I've seen a somewhat similar sentiment before. If I could just remember where?)In an increasingly secularist society, the presuppositions--increasingly--of the educated masses are going to be scientific naturalism, and what I'm saying is that King Follett is a theology that grows out of scientific naturalism.
Although I like it, that's kind of a shocking statement that probably deserves more attention--maybe in a future post. Yet in spite of such radical possibilities, in many ways the Church is a lot like its other Christian neighbors. Givens says that this is because we define ourselves in relation to the dominant culture, which is traditional Christianity. In other words, traditional Christians are our largest group of potential converts, as well as the holders of power (political, social, etc.). In terms of strategy, it's probably not in the Church's best interest to emphasize this other side of Mormonism, but Givens thinks that we have the capacity to build bridges to other minority audiences.
I'll end with another statement I liked:Joseph Smith, clearly, clearly, treasured the opportunity to think out loud. And on numerous occasions he expressed irritation with the fact that people always expected his pronouncements to carry the stamp of divine approval and authority. And I think he was trying to model for us a mode of intellectual inquiry, where as long as we don't make claims that are out of proportion to the certainty or authority that we have...
(Givens was speaking extemporaneously, so that last sentence kind of trailed off.)
(Hat-tip to Mormon Transhumanitists.)


2 comments:
Jared*
Interesting stuff. Where does that " King Follett is a theology that grows out of scientific naturalism" quote come from?
Thanks.
See 37:10.
Post a Comment