Thursday, March 02, 2006

Book Review: The Creationists

In 1931 the First Presidency issued a statement to all General Authorities stating that the Church had no doctrine concerning the existence of pre-Adamites. Although it may seem strange, in addition to the direct involvement of B.H. Roberts, Joseph Fielding Smith, and James E. Talmage was the indirect involvement of a Seventh-day Adventist: George McCready Price. Price was an amateur geologist who sought to reconcile the Bible and the teachings of Ellen G. White with science.

The result of this effort, explained in The New Geology and other works, came to be known as 'flood geology,' a concept that sought to explain all of the fossil strata as a result a global Noachian flood. Price's publications influenced--or at least gave support to--Joseph Fielding Smith's views of earth history and Smith invoked Price's writings in the 1931 controversy. James Talmage, on the other hand, had no patience for Price's arguments. Although the controversy was halted by the First Presidency statement, Price's influence on Joseph Fielding Smith continued. In his later book Man, His Origin and Destiny, Joseph Fielding Smith referenced or recommended two of Price's books.

Although this slice of history is of particular interest to Mormons, Price had a much larger influence on fundamentalism and creationism that can still be seen today. The story of the creationist movement is the subject of historian Ronald L. Numbers' book, The Creationists. If you want to understand the history of the creationist movement--and to some extent the newer intelligent design movement--this is the book to read.

Continue Reading


Numbers was born and raised as a Seventh-day Adventist and instructed in strict George McCready Price-style teachings. He later abandoned the instruction of his youth.

I vividly remember the evening I attended an illustrated lecture on the famous sequence of fossil forests in Yellowstone National Park and then stayed up much of the night with a biologist friend of like mind...first agonizing over, then finally accepting, the disturbing likelihood that the earth was at least thirty thousand years old.
Although now estranged from his Adventist roots and its creationist teachings, Numbers seeks to treat the topic and its adherents (which included his own father) with respect.

There are several catagories of creationism with shades between them. So-called young earth creationism (YEC) is the strictest form and established itself as synonymous with 'flood geology,' and 'scientific creationism' or 'creation science.'

By the late nineteenth century even the most conservative Christian apologists readily conceded that the Bible allowed for an ancient earth and pre-Edenic life. With few exceptions, they accommodated the findings of historical geology either by interpreting the days of Genesis 1 to represent vast ages in the history of the earth (the so-called day-age theory) or by separating a creation "in the beginning" from a much later Edenic creation in six literal days (the gap theory). Either way, they could defend the accuracy of the Bible while simultaneously embracing the latest geological and paleontological discoveries...

The creation scientists, by contrast, compress the history of life on earth into less than ten thousand years. To accomplish this, they attribute most of the fossil record to the brief period of the flood and its aftermath. They believe that the majority of plants and animals buried sequentially in the stratified rocks once lived together in the antediluvian world.


As alluded to above, 'creation science' has its roots in George McCready Price. Price's development of 'flood geology' was a way to not only reconcile scripture and geology, but to also cut off evolution at its base, since evolutionary theory depended on the orderly sequence of the fossil record to be able to infer biological change over time (radiometric dating had not yet been developed). Price sought out geological anomalies such as the Lewis Overthrust where fossils appeared out of order to argue that there was no real order to the fossil record, and therefore no way to infer biological change over time. He was mostly ignored by the geology community--and even by his own church--but he attracted a following, though some associates broke with him on several issues. His concepts were re-packaged in the 1960's by John Whitcomb and Henry Morris (who passed away a few days ago) in their book, The Genesis Flood, which helped launch the modern YEC movement.

Henry Morris went on to help form the Creation Research Society (CRS)--the first strict creationist society to survive long-term (others had dissolved in bickering) and later the Institute for Creation Research (ICR). A number of these leading creationists held Ph.D. degrees in subjects like engineering, physics, and biology, yet until 1969 'flood geology' did not have any doctoral geologist supporters. In a repeated scenario, creationist geology doctoral students eventually came to disbelieve in the central tenets of 'flood geology.' Since then the movement (including several different organizations such as Answers in Genesis) has gained a number of scientifically trained people from a variety of fields, although their contribution to 'creation science' has often consisted largely of arm-chair speculation and library research devoted to finding weaknesses in opponents' work. What they lack in genuine scientific evidence they make up for in confidence and argumentation.

Numbers does not seek to refute creationist claims, but as a matter of historical record he does document disagreements and sloppy research. For example the famous Paluxey footprints were touted in The Genesis Flood as showing that humans and dinosaurs co-existed because they each left prints in the same rock formation. However the original claim came from Clifford Burdick, a man who possesed zeal but was ultimately untrustworthy and sensationalistic. Even though the footprint claim was eventually retracted by Henry Morris, it can still be found in creationist literature.

Because the book covers creationism from the late nineteenth century on, it can be boring as the details of the struggles of long-dead figures are presented, although it is remarkable how little the basic arguments surrounding reconciliation of science with scriptures have changed. The book begins to pick up when discussing George McCready Price and gets even more interesting with the story of how the more science-friendly Christian organization, American Science Affiliation (ASA), helped to spark a fundamentalist backlash. The later chapters deal with more modern creationists like Henry and John Morris, Duane Gish, and others, as well as some of the major court battles. Although Ken Ham is mentioned, the book pre-dates the formation of Answers in Genesis. Also, a portion of a chapter describes creationism in the LDS context and centers on the 1931 controversy, the publication of Man, His Origin and Destiny, and the creationist writings of Melvin Cook.

Why has YEC creation science become so popular? Numbers suggests that it is because it allows one to read the Bible without gymnastics. As explained above, very conservative Christians have reconciled scripture and geology using the day-age and gap theories, but creation science eliminates the need for such additional assumptions--the scriptures can be read and understood at face value. This straightforward accuracy, its proponents argue, invites confidence in all of scripture, including that portion dealing with future prophesied events. My own thought is that while many Christians do not accept strict creationist teachings in a systematic way, some appreciate them for the balance they represent against mainstream science.

Although such results may seem desirable at first glance, such an approach to scripture seems problematic in the LDS context. The Creationists provides perspective and understanding of this religious movement and challenges us to consider where we should stand on similar issues.

15 comments:

Western geologist,  3/02/2006 11:55:00 PM  

I recently came across a copy of Price's "The Fundamentals of Geology" in a bookstore. I haven't had time to do more than skim it, but I'm looking forward to it. I think Morris is the father of the modern creationist movement, which I guess makes Price the grandfather.

I also think Numbers does a really nice job with his book. While you're generally correct that he doesn't try to refute creationist claims he does (indirectly) deal with a few interesting claims. For example, his recounting of Walter Lammerts' trip to the Lewis overthrust in Glacier National Park in Montana (featured in The Genesis Flood), and some correspondence after that (I apologize, but I forget the exactly who was involved). Based on that correspondence it's clear that Lammerts' wasn't describing the Lewis overthrust in the material that features in The Genesis Flood.

I think the creationist movement is so popular because it does provide a reconciliation between science and the Bible (I think it's a superficial reconciliation, but that doesn't reduce its appeal). I think the reason that a large part of the Christian church hasn't realized that it is only a superficial reconciliation is that the scientific community doesn't put enough effort into addressing creationist claims. I'm not disparaging the scientists who do take the time to address creationists, but I think that by and large the creationist literature far outweighs responses to it. I think that a lot of lay people interpret this lack of a response as an indication that the scientific community can't respond (while I think that a lot of scientists think that the creationist claims aren't worth devoting time to). That's my long-winded way of saying that I think that scientists (particularly Christian scientists) need to be more involved. That's one of the reasons I was very happy to find out about your blog. Thanks a lot for your efforts.

Anonymous,  3/03/2006 05:48:00 PM  

Great write up, thanks.

Rob Osborn,  3/04/2006 03:03:00 AM  

Jared,

I think it would be interesting to take the creationists and evolutionists points of views and stack them up against the doctrine of the LDS religion. I think it would be very interesting to find out that the creationists views are more in line with LDS doctrine than evolution's views.

Which brings up a valid point- Why do you not critisize the evolutionists views also, seeing that they are more out of line than creationists?

Jared*,  3/04/2006 12:15:00 PM  

Rob,

You are really asking me why I support mainstream science. Many Christians accept evolution--I just want to be clear that it is not as simple as pro vs anti-God.

I'm not sure I can give a sufficient answer at the moment. My short answer is this: I find much truth in both LDS doctrines and mainstream science. Neither has arrived at all of the final answers and both are subject to change given further information.

In my view, the heart of the gospel is about having faith in Christ unto repentance and receiving the ordinances from his authorized servants. Science has little bearing on that.

Coming from the other direction, there is a history of God revealing things line-upon-line and overturning or modifiying previous teachings that is not insignificant. In the face of such a history, I cannot reject scientific findings merely because they don't fit easily with current teaching. Furthermore, many who criticise mainstream science don't seem to really understand it.

In summary, I seek truth in both spheres.

Rob Osborn,  3/04/2006 12:30:00 PM  

Jared,

I probably have 50 books sitting next to me on the topics of geology, astronomy, life science, science encyclopedias, biology, and the like. The claim that most who critisize mainstream science are those who don't understand it, is a cop-out.

I and many like me are informed and understand it. Sure, I can't say that I have a degree in any of them, but that does not mean that I don't understand them.

Don't you think it would be interesting to put the top ten ideas from each side and see which one sides more closely with the LDS doctrine? I mean really, what would it hurt?

Jared*,  3/04/2006 01:49:00 PM  

Rob,

I didn't say anything about you. I have no idea how comprehensively you've read or what your background is. Nor do I deny that intelligent criticisms can be made, but I don't think it is a cop-out, I think it is often true.

Your proposal to line up creationist vs mainstream science ideas to see which is closer to LDS doctrines would not prove anything--the result is transparant. We share a common heritage of the Bible and our additional scriptures largely adopt its narrative. All of it was written before most of the modern scientific findings.

Creationism uses the Bible as its starting point and constrains all facts into that paradigm. Thus it is no suprise that the conclusions match the Bible and would therefore closely track LDS doctrines.

There would be a few differences, but those would be based on competing authority claims or assumptions, not on anything measurable or openly verifiable.

Rob Osborn,  3/06/2006 11:13:00 AM  

Jared,

So should we discount and disbelieve God just because science cannot measure or test and verify his existance? Modern scientific findings change theories all the time. The LDS religion and it's doctrine fits in the creationism slot and not in the evolution slot.

If it is God that reveals all truth, then should he not be the author of our very existance?

One last question. If you believe that the current understanding of science is correct, does that make the LDS doctrine incorrect?

Capt. Obsidian,  3/06/2006 11:30:00 AM  

Rob,

You are setting up a false dilemma. You are saying that you can either believe in LDS doctrine or you can believe in evolution. It is entirely reasonable to believe in both. The First Presidency has issued statements on evolution in the past. They have all stated that the LDS church has taken no position on organic evolution.

If you want a good overview of how evolution can be compatible with LDS doctrine, I recommend The Mormon Myth of Evil Evolution, a Dialogue article by Michael R. Ash.

Believing in evolution is not the same as saying that there is no God. I view evolution as the perfect process for creating and organizing life.

Jared*,  3/06/2006 01:41:00 PM  

Rob,

So should we discount and disbelieve God just because science cannot measure or test and verify his existance?

I don't think I've suggested anything of the sort.

If it is God that reveals all truth, then should he not be the author of our very existance?

I'm not sure what you mean here. I don't deny God a role in our existence, but I very much doubt that it could be discovered by scientific means because it would blend into the background of normal natural operation.

does that make the LDS doctrine incorrect?

First of all, let's be clear that we are only dealing with a subset of Church doctrines here. My opinion (which I reserve the right to change) is that they are incomplete. If you want to call that incorrect, then fine. Just keep in mind that I mean it in the same sense that the Book of Mormon prophets were incorrect about what happens after this life because they apparently didn't know about the three degrees of glory, or that the gospel is preached in the spirit world, or that eternal punishment does not really mean never-ending punishment, and so forth. Or to use a more recent example, in the sense that many people realized years before the change that the priesthood ban didn't make any sense (at least on the grounds commonly given).

None of this should be interpreted as me saying that current Church leaders are not leading correctly--that's not my call to make.

As I mentioned before, both our scientific and theological understanding are subject to change--it has happened in the past and I expect it to happen in the future.

Rob Osborn,  3/06/2006 08:35:00 PM  

Jared,

I agree with you on the whole incompleteness we have of the gospel. One of the big revelations in our day is the the space for repentance extends past death, something the BoM peoples never taught.

I also believe that modern day prophets have said things that have shaped our doctrine and view of things even though in my opinion they are not always right because of apparent contradictions upon further and later revelations.

in the case of God as the author of our existance I was referring to including him in science as the author of things unexplained like- where did we come from. There are those that say that that would be a theological issue and not a scientific issue. Nothing is further from the truth. God is the center and the foundation to unraveling scientific truth.

Rob Osborn,  3/06/2006 08:55:00 PM  

Capt. obsidian,

I gave the link you gave a general run through with the eyes. It appears to be the usual rhetoric on the "official neutral stance" of the church. The reason that one cannot advance the theory that evolution is the process that God used to create life is simple. The reason is because God created all forms of life including man into an imortal condition. Because they were all formed into this condition, there could be no possibility that he would use the offspring for millions of years to create another species.

2 Nephi 2:22, states that if there was no fall then all things which were created would have had no end.

Capt. Obsidian,  3/07/2006 12:21:00 AM  

Rob,

2 Nephi 2:22 can be interpreted as referring only to the Garden of Eden, as the first sentence of the verse refers to Adam in the Garden. We simply don't know enough about what or where the Garden of Eden was in order to make definitive statements extrapolating conditions in the Garden to the whole earth.

In addition to demonstrating how First Presidency statements on evolution have been neutral to the subject, the article I linked to includes an informative explanation on how the perception of an anti-evolutionary stance became prevalent within the church. In short, it was due to Joseph Fielding Smith's talk "Man, His Origin and Destiny", which was not approved by the First Presidency and was not an official proclamation by the church. In fact, David O. McKay, who was President at the time, was quite upset about the talk and it's subsequent publication. I can even link you to a copy of a letter that McKay wrote stating:

"On the subject of organic evolution the Church has officially taken no position. The book 'Man, His Origin and Destiny' was not published by the Church, and is not approved by the Church. The book contains the expressions of the author's views for which he alone is responsible."

Unfortunately, Bruce R. McConkie (Smith's son-in-law) incorporated Smith's position in his Mormon Doctrine book, which many members actually take as official doctrine of the church. Talmage, Widtsoe, and B.H. Roberts (all members of the QofT), all believed in an old earth and the existence of pre-Adamites.

One of the beautiful things about the church's position (or lack thereof) on evolution is that we can both hold different views on the subject and still be members in good standing.

Rob Osborn,  3/07/2006 12:44:00 AM  

Capt. Obsidian

I agree that we can both have different views and still be in good standing with the Lord.

Western geologist,  3/08/2006 10:04:00 PM  

Jared, Rob, and Capt. Obsidian,

Speaking as someone who's not LDS, I really appreciated the insights into different LDS positions on evolution. Thanks to all three of you. I am especially impressed with the civil tone - it's not something I usually encounter when discussing evolution (which I suppose may say something about the places I usually visit).

Anonymous,  1/07/2010 01:33:00 AM  

A few point.

B. H. Roberts was a seventy, not a member of the Twelve.

Second, what we know is that we are Spirit children of God. If the process of creating the earth is many day ages, then why can't God "forming Adam from the dust" be a short hand for the long process of biological evolution?

I think the general dislike of evolution by Church members come from its use as a club to attack belief in God. The fact that evolution and beleif in God can be reconciled is hard to realize when its loudest supporters mock God.

I am very glad that references to McConkie's Mormon Doctrian have been removed from the Gospel Principals manual in the most recent edition.

This is hopefully a continuing step into an era where Church members will embrace and not distrust science.

The last problem is that some people wish to claim that anyone who is "intelligent" leaves the Church. We need to stop letting those who hate the Church define what we believe, and embrace the full seeking of knowledge at the heart of gospel teachings.

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP