Review of FARMS Review
The latest issue of FARMS Review (Vol. 17 Issue 1, 2005) is available online to subscribers. Two of the articles are worth mentioning here.
Continue Reading
First is "Missing the Boat to Ancient America...Just Plain Missing the Boat," by Ryan Parr, which reviews Simon Southerton's book, Losing a Lost Tribe: Native Americans, DNA, and the Mormon Church. If you've been following this issue you won't find much new in this article. However, given his background, Parr seems like the most qualified commentator yet.
I do have one concern. Concerning DNA lineages, Parr states:each [haplotype] must be selected by a random biological lottery from generation to generation. Statistically, this is known as “coalescence.”
...Indeed, over time, the fate of most Y and mtDNA lineages is extinction through coalescence.
I don't have access to the text he cites, but I'm pretty sure that instead of "coalescence" he means "genetic drift." Compare his usage of the term with this. Maybe I'm missing something, but I don't think he used this term correctly. [Correction: the term is used appropriately, as I explain in this comment.] This concerns me because if he's using basic population genetics terminology incorrectly, it makes you wonder about the quality of his analysis. At the very least, it opens the door to criticism from Southerton that Parr doesn't know what he's talking about. (This after Parr attacks Southerton on Southerton's area of expertise--plant genetics.)
There is also a review of Carl Sagan's The Demon-Haunted World: Science as a Candle in the Dark by Allen Buskirk. This is basically a defense of religion against the attacks of scientism. It's a little long but worth at least a skim. (Coincidentally, I recently decided to put Sagan's book on my list of books to read.)


7 comments:
Jared, not being a subscriber I can't really comment on the review yet, but I did read Sagan's book. What I specifically recall was Sagan's careful avoidance of considering religious claims -- he aimed at debunking pseudoscience (UFOs, Atlantis, crystals, astrology, channeling, etc.), not religious belief. So the reviewer is sort of defending religious belief from an attack Sagan did not really make. I was impressed it was an argument Sagan could have made (others certainly would have) but didn't.
Dave,
The review seems to be inspired by some anti-mormon use of Sagan against us. The reviewer also thinks that the boundary between pseudoscience and religion is not always maintained in the book. Having not read it yet, I guess I'll just have to wait and see.
But even if Sagan reaches too far, I'm sure many of his points are valid and worthy of consideration.
As far as I can tell, all the reviews are available to anyone. I didn't have to log-in to read them.
Daniel Peterson talked about publishing a review of Sagan's book in June 2004.
I found the source cited in footnote 5 of Parr's article.
Mode of Inheritance
I also found the source for note 6 in Parr's review. The book can be read on amazon.com using the "search inside" feature.
Molecular Markers
Thanks for the help, Justin.
I can't find the word "coalescence" anywhere in the paper (ref 5). I do find "sampling drift" in the discussion.
I searched the book on Amazon and found several uses of the word. It does not appear on the pages cited in the review. I did find the word on page 299 in the context of tracing matrilines to mitochondrial "Eve." This usage is consistent with the reference I provided.
However, I am finding some usages on the internet that are consistent with Parr's. I'll have to look into it a little more. I'll report back here later.
According to Evolution, by Douglas Futuyama (well-known and respected), coalescence can mean what Parr says. (pg. 228, searchable on Amazon.com)
As allels go extinct, they are said to "coalesce" to one ancestral copy, as illustrated in the review.
So it looks like "coalescence" can be used in two ways; one looking backward in time, and the other forward.
Post a Comment