Friday, August 26, 2005

Joseph Fielding Smith: Man and the Moon

You may have heard that Joseph Fielding Smith once said that man would never get to the moon. The topic came up on another blog recently, so I thought I would assemble what I could find on the topic.

Continue Reading


1. Joseph Fielding Smith's Answers to Gospel Questions Vol. II contains the following passage:

When man was placed on this earth it became his probationary, or mortal home. Here he is destined to stay until his earth-life is completed, subject to all the mortal conditions outlined in the beginning. There is no prophecy or edict ever given that mortals should seek dominions beyond this earth while they dwell in mortality. Here we are, and here we should be content to stay. All this talk about space travel and the visiting of other worlds brings to mind vividly an attempt long ago made by foolish men who tried to build to heaven.

This earth is our destined earth home. With this in mind, wise men will be content and will wait until the time comes when this earth is cleansed and purified from all sin for heavenly visits, and in that day they will come. (p.191-192)
The question that he was responding to asked about whether space travel might play a role in the fulfillment of prophecy, such as the return of the ten tribes. The answer should be read in that context.

2. According to Francis Gibbon's biography, Joseph Fielding Smith: Gospel Scholar, Prophet of God,
[Elder Smith] took a dim view of space travel. During a stake conference held in Tulsa, Oklahoma, on May 1 and 2, 1962, a reporter questioned him about the plans of the United States to put a man on the moon. "I answered that they might, but evidently if so he might have difficulty to get back again." This comment was picked up and reported by the national wire services, producing a wholly unexpected reaction. "I am flooded by letters in relation to it," wrote the apostle, "with some editorial criticism." Although he never answered publicly, he confided this response to his diary: "The fact is . . . mortal man has no business trying to get on the moon, for earth is a probationary state and in mortality we are expected [to stay on] this earth." (p.371)


3. The Life of Joseph Fielding Smith, by Joseph Fielding Smith Jr. and John J. Stewart, treats the same episode as #2 above.
President Smith questioned the wisdom or worth of the government's expensive efforts to place men on the moon. In recent years the rumor has circulated around the Church that President Smith once prophesied that men would never reach the moon. The falsity of this report is apparent from the fuss that was raised back in 1962 when he commented on the moon venture. In his journal for May 1 and 2, 1962, he observed, "When in Tulsa, Oklahoma, I was interviewed by a reporter. He asked me about the endeavor to place men on the moon. I answered that they might, but evidently if so he might have difficulty to get back again. This was sent out as a dispatch to newspapers all over the U.S., and I am flooded by letters in relation to it, with some editorial criticisms. Why such a fuss? . . . This remark apparently disturbed a great many people. The fact is, however, although I did not say it, man-mortal man-has no business trying to get on the moon, for earth is a probationary state and in mortality we are expected [to stay on] this earth." He did not say whether the letter writers were upset because he said that man might get on the moon, or because he said they might have a difficult time getting back. Perhaps there was some criticism from each side. (p. 322-324)


4. Quinn's biography of J. Reuben Clark contains this note:
As an example of Apostle Smith's rejection of science, he instructed a stake conference in 1961: "We will never get a man into space. This earth is man's sphere and it was never intended that he should get away from it. The moon is a superior planet to the earth and it was never intended that man should go there. You can write it down in your books that this will never happen." See E, 848 (entry for 14 May 1961), with commentary a few days later in George S. Tanner diary, JWML. Smith wanted this view to be taught to "the boys and girls in the Seminary System." (Chapter 7 note 79)
This is also in Quinn's Extensions of Power, a book I do not have. I understand that the book does not give a source for the quotation. If anybody knows the ultimate source, please provide it.

5. An essay attributed to Joseph Fielding McConkie contains this:
I was present on at least one occasion when President Smith said it. It was a Sunday dinner at our house. My grandfather, Oscar W. McConkie, had asked President Smith if he thought the Lord would allow us to get to other worlds and communicate with the people on them. President Smith indicated that he did not. He reasoned that because the atonement that Christ worked out on this earth applies to all the creations of the Father, that our getting to other worlds and discovering that they had the same Savior and the same plan of salvation would dispense with the necessity of our accepting the gospel on the basis of faith. To dramatize the point he said, "I don't even think the Lord will let men get to the moon."

I concurred with President Smith's reasoning then and do so now. What he said, in my judgement, was right. The illustration he used to dramatize his point has since proven to be in error. It, however, has nothing to do with the point he was making.


6. [Edited to include quote provided in comments below]
"Now I say this is a probationary existence. We are placed here on probation. The people in our land, as well as in foreign lands, are all going crazy over getting to the moon, setting up headquarters there, and so forth. I think the Lord sits in the heavens and laughs at our foolishness. He does not have to do like He did in the days of the building of the Tower of Babel, come down to take a look. But I think he sits in the heavens and smiles at the foolishness of mortal men." ("We Are Here to Be Tried, Tested, Proved," BYU address, October 25, 1961.)

Pres. Smith's skepticism about space travel seems to come from the silence of the scriptures on the matter. He was not the prophet when the statements were made, and his sentiments were apparently common at the time. An additional thing to consider is that some of his commentary was apparently in response to talk of colonizing the moon or other planets. In that regard, his opinon has not been contradicted yet.

It is interesting to note that Pres. Smith seems to have believed that the moon was in some way superior to the earth--perhaps in a non-mortal state. Given the scriptural symbolism, he may have thought that the moon was a terrestrial world (in the sense of the degrees of glory). This may be likely, as will be seen in a forthcoming post.

(FAIR has an article on the nature of prophets that touches on Pres. Smith's view of space travel.)

8 comments:

Anonymous,  8/25/2005 09:03:00 PM  

Thanks for pulling these together.

Anonymous,  8/25/2005 09:54:00 PM  

And a fair analysis to boot. Thanks.

Anonymous,  8/26/2005 02:35:00 AM  

In the spirit of the FAIR article on The Nature of Prophets and Prophecy, I'd like to add this gem: "There have been times when even the President of the Church has not been moved upon by the Holy Ghost. There is, I suppose you'd say, a classic story of Brigham Young in the time when Johnston's army was on the move. The Saints were all inflamed, and President Young had his feelings whetted to fighting pitch. He stood up in the morning session of general conference and preached a sermon vibrant with defiance at the approaching army, declaring an intention to oppose them and drive them back. In the afternoon he rose and said that Brigham Young had been talking in the morning but the Lord was going to talk now. He then delivered an address the tempo of which was the exact opposite of the morning sermon." (Harold B. Lee, Stand Ye In Holy Places, p. 110.)

Justin B.,  8/26/2005 09:29:00 AM  

Another quote:

"Now I say this is a probationary existence. We are placed here on probation. The people in our land, as well as in foreign lands, are all going crazy over getting to the moon, setting up headquarters there, and so forth. I think the Lord sits in the heavens and laughs at our foolishness. He does not have to do like He did in the days of the building of the Tower of Babel, come down to take a look. But I think he sits in the heavens and smiles at the foolishness of mortal men."

Joseph Fielding Smith, "We Are Here to Be Tried, Tested, Proved," BYU address, October 25, 1961.

Jared*,  8/26/2005 10:05:00 AM  

Thanks, Justin. I knew I had seen the context of colonization somewhere, but I couldn't remember where.

Anonymous,  8/26/2005 10:28:00 AM  

A current dogma of space exploration is that sending men out is wasteful folly and that we should only use unmanned craft and remotely controlled instruments. I mostly disagree with that dogma (manned missions have beat the unmanned ones at sample return by orders of magnitude), but for those who do agree that sending men into space is a waste, does that increase their esteem for Joseph Fielding Smith's words?

Anonymous,  8/26/2005 10:32:00 AM  

The Joseph Fielding McConkie story that John W. Redelfs posted in a comment here is truly another gem.

Jared*,  8/26/2005 10:45:00 AM  

This is off topic, but since Gary has drawn additional attention to Joesph McConkie's essay I will pose this question.

If we assume that there is other mortal human life out there involved in the same plan of salvation, if we were to make contact what are the chances that we would figure out that we share the same plan of salvation? Pick a country and time at random on earth and it seems to me that you would have a difficult time finding the plan of salvation. Why would it be different for them?

Let's say that we told the other planet everything we know about ourselves--our cultures etc--and they told us about theirs. We might find the same true plan of salvation, but I'm betting we would find some of the same errors as well.

Would contact really remove the need for faith in the restored gospel?

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP