Sunday, January 23, 2005

The Plan of Salvation is a Model

Discussions of the relationship between science and religion often dwell on the differences between the two. Some see the two as totally and completely at odds with one another. However, there are some ways that I think science and revealed religion are very much alike. One of these is the use of models.


Continue Reading


The term "model" can have at least two meanings in scientific research. One usage has to do with experiments we can do in the place of experiments that we cannot do. For example, we cannot experimentally give people inhalation anthrax (or any other of a number of diseases), but we can often find an animal that exhibits features of disease that are similar to humans. Other examples of this type of model are computer models. Climatologists cannot experimentally alter the earth’s weather patterns, but they can look at history and design computer programs that analyze a number of variables in an attempt to predict what future weather systems will do.

Another meaning of the term "model" has more to do with intellectual framework. It is a story--of sorts--that unifies various experimental data and provides a basis for the formation of hypotheses. It can be big or small. Sometimes it doesn’t matter very much whether the model is correct or not--in fact in the early periods of investigation it will almost certainly either be false or woefully incomplete. What matters is that there is something to work with that can lead to productive results and revision of the model.

An example of this type of model might be the replication strategy of a virus. We might start out with this: the virus enters the cell and then replicates its genome and produces viral proteins, which then assemble together to from a new virus, which is then released from the cell. Then hypotheses and experiments are designed to answer questions such as: how does the virus enter the cell, where in the cell does replication take place, how are the viral proteins brought together, etc. The model is then updated to incorporate the new findings. For example: the virus binds to protein X on the cell surface, is engulfed into a vacuole where its envelope fuses with the vacuole in a pH dependent manner etc.

Sometimes competing models are proposed; both are reasonable explanations of the data. So naturally, experiments are devised to help resolve the issue. Other times a model may be correct but incomplete; it explains the previously known data perfectly well but cannot explain newer data. For example, a cellular signaling cascade may be known in great detail, but then it is discovered that it feeds into another signaling cascade.

In the gospel we have a number of models. The plan of salvation is essentially a model; it unifies or provides a framework for a number of teachings contained in the scriptures. Elder Boyd K. Packer has written:

Gospel principles are not always fully explained in one place in the scriptures nor presented in order or sequence. The whole plan of salvation must be assembled from pieces here and there. Sometimes one finds larger segments, but often it is in small bits scattered through the chapters and verses. Seen separately, and gathered at random, they do not easily fit together to form a plan or a chart we can follow. Nevertheless, it is essential that we look to the revelations to find the meaning of and to give direction to our lives (Our Father's Plan, pg 2).

We’ve all seen it diagramed with circles and arrows: pre-earth, morality, spirit world, and three degrees of glory. But how would the diagram have looked when the church was organized in 1830? The revelation in D&C 76 had not yet been given and the Book of Mormon is very dualistic--heaven or hell. D&C 76 represented new "data" that caused a re-interpretation of older "data" and led to a revision of the model of the plan of salvation. (This is a sort of thought experiment, not an attempt to describe the history of doctrinal development. Also, there are probably theological terms for what I am describing, but I am not a theologian and it is beside the point anyway.)

Other revelations have had similar effects: eternal punishment is not necessarily without end, Christ did not preach personally to the spirits in prison, there are three degrees within the celestial glory (about which we know almost nothing), the King Follet Discourse, and so on. New revelation can instruct us on something about which we knew nothing, or it can cause us to re-examine and re-interpret what we thought we knew (ie. revise our model). Other models include the Garden of Eden (we don’t know how much is figurative or how much Adam and Eve really understood), how the Second Coming will occur, or even how the Atonement works (some, such as Cleon Skousen, have proposed a model for the workings of the atonement. I think they are mostly speculation.)

All of this is in accord with scriptures that state that we learn line upon line, and the 9th Article of Faith:
We believe all that God has revealed, all that He does now reveal, and we believe that He will yet reveal many great and important things pertaining to the Kingdom of God.

I see science and religion as similar in their use of models. The difference is in how they obtain data. I believe tensions between science and religion are due to incomplete models--on both sides--and that the tension will be resolved when all the data are in.

2 comments:

Anonymous,  4/14/2005 09:58:00 AM  

Jared - I believe we also have a model in place on what "doctrine" is. I have always been taught that the Scriptures are true, and, that the First Presidency is licensed by God to interpret them. I see you trying to change this model. You now want to add science to the "cannon." This has never been done before. Without a model for doctrine that is credible and unchanging,while the faith of some individuals may survive, that of many will not.

Jared*,  11/06/2005 03:13:00 PM  

You seem to assume that "doctrine" means "things as they really are, were, and will be", or "ultimate truth."

While I believe there is much overlap between the two, they are not always synonymous. Doctrine means "teaching." The First Presidency and Quorum of the Twelve are authorized to decide what will be taught, but those teachings are not necessarily ultimate truth. This, it seems to me, is self-evident and is illustrated in the examples given in my post.

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP