Monday, January 17, 2011

If I Had a Side Blog

Odds and ends that may be of interest:

1. There's a new blog dedicated to the Word of Wisdom - Word of Wisdom Living. I'm not sure what to think of it yet, but check it out. It probably can't make you less healthy.

2. You don't have to be a liberal democrat to recognize climate change as an important issue. Examples here and here.

3. Salon.com: "We've removed an explosive 2005 report by Robert F. Kennedy Jr. about autism and vaccines. Here's why."

4. Steve Peck ate puffer fish and luckily lived to tell the tale.

5. ESP makes it into a respected psychology journal. Controversy ensues.


Continue reading...

Sunday, January 09, 2011

The Lost World of Genesis One


Christmas brought me a few books that should serve as blogging material. First up is The Lost World of Genesis One by John Walton, a professor of Old Testament at Wheaton College. Walton argues that if Genesis 1 is read carefully with the ancient Near East context in mind, it becomes clear that the creation story is a functional account (how things work together in an ordered system) rather than a material account (the physical origin). He then argues that scientific accounts of physical origins do not conflict with the Bible because the Bible has nothing to say on the matter.

A couple of things shake out of his analysis that should be of particular interest to an LDS audience. First, is Walton's conclusion that the Hebrew word translated as "create" (bara) does not refer to creation ex nihilo. Although he still believes that ultimately God did create everything out of nothing, Walton argues that the text itself does not teach or imply such a thing. He lays out the reasoning of the ex nihilo interpretation as follows: Materials for creation are never mentioned in association with the word (bara), therefore they must have been created out of nothing. Walton argues that this line of reasoning depends on the assumption that material creation, rather than functional creation, is what is described.

[Genesis 1] does involve creative activities, but all in relation to the way that the ancient world thought about creation and existence: by naming, separating and assigning functions and roles in an ordered system. [p. 46]
This is within striking distance of Joseph Smith's interpretation. Although his reasoning took a somewhat different path, Joseph also rejected creation ex nihilo based (at least partly) on his analysis of the same Hebrew word, as recorded in the famous King Follett discourse:
Now, the word create came from the word baurau which does not mean to create out of nothing; it means to organize; the same as a man would organize materials and build a ship. Hence, we infer that God had materials to organize the world out of chaos—chaotic matter, which is element, and in which dwells all the glory.
Second, Walton argues that the creation of the cosmos should be understood as God creating a temple. (I hardly need to mention the role of the creation in LDS temple worship.) Interestingly, he says that when the text says that God "rested" on the seventh day, this is actually a reference to God taking up his place within his temple, and would have been recognized as such by ancient Israelites because in ancient Near Eastern culture, God(s) rest in, and only in, a temple. He then goes on to write things that will look familiar to anyone who as done any reading of what LDS scholars have written about ancient temples (eg. Hugh Nibley's Temple and Cosmos) [1] . For example,
This close connection between cosmic origins and temple building reinforces the idea across the ancient Near East that the temples were considered primordial and that cosmic origins at times were defined in terms of a temple element....

We can draw the connection between temple and cosmos more tightly when we observe that temples in the ancient world were considered symbols of the cosmos. [p. 79]
According to Walton, in effect, God finished setting up the functions of his temple and then settled in to get down to business. This leads Walton to propose that Genesis 1 is essentially a seven-day inauguration ceremony of God's temple (the cosmos), which he has set up around the needs of humans, and in which he dwells and conducts his business.
Given the relationship of the temple and the cosmos, the creation of one is also the creation of the other. The temple is made functional in the inauguration ceremonies, and therefore the temple is created in the inauguration ceremony. So also the cosmic temple would be made functional (created) in an inauguration ceremony. [p. 88]
Walton insists that he is not offering an alternative to a literal reading of Genesis 1. Rather, he says that this is a literal reading; it is how the ancient Israelites would have understood it. Making the switch from material to functional thinking is difficult, which Walton would probably say is a testament to the power our cultural environment has in shaping our thinking. Although he offers several analogies, I think of it like this: Imagine a baby blessing where the father, rather than making a general statement about the health and growth of the child, proceeds to name each major organ system and describe the function of each. Nobody would mistake this for the actual physical creation of the organ systems. (It occurs to me that we need not look outside of the temple for an example of functional language (eg. initiatory ordinances).)

Nevertheless, it is hard to read the creation account in the Book of Abraham, or consider the creation account in the endowment, without getting the sense that God (or his representatives) is depicted actually doing something. Yet even here Walton may have a partial solution. Early in the book he says that the ancients did not distinguish between 'natural' and 'supernatural' causes. There were no 'natural laws' which caused things to run on their own, with God stepping in from time to time. Rather, the ancients attributed everything to God. Whereas we might say that God used an earthquake caused by a shift in tectonic plates, or (to use scriptural history) that he used the empires of Assyria and Babylonia to accomplish his purposes, the ancients would simply say that God did it. So it shouldn't be surprising that a text written for another culture shows no concern for a distinction important to ours. On the other hand, we are not totally divorced from the ancient mindset. It is not uncommon for people to express a sense of providence in what seem like ordinary natural events.

There are additional nuggets of insight to be mined from the book, but I'll leave it at that for now. At under 200 pages, the book is an easy and quick read. It is also organized well; each chapter title encapsulates the main point of the chapter and there is a nice summary at the end, as well as answers to FAQs. The last couple of chapters wander a little off-topic by getting into how science is taught in public schools. I pretty much agree with his position, which is to leave discussion of purpose (or lack thereof) out of science classrooms, but it seemed a little out of place in this book.

I'll close with a quote from the introduction.
The Old Testament does communicate to us and it was written for us, and for all humankind. But it was not written to us. It was written to Israel. It is God's revelation of himself to Israel and secondarily through Israel to everyone else. As obvious as this is, we must be aware of the implications of that simple statement.

Notes:

1. I don't mean to imply that all of these similar insights originated with LDS scholars.



Continue reading...

Thursday, January 06, 2011

Vaccine-Autism Link Fraudulent from Beginning

The vaccine-autism controversy began with a 1998 paper in the Lancet, by British doctor Andrew Wakefield, that suggested an association between MMR (measles, mumps, rubella) vaccine and autism in 12 children. Although the alleged vaccine component responsible, in the minds of anti-vaccine advocates, has shifted over time (eg. thimerosal, which has since been removed from childhood vaccines), it was Wakefield and MMR that started the ball rolling. The paper was finally retracted by Lancet last year and Wakefield lost his medical license over ethical problems with the study.

Now the BMJ (British Medical Journal) is publishing the results of journalist Brian Deer's investigation into the paper. The BMJ's judgment is unflinching: fraud.

Below I reproduce their summary for part 1 and provide relevant links.

How the link was fixed

The Lancet paper was a case series of 12 child patients; it reported a proposed “new syndrome” of enterocolitis and regressive autism and associated this with MMR as an “apparent precipitating event.” But in fact:

*Three of nine children reported with regressive autism did not have autism diagnosed at all. Only one child clearly had regressive autism

*Despite the paper claiming that all 12 children were “previously normal,” five had documented pre-existing developmental concerns

*Some children were reported to have experienced first behavioural symptoms within days of MMR, but the records documented these as starting some months after vaccination

*In nine cases, unremarkable colonic histopathology results—noting no or minimal fluctuations in inflammatory cell populations—were changed after a medical school “research review” to “non-specific colitis”

*The parents of eight children were reported as blaming MMR, but 11 families made this allegation at the hospital. The exclusion of three allegations—all giving times to onset of problems in months—helped to create the appearance of a 14 day temporal link

*Patients were recruited through anti-MMR campaigners, and the study was commissioned and funded for planned litigation

For more details:

BMJ news summary

Secrets of the MMR scare: Part 1, Part 2, and Part 3.



Continue reading...

Thursday, December 30, 2010

Evolution on Church Radio

Mormon Channel, the Church's official radio station, has a new program called Insights that takes education as its theme. The second episode is an interview with BYU biology professor Dennis Shiozawa. The discussion includes matter-of-fact references to geological timescales, as well as some discussion of evolution (especially at minutes 19 and 47). Here is part of the episode description:

Learn how biologists track species and map DNA to better understand gene pools, evolution, the our effect on our environment.
It's nice to to see mainstream biology and geology represented in Church media. Kudos to Insights and the Mormon Channel!


Continue reading...

Wednesday, December 22, 2010

If I Had a Side Blog

What to do with things I come across that don't seem to warrant a dedicated post? Some blogs have side blogs, but that doesn't seem to be an option in Blogger. Yeah, maybe there's a third-party gadget out there, but I don't feel like messing with it. So until I decide on something I like better, I'll collect items of interest and occasionally post them under this title. So let's kick it off.




1. Rumors of the demise of the incandescent light bulb have been greatly exaggerated.

2. Creationists often deny the existence of vestigial structures, but they can be found within creationist-defined "kinds."

3. Speaking of creationism, an analysis of fruit fly genes delivers another smack to Intelligent Design.

4. The Eternal Universe explains why funding basic research into things of no practical application is important for getting practical applications.

5. FOX News slanting coverage of climate science? Say it ain't so!

6. Send this lady on a mission!

7. If you've seen one temperature data set, you've pretty much seen them all (here, too).



Continue reading...

Thursday, December 16, 2010

One Long Argument from Authority

Argument from authority: "Appeal to authority is a fallacy of defective induction, where it is argued that a statement is correct because the statement is made by a person or source that is commonly regarded as authoritative."

One long argument: Phrase used by Darwin in the final chapter of The Origin of Species to describe the whole book.




A couple of months ago I highlighted a harsh review of Rod Meldrum's publications and talks that was published in the FARMS Review. Although the main focus was the Book of Mormon, evolution was dragged into the discussion.

Meldrum's website has a number of free downloads, including a handy little compilation of many of the bad things past prophets have said about evolution. In some cases (e.g. Joseph Smith) the statements are not directly about evolution, but are nevertheless used as ammunition. In other cases (esp. Joseph Fielding Smith), statements and writings before their becoming president of the Church are grandfathered in. Also, someone has helpfully underlined and bolded all of the important parts, in order to assist hitting you over the head.

The document is said to have been compiled by one James Stoddard, who is the president of ZionVison. In case you need further bludgeoning, check out their video, Creation and Evolution: A Witness of Prophets. You can get a taste of it by looking at these trailers. You can also read a transcript of the video here.

In addition to argument from authority, the video is long on another logical fallacy: appeal to consequences. In classic form, the video blames evolution for various evils in society, such as Hitler and the Columbine massacre. There is also a little bit of traditional quote-mining--more likely recycled quote-mining (example).

I think my favorite part is where it refers to BYU zoologist Duane Jeffery as "one modern biologist, who rejects the miracles of the scriptures," and who "has spent much of his life promoting the theories of Darwinism while belittling the words of latter-day Prophets of God." One wonders how he hung on to his job all those years! Of course the movie doesn't mention his career at BYU. More on that in a minute. The movie charges,
He has given this rationale for his rejection of the miracle of the flood: “Can one really fit ten million species onto a single ocean-going vessel, feed and care for them all with their often very restrictive diets or living conditions (many of which we are helpless to duplicate even with modern systems), and keep it all going with just eight people for an entire year? The answer, plainly, is no.”
I'll bet that's the least of the reasons Jeffery rejects a universal flood. (For more on the flood, see here.)

Toward the end, the movie starts to really lay it on thick. We are told that there are only two forces in this world (presumably good and evil). Then the law of witnesses is invoked along with woe pronounced against those who reject such witnesses. Speaking of witnesses, it's interesting to note how the power of General Authority quotes can be shaped by how they are introduced. "Elder so-and-so stated his opinion that..." doesn't quite pack the same puch as, "Elder so-and-so testified..." or "Elder so-and-so gave his witness..." So naturally, the movie describes the quotes with these terms.

There is no mention of more moderate sentiments expressed by Church leaders like David O. McKay, Heber J. Grant, Stephen L. Richards, James E. Talmage, or John A. Widtsoe, or even some of the allegedly hostile leaders, nor of the views expressed by such prominent Mormons as Henry Eyring. You also won't learn from the video that evolution is taught at BYU. Not only taught, but researched as well. These factors may or may not weigh heavily in how a person views evolution, and given the polemical agenda of the movie their absence is understandable. However, they do tend to undercut the implied message of the movie that the fate of your soul hangs in the balance based on your view of the science.

There is obviously some kind of affiliation between ZionVision and Brigham Young Academy.org (which, in case you are curious, is a sister to the Joseph Smith Academy.org, both of which are divisions of the Joseph Smith Foundation. None are affiliated with the Church.) They have compiled an impressive polemic of an FAQ on evolution, some of which contains exact passages from the movie. It's NDBF on steroids! (No relationship; I checked.) These folks are hard-core; they even call out FAIR (arguably the best LDS apologetic organization out there) and accuse it of mocking, ridiculing, and fighting against "the clear scriptural teachings and witnesses of the Prophets of God." Other honorees include Michael Ash, Steve Peck, and David Bailey. If they wanted to be thorough, they really should have included Hugh Nibley, too. (Yours truly somehow didn't make the list, in spite of almost six years of blogging. Do I have that little influence? I guess I can take some consolation that Mormons and Evolution, a group blog that I participated in for a while, is listed.)

Dealing With General Authority Statements

Although pronouncements by authorities do not determine the truth or falsity of a proposition (hence the logical fallacy), we look to the prophets and apostles as a source of truth, and their thoughts deserve consideration. This style of argumentation, where one is made to feel like s/he is rejecting the prophets, can therefore be quite difficult and frustrating to grapple with because, in its strongest form, there can be no counter-argument. Attempting to do so only validates the perception that you reject the prophets. And yet, we who defend science cannot remain silent or else the authoritarian bullies will be the only ones heard. So what can we do when confronted with such material? Here are a few suggestions to consider.

1. Recognize that these lists of General Authority statements are not merely intended to be informative. They are compiled in such a way as to give rhetorical advantage, and they are often embedded within an implied overarching narrative. Different statements could be strung together for a different effect (example). Consideration should be given to the full range of views expressed along with historical and cultural context. Resist efforts to reduce everything down to a simple black-and-white, good-and-evil story.

2. The cover letter to the BYU evolution packet, prepared in 1992 by the Board of Trustees (which includes the First Presidency), states: "Various views have been expressed by other Church leaders on this subject over many decades; however, formal statements by the First Presidency are the definitive source of official Church positions." Don't feel a need to reconcile every statement--even those by prophets.

3. When you dig below the surface of General Authority statements critical of evolution (or other science), it often turns out that they are actually defending some deeper principle such as the existence of God, morality, inspiration of scripture, etc. Be clear that you agree with the deeper principle.

4. Recognize that the zeal of the anti-evolution crusader is not reflected in the broader Church program. Many people who accept evolution serve as bishops and stake presidents, evolution is taught without apology in the science classes at Church schools, and Church-owned Deseret Book occasionally publishes books that are friendly--or at least moderate--toward evolution (eg. Mormon Scientist, Of Heaven and Earth, and Lenthen Your Stride: The Presidency of Spencer W. Kimball).

5. Study and use the example of Henry Eyring. During his life he successfully navigated these waters and is still held in high esteem in LDS culture.


Continue reading...

Monday, December 13, 2010

Bickmore Takes On Senator Hatch

BYU geologist Barry Bickmore has recently directed his ire toward Senator Orrin Hatch. First there's his post, Orrin Hatch and the Open Mind, then there are his op-eds in the Salt Lake Tribune and Deseret News from a couple of weeks ago.

DN: Global warming consensus matters

SLT: Separating truth and fiction in climate debate

Here's a taste from the Tribune:

Lately, opposition to mainstream climate science has become something of a litmus test for Republican politicians. As a Utah Republican myself, and an Earth scientist, I have been disappointed with how many of our politicians have gone beyond the usual wishy-washy dodge of saying they support “developing all sources of energy” to actively promoting anti-science....

Instead of wallowing in anti-scientific doubt-mongering, why can’t Republicans start garnering support for solutions to the climate change problem that don’t involve massive increases in government revenue and control?



Continue reading...

Monday, December 06, 2010

The Flood and the Baptism of Fire

Brigham Young is often cited as the origin of the teaching that Noah's Flood was the earth's baptism. However, although he did draw the comparison, he did so without much elaboration.

We are of the earth, earthy, and not only will the portion of mother earth which composes these bodies get a resurrection, but the earth itself. It has already had a baptism. You who have read the Bible must know that that is Bible doctrine. What does it matter if it is not stated in the same words that I use, it is one the less true that it was baptized for the remission of sins. The Lord said, "I will deluge (or immerse) the earth in water for the remission of the sins of the people;" or if you will allow me to express myself in a familiar style, to kill all the vermin that were nitting, and breeding, and polluting its body; it was cleansed of its filthiness; and soaked in the water, as long as some of our people ought to soak. The Lord baptized the earth for the remission of sins, and it has been once cleansed from the filthiness that has gone out of it, which was in the inhabitants who dwelt upon its face. [Journal of Discourses 1:274]
Orson Pratt took this idea to the next level and his logic seems to have become lodged in Mormon consciousness.
The first ordinance instituted for the cleansing of the earth, was that of immersion in water; it was buried in the liquid element, and all things sinful upon the face of it were washed away.... The second ordinance instituted for the sanctification of the earth, is that of fire and the Holy Ghost. The day will come when it shall burn as an oven, and all the proud, and all that do wickedly shall be as stubble; after which, the glory of God shall cover the earth, as the waters cover the deep. Here then is a baptism of fire first, then of the Holy Spirit. As man receives the baptism of fire and the Holy Spirit through the laying on of the hands of a legal administrator, so the earth receives the same, not through its own agency, but through the agencies ordained of God.... As man becomes a righteous man by the new birth, so the earth becomes a righteous earth through the same process. [Journal of Discourses 1:331 - 332, emphasis added]
A couple of months ago it occurred to me that there is a fundamental asymmetry here. The Flood was necessary and had to cover the whole earth, the logic goes, because it was a baptism, and we all know that baptism must be by immersion. But this pickiness for literalism in correspondence suddenly disappears when it comes to the baptism of fire. The problem is summarized with the following table:

Baptism:----Water----Fire

People-----Literal-----Metaphorical

Earth------Literal------Literal


I see two ways to salvage Pratt's logic. The first is to say that the burning of the earth at the second coming is metaphorical. The second:




Of course we could dispense with Pratt's logic and chalk the whole thing up to pioneer speculation, but that would remove one of the claimed imperatives for a literal global flood. What to do? Well, I'm definitely not going along with one of these options. I'll let you guess which one.


Continue reading...

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP