What the Big Bang Means for Mormons
Since we're on the topic of the Big Bang, I want to highlight an article from the FARMS Review (now Mormon Studies Review) in 2004: The Big Bang: What Does It Mean for Us? by Hollis R. Johnson, an emeritus professor of astronomy at Indiana University. The essay is a response to an evangelical critique of LDS doctrine, but it serves as a nice accessible introduction to cosmology. You should read the whole thing, but I'll give you the nickel version.
To understand the evangelical critique, you have to know that the original formulation of the Big Big bang envisioned the initial state of the universe as infinitely dense and infinitely small, known as a singularity. This fit nicely with creation ex nihilo, and also implied that if God exists in space and time, then he was a product of the Big Bang.
This notion of singularity has had a lot of staying power in the popular understanding of the Big Bang, but Johnson points out that science has moved on and the singularity has been discarded. For one thing, the notion of a singularity is at odds with quantum mechanics because it would violate the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. (I presume that this holds for black holes as well?) This and other questions gave rise to inflationary cosmology, and the concept of the multiverse.
So what does the multiverse mean for our theology? Well it supports the teaching that matter (i.e. energy) is eternal. It's less clear to me what it means for God or our future in this universe, but Johnson thinks it's premature to take a strong stand on these things anyway. He chastises critics for assuming any particular scientific model as the final truth, especially when dealing with a topic as large and mysterious as cosmology. His frustration with theologians comes through in these two gems:
Creation from nothing is clearly a fantasy devised by certain theologians, perhaps in a misguided attempt to glorify God by making of him a fantastic magician.
How long is eternity? Theologians can speculate forever, while scientists continue to provide a factual time line.The straightforward and unapologetic explanation of cosmology makes this essay one of my favorite FARMS Review essays.
Note:
I found a minor mistake that is hardly worth bringing up, but I'm going to anyway. Footnote 7 says: "Note that numbers in an exponent simply show the number of zeros after (+) or before (-) the given digits. For example, 105 means 1 followed by 5 zeros (100,000), and 10—9 means 1 preceded by a period and 9 zeros (.0000000001)." The first part is correct, but the second is not. 10—9 = .000000001; one preceded by eight zeros.

15 comments:
"This fit nicely with creation ex nihilo,"
Huwuh? How can it be ex-nihilo if all the matter/energy is already there, even if condensed into a singularity?
I suppose they would say that God brought the singularity into existence.
I seem to remember the JS taught that the universe had existed for billions of years. Reference anyone?
“That which has a beginning will surely have an end; take a ring, it is without beginning or end— cut it for a beginning place and at the same time you have an ending place.… As the Lord liveth, if it has a beginning it will have an end.” (Teachings of the Prophet Joseph Smith, 181, 354.)
W.W. Phelps wrote: "Well, now, Brother William, when the house of Israel begin to come into the glorious mysteries of the kingdom, and find that Jesus Christ, whose goings forth, as the prophets said, have been from of old, from eternity; and that eternity, agreeably to the records found in the catacombs of Egypt, has been going on in this system, (not this world) almost two thousand five hundred and fifty five millions of years: and to know at the same time, that deists, geologists and others are trying to prove that matter must have existed hundreds of thousands of years; -- it almost tempts the flesh to fly to God, or muster faith like Enoch to be translated and see and know as we are seen and known!"
I think the request was for a JS reference.
See http://bycommonconsent.com/2007/08/27/2555000000/
RE: "two thousand five hundred and fifty five millions of years."
W.W. Phelps was not talking to William Smith about "the grand beginning," he was talking about "this system," the system with which our earth is presently associated.
Brother Phelps explained the larger view differently:
-------------- quote --------------
“If you could hie to Kolob in the twinkling of an eye, And then continue onward with that same speed to fly, Do you think that you could ever, through all eternity, Find out the generation where Gods began to be? Or see the grand beginning, where space did not extend? Or view the last creation, where Gods and matter end? ...There is no end to matter; there is no end to space.” (Hymns, 1985, 284.)
-------------- end quote --------------
I'm not aware of any statement from JS that assigns a number to the age of the universe. The Phelps quote is the closest thing there is, I think--at least for putting a lower bound on it.
I suspect that we have to be careful with the word 'universe' because of differing perspectives. Connecting our use of terms with Joseph's teachings is risky business.
I think that JS's use of a ring to explain eternity, no beginning and no end, is a poor example, because the ring is really a loop. Reincarnation is that type of eternity. A person comes to earth and lives as some type of animal. The person dies and returns as another type of animal, and so on. Thus, life is a series of loops or rings. I don't understand reincarnation well enough to know if a person eventually reaches the point where he/she breaks out of the loop.
As I visulize eternity from the LDS viewpoint, I see it as a line that has no end when going in either direction. Visulizing something with no end is easy, but it's hard for our finite minds to visulize something with no beginning. We had a beginning at birth in mortality. We had, I assume, a beginning when we became spirit offsprings of our Father. I guess it's our basic intelligence that has no beginning but existed as something that could be enclosed by spirit matter and we thus became spirit offspring of our Father.
Getting back to the main theme in Jared's post, I've always liked the idea of a Big Bang, even though I don't understand it very well. The Garden of Eden story (it doesn't matter whether you take the story literally or metaphorically) teaches that the mortal earth had a beginning: Adam and Eve made their decision, and the earth became mortal. The Big Bang is merely attempts by scientists to explain from their viewpoint how mortality as we know it got started.
This is a little off topic, but to go along with Allen a bit, if you take Joseph's ring analogy too seriously, then you have to confront parts of our theology that have beginnings such as eternal marriage and the resurrection. Both are said to have no end, but both have beginnings.
I went from being a True Believer of officially sanctioned cosmology to a serious skeptic after I noticed (after many endowment sessions) that the temple teachings completely contradict it. The Electric Universe theory fits much better.
Even the Family Guy version of the Big Bang makes more sense than what I was taught in school.
Wage Slave -
How does the temple endowment contradict the big bang? The endowment doesn't have anything to do with the creation of the universe. It only discusses this earth (similarly to how God told Moses that there were many other worlds, but that He would only teach Moses about the earth upon which we live).
Hello! I love your blog, it's awesome!
I'm a 16-year old mormon girl from Finland. I'd love you to check my blog and leave your comment, because YOU're a good blogger! http://susanna-behindmyeyes.blogspot.com
Post a Comment