Abinadi and Resurrection Contraries
Joseph Smith once wrote that "by proving contraries, truth is made manifest" (History of the Church, 6:428). I noticed something incongruous in the Book of Mormon, and Joseph's statement seems apt for it. I don't imagine I am the first person to notice it, but I don't recall ever having seen it discussed before. First, let's lay the groundwork.
The Book of Mormon prophet Abinadi taught the following about the resurrection (Mosiah 15:21 - 25):
21 And there cometh a resurrection, even a first resurrection; yea, even a resurrection of those that have been, and who are, and who shall be, even until the resurrection of Christ—for so shall he be called.
22 And now, the resurrection of all the prophets, and all those that have believed in their words, or all those that have kept the commandments of God, shall come forth in the first resurrection; therefore, they are the first resurrection.
23 They are raised to dwell with God who has redeemed them; thus they have eternal life through Christ, who has broken the bands of death.
24 And these are those who have part in the first resurrection; and these are they that have died before Christ came, in their ignorance, not having salvation declared unto them. And thus the Lord bringeth about the restoration of these; and they have a part in the first resurrection, or have eternal life, being redeemed by the Lord.
25 And little children also have eternal life.
A straightforward reading of this passage has been summarized by Robert J. Matthews (I have re-numbered his points for the purposes of this post).
[1.] There is a first resurrection, consisting of those who have been, who are, and who shall be from the beginning down to the time of Christ. This means "all the prophets, and all those that have believed in their words, or all those that have kept the commandments"—they are the first resurrection (15:21-23).
[2.] Those who died in ignorance, before Christ came, to whom the plan of salvation was never declared, shall have part in the first resurrection (15:24).
[3.] "Little children [who die as little children] also have eternal life," which in the context of Abinadi's discourse means that they will be in the first resurrection (15:25).
Presumably, this 'first resurrection' is a reference to those who are said--in both the New Testament and the Book of Mormon--to have risen following the resurrection of Jesus. Matthews again:
The first resurrection that Abinadi spoke of consists of the righteous who lived from the time of Adam to the time of Christ. We who live after the time of Christ know of a "second session" of the first resurrection, one stretching from Jesus' time to his second coming and then on through the Millennium. Abinadi spoke from his perspective; we speak from ours.
With this in place, let's consider the resurrection in connection with archaeology. I've seen one LDS commentator speculate that empty tombs and graves discovered by archaeologists may be evidence that the person was resurrected, rather than that grave robbers and/or animals removed and destroyed the remains, or that they simply decayed. Of course there is no way to test such an idea since, as far as we know, resurrected bodies leave no identifying traces. Further, we have no idea whether any particular person would be judged worthy of inclusion in the first resurrection. And although Abinadi said that the ignorant would also be included, which would presumably include the vast majority of people, Matthews points out that modern revelation gives the caveat that "all who have died without a knowledge of this gospel, who would have received it if they had been permitted to tarry, shall be heirs of the celestial kingdom of God" (D&C 137:7).
So when archaeologists find human remains that pre-date ~30 B.C., can we infer that the person was either not righteous, or would not have received the gospel if they had access to it? The vast geographical and temporal range of discovered remains makes this a difficult proposition to accept, but we simply don't know what these people were like or how God would judge them.
But what about little children? If little children (who died as little children) up until the resurrection of Jesus were included in the first resurrection, as Abinadi seemed to say, then we can make a simple prediction: archaeologists should not find their bodily remains. How does this prediction hold up? Not well.
This child of 6-12 months, decorated with beads, lived and died over 8000 years ago. Click picture for more information.
And so we have a contradiction: Abinadi seems to be saying that little children are included in the first resurrection, which took place at the resurrection of Jesus. But archaeologists have found the remains of little children dating from before Jesus. We're missing something; there are several ways the contradiction might be resolved. Here are a few possibilities I can think of.
1. Matthews' interpretation of Abinadi is incorrect. Little children will have eternal life, but are not included in the (first) first resurrection. Abinadi's statement about children was really more of an afterthought.
2. Abinadi made an unjustified inference, or Alma (who wrote the original account) or Mormon (the editor) misunderstood Abinadi.
3. Alma (son of Alma) was a little unsure about the timing of the (first) first resurrection. "I do not say that their resurrection cometh at the resurrection of Christ; but behold, I give it as my opinion, that the souls and the bodies are reunited, of the righteous, at the resurrection of Christ, and his ascension into heaven [Alma 40:20]." Thus, although some people were resurrected at the time of Jesus' resurrection, Alma gives us some leeway to think that the (first) first resurrection has actually not been completed for some reason.
4. The (first) first resurrection was limited in scope and served more as a sign, both of Jesus' resurrection and of things to come, rather than a comprehensive event.
5. The resurrection does not necessarily incorporate surviving physical remains.
6. (For fun)--Just as (according to some) dinosaur fossils aren't really millions of years old, all discovered remains of little children really post-date ~30 B.C.
Some of these explanations are more likely than others. Arguments can be made against each of them. With respect to #5, statements by Joseph Smith and Joseph F. Smith (and probably others) indicate that the body you lay down is the one you take up. That a few bone fragments might be left out seems reasonable, but whole skeletons or mummified flesh?
So where does this leave us? There are several lessons we might draw out of this. We could talk about how we don't believe that prophets are infallible, or that canonized scripture can contain mistakes (see the title page of the Book of Mormon), or that our understanding can change as new facts and revelation come to light. It seems to me that this is a case where science clearly informs (or should inform) interpretation of scripture. Sometimes people draw a contrast between science and revelation--that whereas science is tentative and open to revision, the revelations are not because God only speaks the truth. However, I reject that division because the revelations must be interpreted, and those interpretations may be wrong, and because there is always a possibility that new revelation will dramatically revise the old.
In my view both science and scripture are tentative and open to revision.

12 comments:
My speculation about the first resurrection is that when Christ was resurrected, only those who were necessary parts of the gospel/restoration work on the earth were resurrected (for example, Moses, etc., who returned priesthood keys to Joseph). As far as I know, there aren't any credibnle accounts of archaeologists finding the remains of rightoues, biblically significant persons. The rest (anyone in the human race who died any time before the Second Coming) would be resurrected at the Second Coming of Christ, and be lifted up with the saints and other righteous who are on the earth at that time.
I've heard speculation that all of those will be heirs of the celestial kingdom, and that part of the resurrection would be referred to as the morning of the first resurrection. Then throughout the 1,000 years of the millennium, those who are destined for the terrestrial kingdom would be resurrected (the afternoon of the first resurrection).
After the 1,000 years are up, the morning of the second resurrection would take place (those who are determined to be part of the telestial kingdom), and at the end the final battle with Satan, the afternoon of the second resurrection would take place, which consists of the few who are consigned to outer darkness, at which time they and the devil are banished to outer darkness.
This is awesome. I taught the EQ lesson on the resurrection a few weeks back, and briefly brought this up--briefly mentioning your point #5 and a warning about taking every single thing in the scriptures too literally. I wasn't aware of the potential for controversy until you mentioned it here.
OK, let's work on the contraries.
1. Suppose that the remains that are uncovered contain imprints (soil, rock, whatever) of where the bones were at one time, but that the bone and all other parts of the individual in question have been resurrected.
2. Suppose that any actual bone uncovered is that of something that predates Adam and will never be resurrected.
3. Suppose that any actual bone is that of a son of perdition who lived at one time (this theory requires belief in multiple moralities) but lost the opportunity for resurrection when cast out in spirit form.
Statements by other prophets aside, I still lean toward #5. What if a person was killed in a place where their bones completely dissolved, then were absorbed by the surrounding vegetation? (I'm not a scientist, so I can't provide actual specifics on how this would take place. Suffice it to say it does not seem at all improbable.) Or what if they're cremated?
So what happens to them? If the resurrection is universal and literal, there must be some way of gathering the materials required for a body from the environment, even if there is nothing identifiable as human remains. If such a mechanism exists, doesn't that seem to imply that actual physical remains are not necessary for resurrection?
Joseph Smith is reported to have said, "There is no fundamental principle belonging to a human system that ever goes into another in this world or in the world to come; I care not what the theories of men are. We have the testimony that God will raise us up, and he has the power to do it. If any one supposes that any part of our bodies, that is, the fundamental parts thereof, ever goes into another body, he is mistaken."
I don't know how you would define what a "fundamental principle" is, but, if we're talking about regular chemistry, it seems clear to me that Joseph overreached on this one.
I actually like all of the possibilities (except 6), but I guess I favor both 4 and 5.
jared,
I'm not sure I follow you.
Is your #1 a proposal for how you might identify a resurrected body?
Your #2 could be true, but that doesn't solve the problem for any children dating from Biblical times.
I don't get #3. Especially if it's a child.
I'll clarify #1 and #3.
#1. I've read that when very old bones are found in the earth, all of the original organic material that made up the bone is gone; possibly resurrected. What is left for scientist to study is the mineralized shape of the bone that is formed by material other than the original organic bone.
#3. From the theory that each of us has or will live many times (multiple mortal probations)it can be deduced that some will be denied a resurrection because they became perdition. In other words, their body is never resurrected as their spirit go to outer darkness.
I admit #3 is far out. However, the early brethren left us with many far out ideas (based on today's standards) about Adam, creation, this earth, the resurrection, and etc.
Like the 10th AoF states, there is much yet to be revealed.
I think that the number of people who have been resurrected is a very small percentage of all the people who ever lived on this earth. What if it were less than 1/10 of a percent, including children?
Jared,
Even the sons of perdition will be resurrected, so I'm not sure #3 applies.
http://www.lds.org/scriptures/gs/sons-of-perdition?lang=eng
I'm more of the opinion that a resurrected body doesn't need to use the materials of the original body. I mean, why should it? Besides, the original material for (my estimate) 99.99% of all humans who have ever lived is incomplete.
I read a book by a professor from Tulane (I can’t remember his name), wherein he made the case that since DNA contains the entire computer code to create our body, perhaps that is the way the resurrection will occur. With the progress being made in bioengineering, it is not unreasonable to predict that someday we may be able to bioengineer an entire human body from a single molecule of DNA. If we can believe such a thing might be possible with our technology, certainly such a thing might be possible for God. So perhaps what God needs to perform the resurrection is just one molecule of DNA for every person who ever lives on Earth. I think I might be able to believe that there could be a molecule of DNA left from every person who has ever lived on the Earth, and with the right technology, it could be found and a new body bioengineered.
So put me down for option 5.a, i.e. the resurrection doesn’t incorporate all the surviving physical remains, but it does require one molecule of DNA.
To me, it has always seemed that Abinadi was a little bit confused about the nature of the godhead, so it wouldn't surprise me if he also did not have a complete understanding of the resurrection.
when very old bones are found in the earth, all of the original organic material that made up the bone is gone
That's true as one of the processes of fossilization. But that wouldn't apply in a very many cases--probably most cases in the last few thousand years. DNA has been extracted from 35,000+ year-old Neanderthal bone, for example.
I still think that the statements about taking up the same body can be reconciled, even if they weren't fully understood by the people who made them. Eliza R. Snow talked about how Joseph taught that there was some essential aspect of our bodies aside from the "gross" physical matter that was retained during the resurrection, and this was preserved, even if our bodies were eaten by wolves (she was speaking about some kids who died on the trek westward). I think it can be interpreted that what is retained is the pattern of information, not the exact atoms that were present previously. In fact, this is the only thing that could make sense, since our own bodies are not composed of the same matter they had a few years ago.
Post a Comment