Tuesday, March 06, 2012

Do Human Races Exist?

While the stir over the Bott gaffe on race was playing out last week, there was, coincidentally, a concurrent discussion in the science blogosphere about whether human races even exist, in a biological sense. Evolutionary biologist Jerry Coyne recently took up the issue, and gave his view that races do exist, but they are hard to define and probably not of much biological relevance except occasionally in medicine. Nick Matzke responded at The Panda's Thumb (see Matzke's post for links to Coyne) and argued that genetic clustering that is sometimes interpreted as demarcating race is actually an artifact of incomplete sampling. You can read a similar debate between anthropologists here.

It seems like this question is the kind of thing that can be argued over endlessly, in part because the answer depends on how you define your terms. This isn't my field, but to my mind the answer seems to be both yes and no. Yes, humans in a geographic area can share a genetic history leading to genetic differences from other geographic areas, a small part of which is manifested in outward (or skeletal) appearance. So it's obvious that native Scandinavians are different than native Africans. But no, there are not any discrete demarcations that allow firm categorizations (or that determine how many categories there should be), and most differences change gradually over geographic distance. So there's no such thing as a genetically "pure" Scandinavian or African. And of course in today's mobile society everything gets even more confused as formerly geographically isolated people are able to intermingle and have children together.

So it seems to me that to speak of biological races is to use a contextual term of convenience, but it's prone to misunderstanding because for most people races are cultural identifiers (whether they realize it or not). My two cents.


2 comments:

Matt Thorley,  3/08/2012 07:12:00 PM  

Jared,

Believe it or not, I agree with you for once. There appears to be no biological definition of “race” as we use the word currently. Of course in times past people referred to the “human race”, which I suppose would be close to the way we use the word species. In any event, it appears that there is no good biological definition for “race” as we currently use the word.

I’ve long thought we need to quit using “race” to differentiate people. Is President Obama white or black? I don’t know, and I don’t care. My children and grandchildren attend school with so many interracial children that it is just not a very functional word anymore.

As a result, I think we need to remove “race” as a basis for differentiating between people in law, employment practices, affirmative action, college admissions, etc. etc. That house of cards will eventually crumble because it is based on something that ultimately can’t be defined. I once asked an affirmative action officer of a local government how “race” was defined for purposes of awarding government contracts. He told me “race” was self declared. I told him great, I hereby declare myself “black” for purposes of bidding on the contract. He said you can’t do that. I said why not? Because, he said, you are obviously not black. Why not, I asked. I just declared myself black. He never did provide a logical answer.

This issue hits close to home for those of us who served as missionaries prior to 1978. I was never comfortable with the Church policy and how we missionaries were instructed to implement it. It was very hard to define back then, which is probably because it was indeed indefinable. It did not, and it still does not, change my testimony, but I wish I had been able to serve after 1978.

Jared*,  3/08/2012 09:10:00 PM  

Glad to see we agree on something. Actually, we probably agree on a lot of things.

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP