Saturday, February 25, 2012

Heartland Institute Heartbreak

The drama unfolding around the release of internal documents of the Heartland Institute (HI) has been interesting, if unfortunate, to watch. In case you've not been following the action, someone posing as a board member of the HI obtained internal documents concerning funding, plans, etc, and anonymously sent them to DeSmogBlog. The HI is probably the most prominent of global warming skeptic "think tanks," and DeSmogBlog covers the corporate attempts to obscure climate issues. We now know that the anonymous poser was climate scientist Peter Gleick, who publicly admitted his role and apologized.

My judgment was blinded by my frustration with the ongoing efforts -- often anonymous, well-funded, and coordinated -- to attack climate science and scientists and prevent this debate, and by the lack of transparency of the organizations involved. Nevertheless I deeply regret my own actions in this case. I offer my personal apologies to all those affected.
Gleick's actions are unfortunate for at least two reasons. First, they were arguably unethical and unlawful, but certainly dishonest, and that dishonesty will hurt more than just him. Second, they distract attention from what the HI has been up to (serving as a policy front group for corporate donors, creating an educational curriculum, etc), and may even create a feeling of sympathy for HI among the public.

I'm reminded of Doctrine and Covenants 10:28:
Verily, verily, I say unto you, wo be unto him that lieth to deceive because he supposeth that another lieth to deceive, for such are not exempt from the justice of God.

But I can't help but note the asymmetry here. Gleick's actions have been condemned by Nature and other climate scientists, as well as prompted his resignation from several science organizations. I expect that similar consequences will continue to play out.

Meanwhile, it seems that amongst the climate skeptic community that there is nothing too false or misleading that can't be used to undermine mainstream climate science. Whether taking stolen emails out of context or pushing plainly incorrect information, there just doesn't seem to be any cost for dishonesty, let alone incompetence, amongst climate skeptics.

Sign of the times, I suppose.


4 comments:

Anonymous,  2/27/2012 10:37:00 PM  

Good post. I just need to disagree with you on one small point. What Gleick did was not horrible, lamentable, or even a huge lapse in judgment. What the oil industry does, what the science shills and PR firms and everyone does for money that puts this planet at risk, is wrong. What Dr. Gleick did was what journalists would be doing everywhere if they weren't asleep at the wheel. He exposed a huge fraud, for the public good. And for this he's taking heat? Whatever happened to the honor and protections afforded to whistleblowers?

And "asymmetrical"? You call a billion to one difference in something "asymmetrical"? Maybe there's a better word. Just sayin'..

Matt Thorley,  3/08/2012 05:15:00 PM  

Jared,

Just days before this incident The Heartland Institute had invited Gleick to speak at one of their functions. I know HI holds an annual conference in NYC. I don’t know if it was that conference or some other, but Gleick declined the offer. Then in offering his apology, he cited his frustration with the lack of debate on this important subject.

If this issue is really so important, and it’s not just politics as I (and many others) suspect, why can’t we have the most prominent “warmist” scientists debate the most prominent “denier” scientists in a neutral setting. As far as I can see, both sides are mostly just “preaching to the choir”, but it appears HI has at least made the offer.

Jared*,  3/08/2012 09:07:00 PM  

Matt,

I think Gleick was talking about debate in the broader sense. But whatever.

I know of two debates (though there may be others). Andrew Dressler and Richard Lindzen debated back in 2010, and Scott Denning and Roy Spencer debated at an HI conference last year.

They may have some use, but live debates aren't well suited to work out scientific truth. They tend to be more about showmanship, and participants can get away with saying all manner of falsehoods. Political debates illustrate the problem.

Anonymous,  3/20/2012 08:56:00 PM  

Ugh. I want to like a blog named "LDS Science Review", but Global Warming/Climate Change keeps coming up. This hobby horse has no legs. Please give it up. It just seems to be an excuse to argue and look down on other people.

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP