Another Reason Flood Geology Doesn't Make Sense
I've had this post percolating in the back of my mind for a while. I don't know why I got to thinking about it recently, but it's been a while since I've posted on creationism, so here it is.
According to young-earth creationists (YECs), the Grand Canyon was formed by water run-off from Noah's flood, perhaps in as little time as days (the Flood having deposited the sediment in the first place). It's a position they are forced into given the premise that the earth is only about 6,000 years old. How else do you form the Grand Canyon in so short a time?
Two years ago my family and I visited Arches National Park in Utah. Before heading home for the day we stopped at Dead Horse Point, which is near the park and overlooks the Colorado River. (See Utah Geology Show and Tell.) It isn't the Grand Canyon but it is impressive, and if creationists are right it must surely have been formed at the same time as the Grand Canyon. However, something struck me as strange. Have a look at this picture and see if you notice what I did.
If you noticed the U-turn in the river, you are a winner. Here is what it looks like from above, via Google Maps.
Moving water can be extremely powerful. So how is it that water powerful enough to purportedly carve out such large and deep canyons in a short amount of time was forced to make this loop? This isn't an isolated occurrence; use Google Maps to explore the Colorado River and its tributaries and you'll find many other examples of these kinds of meanders. My favorite one is Horseshoe Bend, which is just southwest of Page, AZ.
Again, this is the Colorado River--just about 100 miles upstream of the Grand Canyon. And again, why would such powerful water be forced to take this circuitous route, especially if the sediment was soft--having just recently been deposited? (For more fun, go look up Gooseneck State Park.)
I'm not any kind of authority on geology or hydrodynamics, but I figured I couldn't be the first one to notice this problem. I was right; it's one of a number of problems with the YEC view of the formation of the Grand Canyon listed at talk.origins. The mainstream view on the formation of the Grand Canyon is covered in this Wikipedia entry. It's actually kind of complicated. But lest you think that geologists don't believe in catastrophic floods, read about the scablands of Washington State, where there were possibly as many as 100 catastrophic floods that originated from a lake in Montana.

13 comments:
Jared*:
I just don't know how anyone can look at the beautiful stratification and the intricate river bends and then conclude the geological age is just a few thousand years old.
Further, I cannot understand why anyone is threatened by standard geological interpretation.
The Grand Canyon is ancient, and we should still go to Church. Where's the conflict?
I don't see it as an "either/or proposition". One of the more plausible syntheses is outlined by Eric Skousen in his book "Earth In The Beginning". He maintains that, although man's recorded history is only 6,000 years old dating back to Adam & Eve, the Earth's history dates much further back because we have to account for carbon-14 dating, despite its imperfections.
Like S.Faux, I don't see the conflict either.
Good point. But, I believe it is possible that the U-turn was formed by the run-off from Noah's flood. I'm not saying that's what happened, but I'm saying it is possible.
The story is told about how Columbus challenged a group of his opponents to stand an egg upright on its end. After all of them had tried and none had succeeded, they concluded that that it couldn't be done. Whereupon Columbus took the egg and gently dropped its small end on the table. The shell broke a little and the egg stood upright. The men had thought it not possible until Columbus showed them how.
I never assume, because I cannot do something, that God cannot do it either. "God is able to do his own work," said Joseph Smith. And that's true whether we understand it or not. My faith on this point was well expressed by President Monson, who said: "I cannot explain the miracles of the Bible, and I do not attempt to do so, but I accept God’s word." (Nov. 13, 2007)
You're right "Flood Geology Doesn't Make Sense".
And standard geology 101 you learn at any decent university does.
I don't understand why people are willing to give up science that clearly works just because they think it contradicts their people's religious opinions. History shows with good science we can solve problem after problem and with junk science we lose all kinds of important advances and technology, etc...
Great post Jared*.
Gary,
I like what Sterling Talmage said: "...God cannot perpetrate an absurdity. I admit that, in the realm of miracles, I am not wise enough to say in every case what constitutes an absurdity; but some of them are not hard to recognize.
I wonder what his Apostle Dad would have thought about that.
Replaying the tired and boring "young/old Earth" argument is a waste of time. Such dust-ups have gotten us nowhere for the last couple of centuries. Here's a thought: Maybe the Grand Canyon, like Valles Marinaris on Mars, wasn't formed by erosion. Perhaps is was formed by electric discharge machining, which can create the same meandering morphology. Indeed, electric discharge may be the source of all planetary morphology. While mainstream geology refuses to consider the possibility, the thesis is nonetheless sound. If you can look at the theory with unprejudiced eyes, you will find it a much better and more satisfying answer to the age old question of planet formation and age. Familiarize yourself with the tenets of the Electric Universe. (www.thunderbolts.info) From that point of view, the scriptures, ancient history and geology are reconciled -- a neat trick for any upstart theory. Look into it. I think you'll enjoy the experience, if you will keep an open, unbiased mind. It's certainly a better use of your good time and intelligence than squabbling over this tasteless scrap of nonsense.
Just don't open your mind so far your brain falls out!
Perhaps those canyons with rivers in them that we can observe changing slowly due to the rivers in them were formed slowly by the rivers in them. Just a thought.
People hang onto cartoonish religious dogmas because otherwise they have to admit they were wrong. And possibly pay attention in class and read books. Neither are things most people care too much for.
Another cool little tid bit about the area that I read in "Carving Grand Canyon: Evidence, Theories, and Mystery" ( which I purchased in the Grand Canyon book store )deals with tributaries of the Colorado river. If you look at the direction of the tributaries, they tend to double back on the direction water flows in the Colorado. If you look at other major rivers, their tributaries tend to flow on the same direction as the river. This plus other evidence leads geologists to believe the river once flowed in the opposite direction (West to East) and changed direction as the Colorado Plateau was pushed up. Cool!
Here's another thought on the flood theory... how convenient is it that, once the flood waters receded and carved the grand cayon, there happened to be a major river waiting around to fill the channel left behind! A perfect place for the Egyptians to hide their booty too.
To re-emphasize Jack Mormon, even though from the fall to now was only 6000 years, we don't know how long it took H.F. to create the earth OR how long A&E were hanging out in the Garden before they partook the fruit. Those seven "days" of creation were not 24 earth-hour periods.
I see no conflict.
I agree with Dave and Jack Mormon. A "day" in Hebrew means "period of time." And again, are they our days or God's days?
I wonder what his Apostle Dad would have thought about that.
Gary,
I'm glad you brought that up. The quote comes from "An Open Letter to Elder Joseph Fielding Smith," which was written by Sterling in response to the same speech that upset B.H. Roberts.
Sterling sent his father a draft, and Elder Talmage made some suggested edits. He also instructed Sterling to send a copy both to Elder Smith and the First Presidency, and instructed him what to put in the cover letters. He also wrote: "The conditions are peculiar but in my judgment and in that of certain others it is well to follow the course indicated."
This is all published in Can Science Be Faith-Promoting? The editor, Stan Larson, noted several changes in the final letter from the rough draft. I don't know whether they constitute all the changes.
In summary, I think it is likely that Elder Talmage did read the quote in question and did not object, but I can't be sure without seeing the original draft (which is at the U of U).
The question here is not what one believes. People believe all kinds of things. It is, rather, what the evidence suggests. The earth bears solemn testimony of its past and origins and that testimony should be treated with the respect it deserves. Besides, unlike human testimonies which sometimes come and go, the earth's abideth forever.
Post a Comment