Friday, October 13, 2006

Providential Plants: The Danger

My last post used Alma 46:40 as a starting point to discuss the role of God in medicinal plants and I mentioned that some people take such scriptures literally. In discussing what science may look like in the millennium, John Pratt (of Meridian Magazine) cites the scripture above and then writes [1]:

Continue Reading


It will probably be discovered in the millennium that the modern practice of trying to extract the one "miracle ingredient" from a plant has overlooked the fact that the Creator has put a combination of chemicals and enzymes together for a certain purpose. Note also that the scripture does not say "to mask symptoms," which seems to be the modern quick-fix method of taking medicine for relief without getting to the cause of the problem.
In my view this is wrongheaded. As stated before, organisms do not produce substances solely as a favor to other organisms. Furthermore, although reductionism in medical science may not always be a virtue, understanding the molecular actions of drugs is important. But beyond that, this passage gives the impression that ancient healers had wisdom and understanding surpassing modern doctors, or that we would be better off with less precision in our drug research. There is no doubt that traditional healers hit on some useful discoveries, but it is demonstrable that the lion-share of medical success has come in recent decades through the application of scientific knowledge. There may be room for legitimate criticism of quick-fix mentality, but our ability to understand and treat the real causes of disease is unparalleled in history. If God really prepared such a pharmacopoeia for the use of man, I can't help but wonder why he didn't provide more information about it.

But is there harm in the providential view? Certainly not in and of itself. However some adopt the mindset that 'natural' (whatever that means) is equal to 'good' and become consumers of alternative medicine. The alternative medicine industry is not subject to the same oversight and regulation that mainstream medicine is, which means that as long as the producers of such products word their claims carefully they do not have to prove the efficacy--or even the safety--of their products [2,3]. In my view privileging alternative medicine (such as 'natural' dietary supplements) over mainstream medicine in the pursuit of God's natural cures is a mistake that can be harmful to health.



1. One of my first posts on this blog was a review of this article.
2. For a critical summary of natural supplements see here.
3. Overview of Dietary Supplements, FDA, 2001
Unlike drug products that must be proven safe and effective for their intended use before marketing, there are no provisions in the law for FDA to "approve" dietary supplements for safety or effectiveness before they reach the consumer. Also unlike drug products, manufacturers and distributors of dietary supplements are not currently required by law to record, investigate or forward to FDA any reports they receive of injuries or illnesses that may be related to the use of their products. Under DSHEA, once the product is marketed, FDA has the responsibility for showing that a dietary supplement is "unsafe," before it can take action to restrict the product's use or removal from the marketplace.


6 comments:

Anonymous,  10/14/2006 03:16:00 AM  

Jared,

I've enjoyed your last couple of posts. I find the writing of John Pratt interesting because it seems he accuses drug companies of searching for a "cure all" medicine. I think most drugs are developed for a specific purpose. Also most people I know who think they've found the "miracle ingredient" are naturalists and practice alternative medicine. For example, in Puerto Rico ginger was the cure for any ailment. It's not to say ginger doesn't cure all, but it hasn't always worked for me. Let's not get into placebo effects here.

I also disagree with the idea that drug companies are looking for drugs just "to mask symptoms." When we know the pathophysiology of a disease we use drugs to stop the disease. If we don't know that pathophysiology we try to relieve symptoms, based on our understanding of what is causing those symptoms. As much as I hate drug companies, they do a lot of good at curing disease, slowing disease and relieving symptoms.

It appears that his view also discredits any idea that the Creator might inspire those developing drugs.

Anyway, thanks for the posts. They keep me good company while I'm on OB/GYN nights.
Doug

Unknown,  10/14/2006 03:03:00 PM  

Jared,

Interesting idea to consider, but let's not confuse theory and observation. The theory is that plants should not do things to benefits others. The observation is, and the word of the Lord is, that there are such plants.

Perhaps it is that we do not understand Evolution in this particular instance, or perhaps we have some kind of 'directed evolution' or some combination thereof. But whatever we do, we need to remember that "organisms do not produce substances solely as a favor to other organisms" is theory, to be validated or invalidated. I am not saying this to knock evolution. I just don't want sloppy science.

Also, let us remember that there are far more injuries recorded from drugs than from herbs. We can argue the reasons for such a thing, but that is the fact. Considering the corruption in drug approval, I think that the current legistlation works to level the playing feild. But not to worry, there are laws in the works to change that.

Anonymous,  10/14/2006 09:24:00 PM  

Just a quick response while I'm at work--

"...let us remember that there are far more injuries recorded from drugs than from herbs."

I think the key word here is "recorded." Because herbs aren't studied to even a fraction of the extent that drugs are, so of course drugs have a history and herbs have...what? hearsay? Also, drugs are designed to actually do something, whereas many herbal "remedies" do nothing medicinal at all.

Jared*,  10/14/2006 11:04:00 PM  

Glad I can help your cause, Doug.

Sungazer makes a good point about theory vs. observation, and of course we cannot prove a negative. As for observation, helpful plants exist but the issue is whether they produce such substances in an exclusively altruistic manner.


I think BrianJ makes a good point about data collection. A quick Google search turned up this article.

Unknown,  10/15/2006 11:03:00 PM  

I don't want to thread-jack this, but more studies do not mean better science. In fact 1/3 of medical studies are found to be in error. Just today in the New Scientist where was an article on drug studies. http://www.newscientist.com/article.ns?id=dn10296&feedId=online-news_rss20

And yes, there is reasearch on medicinal herbs, and they do have their uses. But I like to keep as many references as I can on the herbs I use. Both herbs and modern medicine have their places.

Sungazer

Jared*,  10/15/2006 11:21:00 PM  

Sungazer,

You won't get any criticism from me for using herbs if you are doing so with good information.

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP