Shortcut to the Spirit
NEW YORK (AP) -- People who took an illegal drug made from mushrooms reported profound mystical experiences that led to behavior changes lasting for weeks -- all part of an experiment that recalls the psychedelic '60s....(There is also a Q&A with the lead research here.)
Psilocybin has been used for centuries in religious practices, and its ability to produce a mystical experience is no surprise. But the new work demonstrates it more clearly than before, Griffiths said.
Even two months after taking the drug, pronounced SILL-oh-SY-bin, most of the volunteers said the experience had changed them in beneficial ways, such as making them more compassionate, loving, optimistic and patient. Family members and friends said they noticed a difference, too.
I have not followed it much, but there is a relatively new branch of science called neurotheology that seeks to understand the brain's involvement in religious experiences. You may recall that several years ago scientists imaged the brains of people (monks, nuns, or some such) while they were having religious experiences (mystical connections with the universe, etc.)
These types of things naturally turn our minds to the operations of the Spirit. We often talk of the Spirit in terms of feeling, which leads me to strongly suspect that there is a neurological basis for our perceptions of the Spirit. Just how it operates and how it is triggered (rightly or wrongly) would be fascinating to know.
So I'll pose two questions:
1. Should we seek to understand the brain's involvement in religious experience?
2. The mystical experiences above seemed to induce change in people's behavior for the better. What if we could offer criminals help in changing their behavior by giving them such a drug?

10 comments:
I didn't touch on near-death experiences in this post, but they are worth thinking about in this context.
I'm all for it. I think Mormon's, of all the christian religions, should have the most basis for a support of such research.
In the documentary New York Doll the washed-up punk rocker (I forget his name already) describes his confirming answer to the truth of the Book of Mormon as being something along the lines of 'a trip, but without the LSD.'
#1: The research will inevitably be done. We need to consider the implications of the possible findings whether we are involved in doing the research or not.
#2: Before making such a suggestion, consider the following from the same CNN story:
Almost a third of the research participants found the drug experience frightening even in the very controlled setting.
Christian,
I saw that movie a month ago. Thanks for reminding me of that.
last lemming,
Of course you are right about #1. We can explore that here, but it might even be worth its own post.
As for #2, your point is good as far as it goes. I was not suggesting that we start administering this drug. It was more of a speculative future scenario--assume that we understand the phenomenon better. On the other hand, the scriptures would seem to support a useful role for scarey experiences also.
#1: Yes, let's do it. Last Lemming is correct in saying that it will happen anyway. Spiritual experiences seemingly must have physical manifestations, even at the atomic level. But we will need to be careful about the worldly interpretation of the outcome of the studies.
#2: We already use a wide variety of mood altering and mind altering drugs in our society, with varying degrees of success and varying degrees of side effects. A relative of my wife's can keep herself out of prison simply by staying on her meds. If she goes off them, she's back in. So, I suppose I would be in favor of anything that could *safely* benefit people with these kinds of problems.
Sorry, Jared. I couldn't help myself...
#1. What would be the point of understanding the brain's involvement in religious experiences, other than for mere curiosity's sake?
#2. I acknowledge the benefits of drugs within society (I'm no Tom Cruise), but I just wonder... If we just gave drugs to criminals to MAKE them behave a certain way, how are we helping them better themselves or teaching them how to better themselves (give a man a fish v. teach a man to fish)? Would criminals be responsible enough to take this drug as needed? What if the drug were to become unavailable during, say, a power outage (or worse crisis), and a bunch of "drugged" criminals were living within society? Why not spend the money on prevention of criminal behavior (ex. pornography, etc.) rather than on treatments?
In my mind, there just seems to be a debate between force v. free agency... but perhaps criminals have already proven themselves incapable of handling agency.
Matronne,
I wasn't referring to forced perpetual medication. I had in mind a boost to help those who want to, to change.
"I wasn't referring to forced perpetual medication."
Yes, you were. :)
Does this drug really result in permanent behavioral change? Perhaps becoming "perfect" isn't so unattainable afterall.
It's what keeps me from being a total jerk!
Post a Comment