Sunday, July 30, 2006

The Scientific Altar Call

Several month ago, BrianJ at Cold and Calculating offered some advice on what to do when weighing the opinion of scientific experts.

If you feel like you just have to know which theory is right–what to believe–then I suggest you become a scientist yourself and join in the search.

But if you just want to know what to teach your kids, how to spend your tax dollars for research, or which textbook to use, then I don’t think you have to believe anything. You just want to know which theory to accept, and you’d do best to go with the theory supported by the majority of scientists, especially if it is a vast majority.

What’s the difference? To believe a theory requires knowledge, time, effort, and study. To accept a theory just means that you act in accordance with it.
To take this one step further, a person can accept--or even believe--a scientific principle or theory without pledging some kind of metaphysical allegience to it. In fact, since science is by nature tentative, you would be wise not to.

Science plays an important role in many aspects of life, but ultimately there is no scientific altar call.

2 comments:

BrianJ,  7/31/2006 10:43:00 AM  

Mark Butler: "[Scientists] do not distinguish between our best available theory...that might change overnight from something that is so reliable that within its domain of application it is inconceivable that it will ever change."

That has not been my observation.

"I would prefer that the public schools made the distinction, i.e. taught the true spirit of scientific hypothesis and discovery."

I agree that public schools do not correctly teach that science is a process of discovery and not a collection of facts. Moreover, they do not teach how those discoveries are made. If this were taught, students would have little difficulty distinguishing between tenative and immutable theories on their own.

BrianJ,  8/01/2006 12:18:00 PM  

Mark Butler: I recognized your qualifier (ie. "when dealing with the public") and was responding to your qualified statement. I did not mean to ignore that when I (mis)quoted you.

I think the problem may be in how I read part of your first post; I may have misunderstood. When you wrote, "so many," it seemed to me that you really meant "the majority." I agree that their are some irresponsible, hype-driving scientists, but I do not think it is the majority.

I think your second comment illustrates my position quite well: "The scientists most in the public eye did not insert lots of qualifiers" (emphasis added). Many scientists are misquoted, but I think many more are simply ignored by reporters looking for a good story. For every scare quote on a PBS program there may be an entire institute issuing qualified statements. The problem in my mind is where the public chooses to get its science.

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP