Review of At the Water's Edge
In the public debate over evolution few people argue about the occurance of microevolution--it has been so clearly demonstrated that most anti-evolutionists conceed this level of change in species. Much more contentious is the debate over macroevolution--the process that gives rise to major groups. What is the evidence for such transitions, how do they happen, and why? These questions are addressed by Carl Zimmer in his first book, At the Water's Edge.
Continue Reading
Zimmer, a respected science journalist, takes us on a journey from water to land, and back to water again. The first half of the book deals with the transition of water-dwelling lobe-fined fish to terrestrial tetrapods almost 400 million years ago, while the second half describes the origin of cetaceans (whales, dolphins, etc.) around 50 million years ago. There are lessons in history, anatomy, physiology, cladistics, and development that are smoothly explained and easy to take in. These mini-lessons are often set in larger narratives that explain the history and progression of scientific discovery. Sometimes Zimmer takes us out on digs where we get to watch paleontologists at work discovering dramatic examples of transitional fossils.
There are certainly questions still to be answered and this book will not be the last word on the subjects it covers. It is nevertheless a good introduction to the issues at hand. The writing is not all third person; Zimmer's interviews with scientists allow us to hear their perspective in their own words. The book also has a number of illustrations that help to convey concepts and suggest what some of the extinct transitional animals may have looked like. There is also a small glossary to help with some of the scientific terminology.
Read the book--what more can I say?

5 comments:
BTW, in my paperback version, all illustrations are black and white.
Saw the animated version in Disney's "Fantasia" almost fifty years ago.
Another BTW--the illustrator, Carl Buell, has his own blog here.
It seems to me that if you accept microevolution, then you must accept macroevolution on at least some level. Take the following scenario, for example:
A population of a certain species is separated into two isolated groups by a change in geography (like an ice age or continental drift). The two groups are no longer able to intermingle and interbreed and will each follow a separate microevolutionary track. If the separation persists over a long enough interval (tens of thousands to millions of years), the changes due to microevolution will eventually result in the two groups no longer being compatible with each other, creating two species from one.
In fact, geographic isolation is a major factor in speciation. This appears to have been the case with Neanderthals. They were isolated from other hominids in Europe by the last ice age. By the time the ice receded, Homo neanderthalensis was no longer compatible with Homo sapiens.
Relgious skeptics would probably argue that the separated species would still be the same "kind," ie. birds would still be birds, and so forth.
That's why it's nice to have more fossil evidence of dramatic transitions--much of which has only come to light in the last 20 years or so.
Also, the increasing knowledge of developmental biology is helping to bridge the gap in understanding of how changes in genes and their regulation translates in to different morphology.
Post a Comment