Friday, February 03, 2006

Judging Miracles: My Approach

I hope my last post didn't raise expectations too high for a profound analysis of miracles. I'm just going to throw out a few of my thoughts on the subject.

Continue Reading


As background, there are at least two great talks on miracles in Church literature. This talk by Elder Oaks, and this talk by Elder Matthew Cowley. On a more practical level, I really enjoy Michael Ash's take on miracles.

"Recognizing that miracles are harmonious with natural (although perhaps unknown) laws gives reason to suggest that some of the “miracles” of scriptural times might be understood in accordance with natural phenomenon with which we are familiar, while other “miracles” might be supported by natural laws with which we are still unfamiliar. Miracles such as the Resurrection, Jesus' walking on the water, his healing of the lame and blind, etc., appeal to natural laws that still allude us. Other miracles, such as the parting of the Red Sea, the manna from heaven, etc., might possibly be explained by phenomenon with which we are familiar – this no less makes such occurrences, “miracles.” Although an earthquake may be the result of the shifting of tectonic plates, for instance, it is no less of a miracle when the timing, location, and outcome is directed by the Lord or by the hand of the Lord's prophet."

I am perfectly comfortable with many miracles having more limited and natural explanations. In many cases I don't think it really matters. My basic philosophy is that I will not deny God the power to do anything that He or his prophets have not ruled out--but we have to deal with what we have in terms of evidence, if there is any.

Did God actually cause the whole earth to be flooded in the time of Noah and kill all land life not on the ark? I won't deny God the ability to do so in principle, but we have to deal with what we have. In order to believe that God flooded the whole earth I must also believe that he erased any trace of it and planted contrary evidence, so I favor a more limited explanation of local floods. (As an aside, imagine you had never seen the ocean before and you were washed out into the open sea. Wouldn't you think the whole earth was flooded?)

So I find myself with a mix of skepticism and faith. I am not willing to throw out miracles, but neither do I automatically accept them all at face value. I guess I could summarize my approach with several questions. For any miraculous claim, (i) how trustworthy is the source? (ii) is there a more limited or natural explanation? (iii) does it matter?

It's not an objective or unbiased approach, but it's the best I've got at the moment.

(By the way, note that Elder Oaks proposes a more natural explanation for the miracles performed by Pharaoh's magicians.)

7 comments:

Capt. Obsidian,  2/04/2006 03:07:00 AM  

Jared,
I tend to have a similar approach to miracles. I saw a program on the Discovery Channel (or a related channel) a few years back about the plagues in Egypt. As I recall, they were able to propose reasonable scientific causes for each of the plagues (except the killing of the firstborn). It also turned out that several of them were logical consequences of a preceding plague. I wish I could remember all the details. I'll have to look it up.

Anonymous,  2/06/2006 01:58:00 AM  

Jared,

You pose this question, "Imagine you had never seen the ocean before and you were washed out into the open sea. Wouldn't you think the whole earth was flooded?"

The answer is obvious. And certainly there are faithful LDS who take this view. But let me simply point out that this view assumes Moses was the victim of a misunderstanding when he wrote about the Flood.

May I outline second point of view without disparaging the first?

This view also addresses your question about how trustworthy the source is because I think Moses did see the ocean, all of it, before he wrote Genesis. In fact, it appears that Moses "beheld the world [and] the ends thereof, and all the children of men which are, and which were created."

And again, Moses "beheld the earth, yea, even all of it; and there was not a particle of it which he did not behold [and] he beheld also the inhabitants thereof, and there was not a soul which he beheld not."

I also believe that, prior to writing Genesis, Moses was interviewed by God himself, who surely knows whether the Flood was local or universal, and who said to Moses, "I will speak unto thee concerning this earth upon which thou standest; and thou shalt write the things which I shall speak."

So if Moses saw the whole earth and its entire history in vision and if he was interviewed by God himself regarding what he should write, I think it is doubtful that Moses was the victim of a misunderstanding when he wrote about the Flood.

That's my view, and as I say, the mention of it is not intended to belittle or find fault with yours.

Jared*,  2/06/2006 04:38:00 PM  

Gary,

Yours is certainly a scripturally defensible position, and one that I have held.

I'm not going to argue what Moses did or didn't see, or know, or write. The JST notwithstanding, we could probably raise some legitmate unanswerable questions on those points.

I'm not against anything you wrote in principle, I just think other considerations also have a bearing on the matter. I think my position does less damage to the scriptures than yours does to the sciences. Given more data, perhaps I would change my mind.

Jeff G,  2/18/2006 03:13:00 PM  

I have a post which I will publish on Monday which has a tentative approach to this question. Here is my take:

"Dennett [claims] that the only way in which we can objectively verify that something is in fact a miracle is by subjecting it to intense scientific and naturalistic scrutiny and demonstrating that science is unable to account for such phenomena. This seems fine in principle but I’m not sure that this is really the road Dennett wants to take in practice.

After all, this is exactly what the ID movement attempts to do with its claims of Irreducible Complexity. The response from the scientists is as follows “Many of those phenomena have been explain scientifically, and as to those which have not yet been so explained we have no reason to suspect that they will not eventually be accounted for as well.” The scientist’s response is perfectly legit, as I’m sure Dennett himself would claim, but this response pretty much takes all of the wind out of the sail of his proposed scientific verification of miracles.

But this then begs the question which Dennett was attempting to answer, how can a miracle be objectively verified in practice? Perhaps one’s confidence in the miraculous nature of some phenomenon can be strengthened, but never completely solidified by science’s inability to account for it, just as the scientist’s confidence in a theory can be strengthened, but never completely solidified by experimental confirmation. This, of course, would presuppose a form of Dennett's method of verification. Aside from this, I’m not aware of any good answer to this question."

This approach seems fairly objective as well as sufficiently humble in scope.

Jared*,  2/18/2006 04:12:00 PM  

Jeff,

I won't make you extend the discussion here, since you intend to post on your own blog. I think you do make a good point about comparing Dennett's test for miracles with ID.

I think that until miracles can be performed on command or on a regular basis we will fundamentally lack the ability to confirm them.

Jeff G,  2/19/2006 10:57:00 PM  

BTW, I saw that you started reading Evo Devo. I recently finished "Evolution in Four Dimensions" which treats a lot of the same material though obviously geared toward the lay reader. It was really good and I highly recommend it.

The four dimensions were:
1. Genetic
2. Epigenetic (Devo)
3. Behavioral
4. Symbolic

The book gave the strongest defense of a partially guided evolution that I have ever seen. Their basic argument is that since we (surviving species) have been able to evolve some of the most wonderful features which help us avoid extinction, what would keep us from evolving systems which are able to control our evolving to a certain extent? Why could we not have evolved systems which respond to selective pressures with a higher amount of variation overall as well in in specific areas?

Jared*,  2/19/2006 11:44:00 PM  

Sounds a little like the evolution of evolution.

Thanks, I'll keep the book in mind.

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP