Thursday, January 12, 2006

Sen. Chris Buttars on KUER

Utah Senator Chris Buttars was recently interviewed on KUER. You can listen to the interview here. Most of the program concerns homosexuality, but Buttars' bill dealing with evolution in schools is discussed 37.5 min into the program.

Suprisingly he conceeds that intelligent design is a faith issue. Nevertheless he sounds deeply confused on evolution. He lumps the origin of the cosmos, life, and species into one big ball. (No one thinks that humans or life originated in the big bang, and what does "evolution between species" mean?)

My impression was that this whole thing will blow over. I hope I'm right.

(via Clark Goble on Eyring-L.)

2 comments:

Anonymous,  1/14/2006 12:42:00 AM  

Here are a couple of my gripes with the bill.
1. He wants us to "critically analyze theories regarding the origins of life". Does he really think high school curriculum can fit it all in? How many religions are there? How many have differing views regarding origins of life? Can you really present one religious view without presenting the others, especially in the US? Leave that for a upper college world religion course.
2. "...not all scientists agree on which theory is correct." I honestly don't know the answer to this next question I pose, but I get the impression that the great majority of researchers, PhD's, etc in the field of evolution agree upon the theory of evolution as it is taught to high school and college students. Are there really a lot of scientists who disagree? Is a 50:50 issue, 75:25, 90:10? Should school curriculum on this topic be driven by some outraged parent or senator or from the scholarly consensus in the field?

Jared*,  1/14/2006 11:26:00 AM  

It will definately be interesting to see how this plays out.

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP