Court Decision Summary
If you don't want to read the full 139 page decision of the Dover intelligent design trial, you can read a good summary here.
While I'm on the topic of intelligent design, The Pandas Thumb provided an interesting quotation:
“The analogy which you attempt to establish between the contrivances of human art, and the various existences of the Universe, is inadmissible. We attribute these effects to human intelligence, because we know beforehand that human intelligence is capable of producing them. Take away this knowledge, and the grounds of our reasoning will be destroyed. Our entire ignorance, therefore, of the Divine Nature leaves this analogy defective in its most essential point of comparison.
You assert that the construction of the animal machine, the fitness of certain animals to certain situations, the connexion between the organs of perception and that which is perceived; the relation between every thing which exists, and that which tends to preserve it in its existence, imply design. It is manifest that if the eye could not see, nor the stomach digest, the human frame could not preserve its present mode of existence. It is equally certain, however, that the elements of its composition, if they did not exist in one form, must exist in another; and that the combinations which they would form, must so long as they endured, derive support for their peculiar mode of being from their fitness to the circumstances of their situation.”
These paragraphs were written in 1814 in response to William Paley's Natural Theology. Perhaps the argument over intelligent design will die down for a little while, but I think that first paragraph is worth keeping in mind because ID proponents almost exclusively argue by analogy to man-made things.

0 comments:
Post a Comment