Tuesday, July 19, 2005

Southerton and Murphy: Could It Have Been Different?

In a statement attributed to Simon Southerton, he tells his motivation for writing his book. "I wrote Losing a Lost Tribe because I want to pressure the church to change its teachings and doctrines that are racist and wrong. Native Americans and Polynesians are not descended from Israelites and they are not the descendants of the imaginary cursed Lamanite race." This is a rather negative take on what the DNA evidence strongly points to--that the majority of Native American and Polynesian genetic ancestry comes from Asia. As such, it contradicts what many members of the Church believe(d), or assume(d), would be the case. It may not be welcome information, but it is what it is.

Let's forget Southerton and Murphy for a moment and go back a few years to when this topic was below the surface. Imagine a young, faithful scholar--let's call him John Sorenson Jr.--who has studied the issue of genetic ancestry and realizes that the science does not match popular belief. He is still a believer and has pure motives--he just wants people to know the truth.

1. Should John Jr. publish his findings?
2. If so, where should he publish? One assumption might be that having it come from FARMS or BYU Studies will make it more acceptable because they are "faithful" sources. What if neither of them are interested?
3. His publication will likely attract attention. How important is tone versus substance in determining whether church members (especially the Brethren) will smile or frown upon his work?

Keep in mind that the information in John Jr.'s publication is being taught in university courses--he's just the first one to put two and two together for the public. It's only a matter of time before someone does it. Might it not as well be him rather than a critic?

I ask these questions because I believe that this issue could have been broached without causing alarm within the Church, if it had been done the right way. Perhaps I am wrong. Could it have been different?

8 comments:

Anonymous,  7/21/2005 01:06:00 AM  

Maybe part of the problem is the church leadership's council not to question them. This council immediately puts many truth seekers in a difficult position. By questioning church practices(racism) or belief's (native americans are descendants of Laman and Lemuel) such person's are then considered unfaithful. We may deny that this is the case, but isn't it? We can't judge Southerton's heart, but I feel that if he were honestly seeking to help the church, or if he were deviously trying to break it down the result would be the same.

What happened to the spirit of the words of Orson Pratt who said, "Convince us of our errors of doctrine, if we have any, by reason, by logical arguments, or by the word of God, and we will ever be grateful for the information, and you will ever have the pleasing reflection that you have been instrumenmts in the hands of God of redeeming your fellow beings from the darkness which you may see enveloping their minds."

Jared*,  7/21/2005 10:47:00 AM  

It seems to me that if Southerton were trying to help the Church, he would have had a very different tone. I may be naive but I really think tone can make a big difference in whether something is interpreted as enlightening and providing new ways of thinking, or tearing down faith and kicking against the pricks.

Stephen,  7/23/2005 12:54:00 PM  

"trying to force" -- I think that captures it all.

Anonymous,  7/25/2005 01:17:00 AM  

Your post refers to evidence showing that "most" of the Native population descended from Asia. Should this be "all"? In what I've read about this, I don't remember coming across anything saying that the Asian-mongolian migrants interbred with people also here.

Jared*,  7/25/2005 04:51:00 PM  

Kirk,

I'm not sure I understand your comment.

Kirk H. Sowell,  7/26/2005 01:04:00 AM  

Jared: To clarify -

Assume that Lehi's descendants made up only 1% of the gene pool in Central America, or for that matter the entire hemisphere. My understanding is that even 1% would be enough to show up today. So to state that "most" natives descended from Asians does not necessarily even cause the Book of Mormon a problem. It would be very easily shurugged off. But if the DNA evidence shows that natives descended entirely from Asian/Mongolian races, that would seem to exclude the story put forth in the Book of Mormon.

So I didn't think you framed the issue correctly. That was what I was trying to say.

Jared*,  7/26/2005 08:01:00 AM  

Kirk,

Thanks for clarifying. I confess that I'm not strong enough in population genetics to know what we should expect to see given different assumptions (number of colonizers, number of pre-existing natives, etc.)

I see several propositions here.

1. All Native Americans are descended from Asians.

2. All Native American genes come from Asia.

3. No Native Americans are descended from non-Asians.

The evidence strongly supports #1. I'm not sure that #2 can be affirmed quite yet. Maybe all genes looked at so far, but can non-Asian genes be totally ruled out? I confess some ignorance here, but my senese is that there is still a fair amount of genetic territory to explore before #2 can be affirmed. That's why I said "most."

Even if #1 and #2 are correct, #3 could still be wrong, but that gets back to assumptions on population sizes, intermixing, etc.

Anonymous,  7/29/2005 11:20:00 AM  

Why is there so much sloppy thinking on these issues?

Kirk says: "Assume that Lehi's descendants made up only 1% of the gene pool in Central America"

Firs of all, I can't make any sense of this. If Lehi was introduced into the gene pool over 2000 years ago, then all the people in Central America would be his descendents. I suppose that would mean his descendents have 100% of the current gene pool. I expect Kirk means "Lehi's party made up only 1% of the gene pool in Central America."

But why would you assume that? If Lehi arrived on an already inhabited continent and immediately began interbreeding with the natives (as modern apologists seem to believe), America would have already contained millions of people. Lehi's band would have been much, much less than 1%.

I also don't know if a 1% contribution would be detectible using current methods, but I'm sure a .01% contribution wouldn't be. Remember, too, that we can only guess at what Lehi's DNA may have looked like.

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP