Simon Southerton Faces Excommunication
Simon Southerton faces potential excommunication. (Hat tip to Latter-day Slant.) But it's not for what you might think.
Continue ReadingSoutherton...faces charges of adultery, not heresy. Southerton acknowledges he had an affair five years ago after he separated from his wife, Jane, and contends church authorities are latching onto that instead of proving more difficult charges of apostasy...
"Clearly I should be excommunicated for the most serious offense and, in my view, apostasy is much more serious."
That strikes me as somewhat of a bizarre analysis. My guess is that he is disappointed that he won't technically have the credentials of an intellectual martyr. Since Southerton left the church several years ago, I had assumed he had his name removed. Apparently he did not--I wonder why.Daniel C. Peterson, editor of the FARMS Review, the journal of Brigham Young University’s Foundation for Ancient Research and Mormon Studies, says Southerton’s view of DNA evidence is “naïve” and oversimplified. “His contention is that the DNA research thus far doesn’t support the Book of Mormon,” Peterson said. “Our contention would be that we would be surprised if it did.”
That seems a little disingenuous. I'll grant that a more limited setting for the Book of Mormon is not a recent invention to counter the DNA evidence, and that Southerton's reaction is more extreme than it need be (although understandable, in my opinion). But are we really to believe that if the DNA evidence was otherwise the people at FARMS would be saying, "Wow. We just did not expect that; we're just as suprised as anyone. It's going to revolutionize how we think of the Book of Mormon."? Maybe it would be so, but I am doubtful on that point.
If all Southerton and Murphy did was to point out that DNA evidence does not support our popular perception of the Book of Mormon and suggest we re-think some issues, then I would have no problem with them. I believe the facts should be out on the table. My problem is that they go the extra step or two to tell everyone, "Therefore the Book of Mormon is pure fiction and your belief in it and the leaders of the Church is vain. There is no other option--Mwahaha!" It's that second element causes my sympathy for them to evaporate.
(I've blogged on Southerton once before.)

4 comments:
Here's a rant of his on one of the Ex Mormon boards. He's pretty clear about why he wants to leave the church but not leave the church.
Dave thinks this will just generate bad PR for the Church. I'm more sympathetic to Palmer--as I understand it he at least still believes in the Church, even if he has some different views. Southerton is apparently proud of his antagonism, which I think makes it harder for anyone to claim that this is just the Church kicking intellectuals around.
Given his science background, I have trouble believing this was Southerton's first intellectual crisis. Maybe this was the straw the broke the camel's back, but it would be interesting to know why he survived others but not this one.
Southerton, like many other anti's, forgets that Lamanite became a political and cultural term and less of a racial term. Eventually, all who were not Nephites were Lamanites. It is perfectly plausible that there were Lamanites who were not Lehite ot Mulekite.
Post a Comment