Friday, April 08, 2005

The Order of the Universe

In Michael Shermer's book review that I mentioned here, he says that he once did a survey where he asked people to explain why they believe in God. "The most popular reason given was: 'Good design, natural beauty, perfection, and complexity of the world or universe.'" Is that the first reason that comes to your mind? It isn't for me.

Continue Reading


 Why should we believe in God? It seems to me that one of the first answers should be, "Because he has revealed himself to us." Now depending on denomination, the form of that revelataion is different. One of the things that has always set Mormonism apart from other major denominations is that God's revelation of himself is much more recent that any of those in the mainstream Christain tradition (or Jewish or Muslim).
 
Closely connected to this ought to be answers based on personal experience. I think one of the best pieces of advice one of my undergraduate science professors gave was that our belief in God should be based on positive experience, not gaps in our knowledge. Is a belief in God that does not include personal experience worth much?
 
So why would the most popular response be something along the lines of "order of the universe?" It seems to me that some form of this answer is really the common denominator of all believers, and sometimes the last reason left to believe. Maybe this explains its popularity. It was used by those who have no other reasons, and by those who think of it as the only answer that others will accept.
 
I certainly don't see it as a strong argument--not by itself. Used alone, is it any more powerful than, "Because chocolate tastes really good"?
 
At a recent priesthood meeting, a member of the Stake presidency put me on the spot during his lesson by asking me, "Jared, you're a scientist--how orderly is the universe?" My mind raced through a number of answers. It was really a digression from his main point and I didn't want to cause trouble, so I just said, "Pretty." While some aspects of the universe are like clockwork, others seem much more like the swirling of water. Purpose and progress can be different from or encompass more than order, I think. It was not the appropriate time to get into that, but I didn't want to give pseudo-scientifc endorsement to an orderly idealism, so I tried to give a supportive answer with some wiggle room.
 
If you were to take that survey, what would your first answer be? What should it be?

2 comments:

Kim Siever,  4/09/2005 11:15:00 PM  

I'm not sure what my answer woudl be, but your response (He revealed Himself to us) really makes me think about it.

Clark Goble,  4/10/2005 07:42:00 PM  

It seems to me that there is something about our conception of God and our approach to religion that makes "he revealed himself" acceptable. In most religions I'm not sure that is really acceptable in the same fashion. Or at least that direct approach is rarer and looked more askance. It goes along with the notion of faith as well, which I think that view of God also changes for Mormons. Faith seems, for us, to be tied to how God reveals himself to us. Whereas for most average Christians faith must take a different form precisely because revelation is typically viewed differently.

(Of course these are all generalities. I know many non-Mormons who have similar views to Mormons on these matters)

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP