Thursday, September 13, 2007

Francis Collins Interview

Francis Collins was interviewed on the Point of Inquiry podcast. Point of Inquiry is part of the Center for Inquiry, a secular humanist organization. Dr. Collins is a bit of a departure from the usual line up, so I was glad to listen to his perspective and enjoyed some of his comments. But I think he does himself a disservice with some of his arguments.

For example, Collins says that if our moral sense of right and wrong is a product of evolutionary development rather than instilled by God,

...why do the atheists insist that we should get over religion and try to be good to each other? Who cares about being good? If they're right, we should all shrug off the whole idea and be just as darned selfish as we possibly can, because there is no driving force behind this. We've all been hoodwinked by evolution into thinking we're supposed to be good, and we should rebel against that. [my transcription; ~min 18]
That looks like a non sequitur to me. How does that make any sense? Why should we necessarily rebel against something established by evolution? And who would want to live in a world where everyone was as selfish as they could be? Answer: nobody (except maybe a few sociopaths). You don't need God in order to realize that total anarchy and a world full of jerks would result in a serious decline in quality of life.

Collins may be expressing fear that some would justify their behavior with that argument. I can't say that such a fear is unjustified, but if someone decides that they are an atheist, I would hope that they have other good reasons not to do violence to me, my family, and my property, and that Collins would not take those reasons away. On the other hand, perhaps this is just Collins trying to score rhetorical points. But Point of Inquiry is not the local church group. It is an organization of people who pride themselves on critical investigation. Such rhetoric only serves to undermine his position, in my opinion.

I don't mean to be excessively negative. I applaud Dr. Collins for being willing to stick his neck out.



Continue reading...

Sunday, September 09, 2007

Duane Jeffery Speaks [Spoke]

Sunstone has made their audio recordings of symposia presentations pre-dating 2005 available for free. I did an author search for Duane Jeffery and have listened to a few of his presentations.

Duane Jeffery has been a professor of zoology and genetics at BYU for over 30 years. (He is also a director of the NCSE.) I don't know him personally (I wish I did), but from my reading I get the sense that he has been one of the point men in the relationship between BYU biological sciences and Church headquarters. When he finally leaves BYU--or dies--I wonder who will fill his shoes. Anyway, enough of the love-fest.

In the Q&A after his presentation on Noah's flood, someone asked about evolution and Church magazines. After a few comments, including mentioning the BYU packet, he said (my transcription):

In February of '98 [actually 2002], I think it was, the Ensign republished the 1909 statement as though it were something authoritative. We pursued that to the top and we were assured that, as one general authority put it to me, "I don't think the Ensign's going to do anything like that again for a very long time." But we were given [a] formal letter from the First Presidency that that was NOT to indicate a change in position, and assured that the documents we have in the BYU packet, which leave that issue open, are the official position of the church.
I think what the Ensign ought to do is--oh, I don't know--publish the BYU packet with an explanation as to how it came about. I know that's crazy talk, given that the First Presidency stands by it, but I can dream.



Continue reading...

Dialogue: Noah's Flood

Clayton M. White and Mark D. Thomas have published an article in the latest BYU Studies Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought on Noah's Flood. The article is "On Balancing Faith in Mormonism with Traditional Biblical Stories: The Noachian Flood Story," and is free (Thanks, Dialogue).

Clayton White is a professor of Plant and Wildlife Sciences at BYU and Curator of Birds at the M. L. Bean Museum. The article itself principally focuses on biological problems that are raised by the traditional, worldwide flood interpretation. I think it is best read along with Duane Jeffery's Sunstone article (also free). Or listen to Jeffery's Sunstone presentation here.

Speaking of Duane Jeffery's article, White and Thomas write:

This is the article mentioned at the beginning of Duane Jeffery, "Noah's Flood: Modern Scholarship and Mormon Tradition," Sunstone, Issue 136 (October 2004): 27-45. He describes two Brigham Young University faculty members who wrote the article and submitted it to BYU Studies. After some three years and about five major revisions to suit the editor, BYU Studies essentially accepted the article. After yet another review by another panel, the article was rejected.
I feel bad for the authors, having apparently been jerked around for three years. I have no knowledge of the deliberations that led to the final decision, and I recognize that BYU Studies has to play CYA more than other publishers of Mormon Studies. However, it is difficult for me to not view this as a black mark for BYU Studies. If there is such a thing as "faithful science," I think this is probably about as good an example as any, and I am left to wonder what this says about BYU Studies. I would like to think that they wanted an even better article that laid out additional historical, linguistic, and doctrinal arguments, but I have my doubts.



Continue reading...

Thursday, September 06, 2007

HIV Denial

You may find this hard to believe, but there are people who do not believe that HIV causes AIDS. In fact, some don't even believe HIV exists. A commentary in PLoS Medicine, "HIV Denial in the Internet Era," gives some basic background on this movement. In addition to their day jobs, Tara Smith blogs at Aetiology, and Steven Novella is the host of the great podcast, "The Skeptic's Guide to the Universe" (I've been listening for about a year and a half, now).

HIV denial is not uncommon among the leading lights of Intelligent Design. Of course, it would be a logical fallacy to say that because they are wrong on HIV, they are also wrong on ID. But I think it is suggestive of being a contrarian crank.


Continue reading...

Thursday, August 23, 2007

Gone BCC Guest Blogging

I'm guest blogging over at By Common Consent for a little bit. Below are links (updated as needed) to my posts there.

1. Faithful Science

2.Elder McConkie’s Other List of Heresies

3. Inspired Errors

4. I got up and bore testimony

5. The Alu in You

Continue reading...

Tuesday, August 14, 2007

Elder Oaks: Science Quotes

Edited transcripts for the interviews with President Boyd K. Packer and Elder Dallin H. Oaks for the PBS documentary The Mormons have been posted by the Church.

Elder Oaks made several comments that touched on science. Although most of them appear to have been made in the context of the Book of Mormon, they have broader applicability and are reproduced below. I may discuss some of these points further in later posts, but I thought I would post them all together first. Except for the footnote and separating dashes, all indications of editing (brackets, etc.) are in the original.

HW: What would you say to faithful, liberal (in the absence of a better word) Mormons who are searching for “the middle way” to look at the Book of Mormon as an inspired text with profound spiritual meaning?

DHO: To people who have a hard time with the literal claims of scripture, I would say: “Keep your life in balance between reliance on history, so-called, or geology or science, so-called, and reliance on spiritual witnesses and the testimony of the Holy Ghost. There are two ways to truth: science and revelation. If you find things that trouble you, don’t dismiss the spiritual explanation and hold with the scientific one. Keep your life in balance by continuing to do the things necessary to keep open the channels of communication to heaven as well as to scholarly journals.”

HW: Describe what that middle way or middle ground is.

DHO: It’s hard for me to define a middle ground because I don’t believe in a middle ground when it comes to morality. I don’t believe in situational ethics. I believe that truth is a knowledge of things as they are. I think we’re dealing with religious truth, and I don’t think that religious truth can be understood by scientific methods.

Whenever science dilutes a religious truth or the revelation of God, it demeans it. While I understand the sincerity of those who are looking for a middle way, I think that God has the final answer on the purpose of life. He has the final answer on what is right and wrong. I don’t think there’s a middle way. I think that science and scholarship can lead us toward truth, but I think that people in the end must be willing to surrender their best judgment to revelation from God.

----------------------------
HW: Possibly the “problem” the Book of Mormon has to a modern person is that there are no precedents [to the plates].

DHO: A book that has no origin, of course that’s a problem! Of course a book, translated from plates that you can’t examine to authenticate it is a terrible problem to anyone who approaches this in a scientific way. There have been other visionaries, but I don’t know of any who have written a book. So Joseph is unique in saying, “I had a vision, and it led to this book, and here’s the book! Read it, put it to the spiritual test.” Well, it can be put to the spiritual test. Millions have done that and have joined the Church. But it can’t be put to scientific test — that really bothers a scientific age! If I wanted science to draw on, it would bother me too.

I suppose that we’re in a scientific age, but surely in human history there have been times when people would have said, “Visions in the age in iron? Visions in the age of sailboats?” [Slight laughter.] Any age could take its own marvels and use them to reject the simpler revelatory experiences of an earlier time.

----------------------------
Now intellectualism is also perceived as a danger. I suppose it has been for at least a century. I read some history of some of the early confrontations with science — creation of the earth and so forth. In fact at Brigham Young University in some of its earliest years, [there] was [such a] manifestation [1]. There’ll be other manifestations at different times. The life of the mind, which is a great, defining object of universities in our day, of which I’ve been the beneficiary in my own life, can be seen or practiced to be in flat-out opposition to the spiritual characteristics of one’s faith. Revelation stands in opposition to science in some aspects according to some understandings. So I think in any day the watchmen on the tower are going to say intellectualism is a danger to the Church. And it is at extreme points, and if people leave their faith behind and follow strictly where science leads them, that can be a pretty crooked path. ([The] science of today is different than the science of yesterday.) We encourage the life of the mind. We establish and support universities that encourage education. But we say to our young people: “Keep your faith. Do the things necessary to hear the promptings of the Spirit. If you’re getting too far off the line in the latest scientific theory or whatever, you will get a spiritual warning.” And I believe that.




1. This is almost certainly a reference to the 1911 evolution controversy. To read more about it, as well as Elder Oaks's interaction with the sciences while president of BYU, see here.

Continue reading...

Thursday, August 09, 2007

Escaping Malthus

The New York Times has an article about a new book--A Farewell to Alms--on the industrial revolution.

Gregory Clark, an economic historian at the University of California, Davis, believes that the Industrial Revolution — the surge in economic growth that occurred first in England around 1800 — occurred because of a change in the nature of the human population. The change was one in which people gradually developed the strange new behaviors required to make a modern economy work. The middle-class values of nonviolence, literacy, long working hours and a willingness to save emerged only recently in human history, Dr. Clark argues.

-------------------
The tendency of population to grow faster than the food supply, keeping most people at the edge of starvation, was described by Thomas Malthus in a 1798 book, “An Essay on the Principle of Population.” This Malthusian trap, Dr. Clark’s data show, governed the English economy from 1200 until the Industrial Revolution and has in his view probably constrained humankind throughout its existence. The only respite was during disasters like the Black Death, when population plummeted, and for several generations the survivors had more to eat.

In my experience, Malthus's name is usually raised in order to flog him (and others) for his (and their) failed doomsday predictions. But apparently there was truth in what he said. Although not an authoritative source, the convenient Wikipedia states:
Malthus himself noted that many people misrepresented his theory and took pains to point out that he did not just predict future catastrophe. He argued "...this constantly subsisting cause of periodical misery has existed ever since we have had any histories of mankind, does exist at present, and will for ever continue to exist, unless some decided change takes place in the physical constitution of our nature."

Thus, Malthus regarded his Principle of Population as an explanation of the past and the present situation of humanity as well as a prediction of our future.

The article notes that Dr. Clark seems to think that human evolution played a significant role in behavioral changes. I'm sure it's possible, but I would need to be convinced.


Continue reading...

Tuesday, August 07, 2007

Newsweek on Global Warming Denial

Newsweek has a lengthy article on the organized and well-funded anti-global warming campaign. Here is the jist:

Since the late 1980s, this well-coordinated, well-funded campaign by contrarian scientists, free-market think tanks and industry has created a paralyzing fog of doubt around climate change. Through advertisements, op-eds, lobbying and media attention, greenhouse doubters (they hate being called deniers) argued first that the world is not warming; measurements indicating otherwise are flawed, they said. Then they claimed that any warming is natural, not caused by human activities. Now they contend that the looming warming will be minuscule and harmless. "They patterned what they did after the tobacco industry," says former senator Tim Wirth, who spearheaded environmental issues as an under secretary of State in the Clinton administration. "Both figured, sow enough doubt, call the science uncertain and in dispute. That's had a huge impact on both the public and Congress."




Continue reading...

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP