A few of weeks ago I blogged about Michael Ash's article, "The Mormon Myth of Evil Evolution." I raised the question of documentation for a rumored rift between David O. McKay and Joseph Fielding Smith. Since nobody knew the source for sure, I emailed Michael Ash to find out. His computer files were not available at the time, but he was pretty sure his source was Brigham Young University: A House of Faith, by Gary Bergera and Ron Priddis. The book is out of print now, so I bought a used copy on-line for a few dollars--a good investment in my view. It does appear to be the source for the rift rumors. However, the supposed rift is only mentioned in passing and is contradicted by others, as pointed out by Justin.
Continue Reading
I find the book quite interesting since it details various developments and controversies at BYU over the years, with many behind-the-scenes views. There is a 40-page chapter on organic evolution at BYU which is certainly worth reading. I've been particularly impressed with Dallin Oaks's administration on a number of issues. Among them, he seems to have been instrumental in getting the sciences at BYU a little breathing room.
When Dallin Oaks replaced Ernest Wilkinson as BYU president in August 1971, he soon learned of serious problems on campus regarding the role of evolution at the university. In his first address to the faculty in September he asked that guilty parties, particularly among members of the religion faculty, "stop casting aspersions on [the] testimony and devotion of their colleagues" in the sciences.
(It strikes me that it isn't only science professors who can live in ivory towers.)
He also initiated a series of seminars to facilitate dialogue between the science and religion faculty, although some religion faculty apparently refused to attend. (Elsewhere, Duane Jeffery says that one of the religion faculty wrote a 4(?) page letter on why he would not participate in anything that Satanic.)
Shortly after Duane Jeffery published "Seers, Savants, and Evolution: The Uncomfortable Interface," the then Elder Benson spoke at a BYU fireside and said "one of our church educators [has] published what he purports to be a history of the church's stand on the question of organic evolution...To hold to a private opinion on such matters is one thing,...but when one undertakes to publish his views to discredit the work of a prophet [ie. Joseph Fielding Smith], it is a very serious matter."
Jeffery promptly wrote to Oaks, emphatically denying that he was on a "campaign to disparage the reputation of anyone." While he had decided not to respond publicly, he explained, his "silence should not be construed as a concession" to Benson's criticisms. Sympathetic, Oaks replied, "I am hopeful and confident that with a little love and understanding and patience and patience and patience that these things will work out."
(Elsewhere, Jeffery says that the then Elder Benson had not actually read his article, but got his information from an aspiring underling who had distorted the article.)
At a later point, Oaks wrote the following to the then Elder Hinckley:
There is a clear issue here: Should the board continue or should it revise its policy that permits Brigham Young University faculty to teach the theory of organic evolution--teaching it as a theory and not as a proven fact?
...If we stopped teaching this theory, within a few years students from BYU would not be admitted to...graduate schools. At that point we would cease to function as a recognized university and would, in the eyes of the world (especially the world of higher education), be little more than a seminary with added courses in the humanities.
...There are thousands of our faith who feel threatened by that openness, and while I have sympathy with that as a personal point of view, in my judgment that kind of narrowness should never be allowed to impose the darkening hand of censorship on this university."
In fairness we should keep in mind, as Stephens and Meldrum point out in their book, that much of the best supporting evidence for evolution has come forth since 1970. Man, His Origin and Destiny was published only a year after the structure of DNA was solved. But the Jeffery episode does raise some interesting questions. Setting aside doctrinal disagreements, if Joseph Fielding Smith's book contained inferior scientific arguments, should the LDS scientists have remained silent--thus appearing to have no answer for JFS's claims? It seems like a tight rope to walk and I'm glad such tension is largely set aside these days.
It came much later, but the BYU packet (available on the side bar), I think, was a great idea and protects both points of view. It also diplomatically frees us from having to account for every statement made by every General Authority (including JSF) because it emphasizes the role of First Presidency Statements.
Continue reading...