Thursday, February 17, 2005

Potential Life on Mars

Scientists are reporting that they may have evidence that life (presumably microbial) exists on Mars. Of course confirmation is decades away--probably not a good dissertation project. It will sure be interesting to see, though.

Continue reading...

Point and Counterpoint

A few days ago, Clark at Mormon Metaphysics pointed out this article written by Carl Zimmer for Discovery Magazine. It is a nifty piece on modeling evolution in computers and describes some interesting applications, including evolution of irreducibly complex systems.

Jonathan Wells (ID proponent) has responded here with a flippant response that attempts at humor, but doesn't really take on any of the issues.

Compare the two for yourself.

Continue reading...

Tuesday, February 15, 2005

Eternal Tension of Type vs Diversity

In his book What Evoution Is (the only book of his I have read), Ernst Mayr discusses the shift from typological to population thinking that Darwin introduced. I'm not student of philosophy, but my understanding is that before Darwin, people thought of each animal species as having a defined essence, which idea came from Plato. Darwin drew attention to the biological diversity within each species--no two individuals are exactly alike. To the typologist, the average is real and deviations are unimportant. To the population thinker, diversity is real and the average is just an abstraction.

This has me thinking that there seems to be a tension between typology and population thinking, or diversity. For example, the scriptures are mostly typological. We were created in God's image, we are to be like him, and we are to be "one." This suggests a type or essence that we are, or are striving for. On the other hand, inspite of being in God's image we are quite diverse physically and mentally. Discussion of the degrees of glory and gradation of intelligences are the only scriptures dealing with diversity that come to mind.

Perhaps there is a time for typology and a time for diversity. But this has me wondering what aspects of existance these two paradigms will govern in eternity. How do they govern the resurrection, eternal rewards, our eternal personalities, the perpetuation of mankind in eternity, etc. Are there differences between where gods began to be and where they will be?

Here and now, when should we seek type vs appreciate and embrace diversity?

Continue reading...

Saturday, February 12, 2005

"Fact, Fable, and Darwin" at Meridian Magazine

This article at Meridian Magazine was brought to my attention by discussion at Mormon Metaphysics. Clark's post and the ensuing comments are worth reading.

The thrust of the article is that even die-hard evolutionists have hidden doubts about the ability of evolutionary theory to explain the origin of species, that it was evolutionists that picked the fight with religion, and that while we wait for the ultimate truth to emerge, "why not lift the requirement that high school texts enshrine Darwin's failed attempt as an eternal truth?"



Continue Reading



My first criticism of the article is technical--there is no documentation. (My brief attempt to locate the original article failed, so I do not know whether it contains footnotes.) Critics of evolution have a history of taking quotations out of contex. I'm not accusing Stark of this, but without references for his quotations, anyone who wants to check up on his accuracy will have a difficult time.

This article perpetuates the unfortunate practice of basing criticism of evolution on Darwin's supposed flaws (or those of his associates). It is as though evolutionary theory came forth fully formed from Darwin--but this is not the case. He certainly laid a strong foundation, but he knew nothing of genetics, or example. Moreover, varying theories of evolution were advanced until the modern synthesis in the 1930's and 40's. And while this article makes much out of missing transitional fossils, there is not a hint that other lines of evidence support current evolutionary theory including biogeography, developmental biology, molecular biology, and genetics.

The second part of the article is really getting at the culture wars. Stark argues that it was the evolutionists who took the fight to Christianity. He writes, "Atheism was central to the agenda of the Darwinians. Darwin himself once wrote that he could not understand how anyone could even wish that Christianity were true, noting that the doctrine of damnation was itself damnable."

This ought to get our blood boiling, right? Well as Latter-day Saints, maybe we should first remember that we don't believe in the doctrine of damnation either (that is, as taught by traditional Christianity.) And in fact, who was it that wrote of:

murder, tyranny, and oppression, supported and urged on and upheld by the influence of that spirit which hath so strongly riveted the creeds of the fathers, who have inherited lies, upon the hearts of the children, and filled the world with confusion, and has been growing stronger and stronger, and is now the very mainspring of all corruption, and the whole earth groans under the weight of its iniquity. It is an iron yoke, it is a strong band; they are the very handcuffs, and chains, and shackles, and fetters of hell.

In the last General Conference, Elder Holland quoted John Taylor:
"Whoever heard of true religion without communication with God? To me the thing is the most absurd that the human mind could conceive of. I do not wonder," said Brother Taylor, "[that] when the people generally reject the principle of present revelation, skepticism and infidelity prevail to such an alarming extent. I do not wonder," he continued, "that so many men treat religion with contempt, and regard it as something not worth the attention of intelligent beings, for without revelation religion is a mockery and a farce. . . . The principle of present revelation . . . is the very foundation of our religion. "

Should we really be taking offense at Darwin and Huxley's scorn? Given our own faith's contempt for burdening tradition (at least in the early years) and the context in which he lived, I do not think that we should sit in judgment of Darwin.

I have little argument with the last paragraph of the article, except that I disagree with the stand he takes on textbooks in high schools. But I'm out of indignation, so I'll leave that discussion for another day.

(By the way, I never answered the question of who wrote the passage railing against the "creeds of the fathers." But you probably already knew it was Joseph Smith, as contained in D&C 123.)

Continue reading...

Martha Nibley Beck

Clark over at Mormon Metaphysics has written about Martha Nibley Beck's forthcoming book. In addition to his level-headed comments Clark is one of the few people who have actually read the book, so check it out. He also points out this great article by Robert Kirby. Here's one of my favorite parts:

If the First Presidency really does maintain a secret Danite squad, how come I'm still here? More importantly, why haven't I been asked to serve on it? When it comes to service, the church only wants me to work in a cannery or haul hay. It's never "Brother Kirby, the Lord has called you to tamper with Sister Beck's brakes."

Continue reading...

Thursday, February 10, 2005

What is A Stem Cell?

Over at Millenial Star they're talking about stem cells--which on a large blog is like yelling food fight in a cafeteria. I don't know what Harvard is doing, but I don't think I agree with Mitt Romney's approach. I am a cautious supporter of embryonic stem cell research. Not providing public funding is one thing, but banning seems overboard to me. But like I said, I don't know what specific practices he objects to.

Rather than re-hash arguments that will not change anyone's mind, I'm going to aim for education.


Continue Reading


On the side bar under "Science Links" is a link called "Reference Books." These science textbooks availabe online--for free. Some of them only allow you to access the content by searching--you can't just browse. This limitation can be somewhat overcome by clicking "full contents" at the top, and then entering search terms contained in the sub-section you want to read. There are often diagrams and figures on the sides of the pages, so don't miss them.

You can search an individual book, or all of the books. So go to the link and enter "embryonic stem cells" as the search terms. You'll see a lot of hits. There is a developmental biology book, as well as Molecular Biology of the Cell. They will probably be the most informative resources. Unfortunately the hits within a book are not organized by chapter order, so you'll have to hunt around a little. But without too much effort, you'll figure out how to navigate around and get the info you want.

So go to it and good luck.

Continue reading...

Another Setback for A Simple Concept

The concept of gene therapy is pretty simple. Sometimes people inherit "broken" genes which prevent the production of functional proteins that play important roles in the body. The idea is to introduce a functional copy of the gene into a population of cells and hope that they will begin to function normally. The gene is delivered to the cells by one of several defective virus strategies. However the implementation of the strategy is more difficult.


Continue Reading


In the case of X-linked SCID (severe combined inmunodeficiency), a protein component of a receptor in immune cells is broken resulting in a non-functional adaptive immune system. Seinfeld jokes aside, this disease made the "bubble boy" famous.

A doctor in France has been treating kids with this disease by introducing the correct gene in to bone marrow stem cells, and the results have been encouraging. His program was halted a couple of years ago, however, because two kids developed cancer as a result of treatment--one has since died. Since the correct copy of the gene integrates into the genome somewhat randomly, there are risks that normal genes can be disturbed. Unexpectedly, the same gene was found to be affected in both of the kids with cancer. I had not heard much since then, but apparently treatments resumed.

Unfortunately, Nature reports that the program has been halted again because of another cancer case.

Fischer is now investigating why the third child, who was treated at a later age than the previous two children, developed cancer. The child's cells did not seem to have the same genetic glitch that caused the first two cancers, he says, but he cautions that the analysis is still under way.

Fischer adds that he still believes in gene therapy as a treatment for X-linked SCID, because 15 children treated in this way are still alive, and 14 are doing well four years later. But his group will not treat any more children using its current gene-therapy system, he says. He adds that he plans to change a key step in the treatment by changing the vector — the modified virus that delivers the therapeutic gene to the patients.

This is one of those difficult ethical scenarios. I don't know what the average lifespan of these kids is, but I'm pretty sure it is less than a decade (with good care.) They have no other real options for long-term survival. Hopefully change in treatment will occur quickly and be at least as successful.

Continue reading...

Wednesday, February 09, 2005

One Seat in the Blogger Center

The term "Bloggernacle" was coined (I think at T&S) to refer to the collection of Mormon-themed blogs. With the creation of another large, group blog and the assortment of smaller blogs such as this one, I think we're well on our way to moving into the "Blogger Center."

As I was thinking about what to blog about today, I noticed that one of my topics had been touched on elsewhere. Then I see that Millenial Star has had quite a discussion on evolution--with over 70 comments. This has made me wonder what the place of LDS Science Review is in the collection of blogs.


Continue Reading


First, I recognize that this is a niche blog. Many of the readers of those large blogs may have no interest in the topics discussed here. Second, although it feeds one's ego a bit, I recognize that the value of a blog is not necessarily correlated to the number of comments. One of my favorite blogs is Mormon Wasp, where comments tend to be few. There isn't much discussion, but it is informative--which is nice in some ways. I don't have the time or energy to run down every post with 70 comments. Furthermore my comments tend to be swamped out and I don't really have time for detailed exchanges on multiple blogs anyway. So this blog serves as my outlet.

I recognize that this blog is currently evolution-all-the-time. Evolution is what interests me lately, so that is natural. I do hope to broaden the scope of the blog a bit by getting contributions from other LDS scientists in other fields.

So stick with me, those of you who come here frequently. I believe this blog has some interesting journeys ahead.

Continue reading...

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP