Wednesday, February 09, 2005

Evolution at Millennial Star

Geoff B. over at Millenial Star has a post on evolution. The post has over 70 comments, some of which contain pretty good points of rebuttal.

Here are my two cents:

1. The use of evolution by people arguing atheism or agnosticism is irrelevant as to its truth or explanatory power in biology.

2. The book Icons of Evolution was brought up in the comments. Coincidentally, I recently found this review. In the interest of full disclosure, I haven't read Wells' book. However appart from its evaluation of Icons, the review has a lot of good information in it.

Continue reading...

What Kermit Taught Me

Many of you may have probably heard about the recent study showing brain activity in minimally conscious people. Carl Zimmer blogged about it here. Terri Schiavo apparently is not in this catagory of people. Cases like hers are tough and I can see both sides of the argument. I hope I never have to deal with similar circumstances. I don't know much about neurology or neuroscience, but a demonstration in my undergraduate physiology class was very interesting.


Continue Reading


As part of the class, we watched a video where a frog's head was cut off leaving the base of the brain and upper spinal cord in tact. The frog could still jump around--and not in an uncoordinated, flailing way either. The frog was then suspended and paper soaked in acetic acid was placed on its foot. The frog responded by kicking its leg until the paper fell off.

This was an interesting demonstration of the presence and capabilities of reflexes. The frog was obviously not conscious anymore, yet its behavior and movement was suprisingly consistant with what conscious frogs do. I'm not therefore arguing that Terri Schiavo's feeding tube be removed, but the frog demonstration helps me to believe doctors who say Terri's behavior lacks consciousness behind it and that the real Terri is gone for good.

Side note: I remember reading in the General Handbook of Instructions that the Church's policy is that not every measure has to be taken to sustain life. (corrections welcomed) I think this displays a practical acknowledgement that we all will/must die, so it is not necessary to fight death off with every weapon available. (I'm thinking of cancer patients who have given treatment a good shot and decide not to fight anymore.)

Continue reading...

Tuesday, February 08, 2005

Bad News and Good News

The bad news is that some issues of Dialogue at the U of U archive have been pulled in order to force purchase of the back-issues. This is certainly regretful since I live on the east coast and refuse to buy whole issues for one or two articles. (I do still have a brother at BYU who can make copies for me--take that, Dialogue!)

The good news is that Michael Ash's article, "The Mormon Myth of Evil Evolution" (one of those now unaccessible articles) is available on his website (pdf). Thanks to Clark at Mormon Metaphysics for pointing this out.

This article is a pretty good overview of the history of conflict over evolution within the church. More in-depth analysis of specific episodes are available elsewhere, but this article is a great (and free) place to start.

Although the article is pretty well documented I do have one complaint. It mentions rumors of a rift between David O. MacKay and Joseph Fielding Smith, but provides no documentation on this point. Does anybody know where this comes from or what the specific context was? Maybe Quinn's "Extensions of Power" (which I do not own?)

Continue reading...

Monday, February 07, 2005

"Regular Joe" Precipitates Scientific Revolution

Observers were stunned recently when an unidentified Kansas man asked a simple question that has shaken evolutionary theory to its roots. "If man comes from monkeys, why are there still monkeys?"
-----------------

The Panda's Thumb pointed out this article in The Guardian titled, "Religious right fights science for the heart of America."

Folks, I don't think this represents progress.


Continue Reading


Al Frisby has spent the better part of his life in rooms filled with rebellious teenagers, but the last years have been particularly trying for the high school biology teacher. He has met parents who want him to teach that God created Eve out of Adam's rib, and then then adjusted the chromosomes to make her a woman, and who insist that Noah invited dinosaurs aboard the ark. And it is getting more difficult to keep such talk out of the classroom.
"Somewhere along the line, the students have been told the theory of evolution is not valid," he said. "In the last few years, I've had students question my teaching about cell classification and genetics, and there have been a number of comments from students saying: 'Didn't God do that'?"

Would we stand for this kind of stuff in a history class? How about, for example, "[Insert favorite military conquerer] was victorious because God was on his/her side." Or maybe, "[Insert favorite minority] suffered oppression as a result of God's wrath."
In a crowded high school auditorium, biology teachers, mathematicians, a veterinarian, and a high school student made passionate speeches on the need for cold, scientific detachment, and the damage that would be done to the state's reputation and biotechnology industry if Kansas became known as a haven for creationists. They were countered by John James, who warned that the teaching of evolution led to nihilism, and to the gates of Auschwitz. "Are we producing little Kansas Nazis?" he asked.

Wait a minute, I thought God created the Nazis. Now really, little Kansas Nazis? Actually this is a little ironic since white supremacists often use the Bible as justification for their beliefs.
But the largest applause of the evening was reserved for a silver-haired gentleman in a navy blue blazer. "I have a question: if man comes from monkeys, why are there still monkeys? Why do you waste time teaching something in science class that is not scientific?" he thundered.

Well, there you go. I guess evolutionary biologists will be running with their vestigal tails between their legs. Meanwhile the gentleman in the navy blue blazer may want to ponder--if he came from Europeans (presumably), why are there still Europeans?

Continue reading...

Internet Items of Interest

Here are several items of note on the web:
1. Ernst Mayr died. I recently read his book What Evolution Is, and I hope to discuss it in the future.
2. Michael Behe is the author of Darwin's Black Box, where an idea for detecting intelligent design was first advanced--irreducible complexity. I read the book several years ago and plan to post my two cents about it. In the meantime, he has an op-ed in the NY Times. For the text and a response, see here.
3. Matt Roper has an article over at FAIR titled "Nephi's Neighbors: Book of Mormon Peoples and Pre-Columbian Populations."

Continue reading...

Friday, February 04, 2005

A Little Help, Please?

Sunstone Magazine has an article by Blake Ostler titled, "YEA, YEA, NAY, NAY: Assessing the Logical Structure of DNA Arguments against the Book of Mormon." Unfortunately I don't have a subscription and that particular article is not available online for free.

Will somebody please summarize the article for me in the comments section?

Update: Thanks to Justin for his help. The concepts in the article aren't really new, just laid out nicely. The bottom line is that, using DNA evidence, critics of the Book of Mormon have some strong arguments regarding the "global colonization hypothesis," but in rejecting Book of Mormon historicity they make assumptions that may be unwarranted.

Continue reading...

Thursday, February 03, 2005

The BYU-Idaho Perspective on Evolution

BYU-Idaho has a campus magazine called Perspective. There are several articles written by science faculty that I want to highlight. The articles primarily cover how the faculty deal with the topic of evolution. One of the articles discusses the history of the BYU Evolution Packet, and should be read in conjunction with the Daily Universe article by William Evenson (available in the pdf link on the sidebar under LDS Links.) These articles are comforting in that they help create a climate of accepting science while maintaining faith. I highly recommend them and will probably add them to my Essential Texts post.

An Explanation of the BYU Library Packet on Evolution

A Delicate Balance: Teaching Biological Evolution at BYU-Idaho

Teaching Geology, an Old Earth, and Organic Evolution in the Context of the Gospel

Science and the Church: Friend or Foe


Here is an excerpt from the first article above:


Continue Reading


First, Church members should avoid following the path of other evangelical faiths without considering carefully how our doctrine differs from theirs. For example, one of the fundamental dogmas associated with a literal interpretation of the creation story is creation ex nihilo,or creation out of nothing. This doctrine states that God created the world from absolutely nothing because He is in the absolute sense omnipotent. However, Joseph Smith taught that God formed the Earth from already existing matter. Other doctrines closely associated with creation ex nihilo, such as a belief that the earth was created in six 24-hour periods, or that species are immutable, are also unspecified or ignored in official LDS theology. In summary, we should be careful about jumping onto the creationist bandwagon because of the other theological cargo that is riding along.

A second benefit of not formalizing a statement about evolution is that we should avoid “jumping to quick conclusions or seizing upon simple answers.” In both theology and science,it is easy for Church members to follow others’ trends of attacking opposing viewpoints with simplistic clichés or emotionally charged logical fallacies. For example, creationists have attacked evolution with arguments that claim that it contradicts the second law of thermodynamics or that it is “just a theory.” For Church members to repeat these arguments demonstrates a severe lack of understanding of the scientific principles involved.

And lastly, we should not just simply attribute the theory of organic evolution to the evil designs of scientists devising means to turn others’ faith from God. There are far too many evolution scientists who are devout in their Christian faith (including our own) to draw any conclusions that belief in evolution has been detrimental to a belief in a supreme being. In contrast,many scientists have claimed that a deeper understanding of the processes of life has developed in them a deeper conviction of the existence of God.

Continue reading...

Tuesday, February 01, 2005

Do We Deserve STDs?

I attended a virology conference a while ago where the immunological basis for a human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccine was discussed. HPVs are a family of viruses responsible for causing warts. Some are sexually transmitted, and a few "high-risk" types are closely associated with cervical cancer in women. (More here.) A vaccine for some "high-risk" types is in clinical trials and looks promising. The speaker mentioned that the vaccine would be controversial among some groups because they would view it as promoting sexual activity. I asked myself if I would have my children vaccinated against any STDs possible. I think the answer has to be "yes."


Continue Reading


Aside from those that are against vaccines in general I can only think of a couple of moral/religously-based arguments against vaccines for STDs.
1. God uses STDs to discourage promiscuity. Vaccinating not only removes that discouragement, but is also a signal that promiscuity is ok.
2. God uses STDs to punish sinners--vaccinate and you remove consequences of sin.

I think these arguments fail for several reasons. First, humans are not the only ones afflicted with STDs--animals are too. I don't know how prevalent in the animal kingdom they are (maybe a vet can comment) but I know that some livestock have them. This puts STDs in a context of microbes filling a niche and exploiting a certain method of transmission, which weakens an argument of God's intent.

As mentioned above, STDs can have long-term health consequences including cancer, AIDS, and death. We understand that God regulates sexual behavior in order to maintain and strengthen the family. Inappropriate sexual behavior is damaging to ourselves and families in and of itself. Can we defend further consequences such as sterility, illness, and death--all of which damage families further? Some STDs can be effectively treated or cured. Would we deny treatment to somebody suffering from one of these diseases on the basis that they need to suffer for their wrongdoing? If not, then why not prevent it in the first place? To me, contrary attitudes seem lacking in charity and forgiveness.

We should also keep the innocent in mind--those who are infected by rape, a cheating spouse, blood transfusion, or other means beyond their control. Such circumstances could happen to anyone. Is the "punishment" of sinners (what about repentant sinners?) worth the suffering of the innocent? I don't think so.

A final couple of questions that I don't have authoritative answers for: To what degree do STDs actually represent a significant factor in people's sexual decisions? Would sexual activity increase significantly in the absence of STDs? My guess is that they play a supporting role, but not as much as we might think.

I admit that I don't have teenagers yet, so perhaps there are aspects to this that I am missing. I'm interested in other people's thoughts.

(Side note: I may pick this up for a post of its own, but I found this article, which is closely related to the topic at hand. Is it enough to feel principled about our approach, or should there be a practical benefit?)

Continue reading...

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP