John Welch on Science and Religion
A little over a week ago, John W. Welch gave a talk at BYU titled, "Forging a Friendly Alliance between Mormonism and Science." Welch is arguably the most influential LDS scholar (for lack of a better term) around. His résumé includes discovering chiasmus in the Book of Mormon, founding FARMS, editing BYU Studies, and sitting on the editorial board of the Encyclopedia of Mormonism. Summaries of his talk are available here and here, with the first link also containing a short audio interview. My favorite quote from the Daily Universe article is the following:
“Our ongoing task is to be building bridges,” he said, “even if it means laying ourselves down as a bridge over troubled waters, taking fire from both sides.”I like to think that I've been a board in that bridge.
To do so, Welch said Mormons must stop “shooting [them]selves in the foot with bad arguments,” and read current publications on the connection between LDS beliefs and modern science.
The article goes on to say that Welch gave out a reading list that he compiled, but I can't find any details. Does anybody know what was on the list?
In related news, one of the stories highlighted on the main webpage of the Deseret News today (earlier, it was one of the rotating stories) is "Science and faith discussion evolving to a place of harmony." There are a couple of quotes from Welch in there as well.


16 comments:
Building a bridge between science and Mormonism will be a long and difficult task. There are so many LDS who have been raised with a negative view of evolution. There are many other LDS who believe God performs miracles outside of natural law.
There are quite a few Mormon blogs that give a positive view of Science and Mormonism, but those blogs aren't read by most LDS. Our General Authorities don't want to do anything to encourage positive attitudes toward science, and many, if not most, LDS don't listen to people who aren't GA.
So, we do what we can, but I don't expect the bridge to be built for decades and maybe not until the Millennium.
Wow, interesting talk. Thank you for pointing this out. I am sure you are a fine board on the "bridge".
Thanks for making me aware of this.
I find it surprising that lawyers are been jumping into the science and religion debate (Philip Johnson and now John Welch). Anyway, as someone who does science, has written a book on science and the LDS faith, and has ready several books on this topic, I don't get the sense that the LDS faith is 'at war' with science. On the contrary, I think mormons have been huge advocates of science.
Now there are several LDS scholars who would probably say that any dissention from macroevolution within our ranks, including dissention from dead and living modern-day prophets and apostles, amounts to warfare against science. I think that they are mistaken.
I am with the prophets and apostles on the matter of macroevolution, but like so many of the general authorities, I don’t impugn latter-day saints who accept macroevolution. It is a legitimate science and they have a right to accept the theory as the way God made life.
"Our General Authorities don't want to do anything to encourage positive attitudes toward science...."
This is the most bizarre and baseless claim I've heard today.
My own view, perhaps biased by living near BYU for 20 years, is that while many Mormons have a negative view of evolution when you start talking details rather than soundbites most of them are actually pretty open to it. There are far fewer "no death before the fall" types than you might imagine. The basic issue is that most Mormons want to say Adam was special but aren't aware of the different theories to deal with that. Explain some of the many options and suddenly that problem (wrapped up unfortunately in the guise of the word evolution) goes away.
I have a copy of the handout that he gave out. It is list of further reading about science and religion. It has sections titled "Works on Science and Mormonism", "Selected Physical Science and Mathematical Articles in BYU Studies", and "Recent Works on Science and Theology, Including Many from Open Theologians".
mapman,
I would love a copy of that. Would you please scan it or take a picture of it or something, and email it to the address on the left sidebar?
I bet you'd like an autographed copy of a book by "the most influential LDS scholar around"... Wait! You do!
I can’t find my position represented in any of this discussion. I don’t doubt that the organisms we find on the earth today are related to organisms that existed on the earth previously. I’m just not convinced that Darwinian Evolution is the explanation. It seems to me that relationship could just as easily imply a common designer.
As I commented on another issue, I’ve done a little (very little) computer programming. When I would get a new programming assignment, and I needed to accomplish specific tasks I had figured out in previous programs, I would copy a section of code from the prior program and insert it into the new program. If someone were to reverse engineer my new program, they would find several subroutines from my prior programs. Does that prove the previous programs evolved into the new program, or does it prove the old and new programs have the same designer, who was simply using what had worked before?
It seems to me that answer must be found in DNA. DNA is a computer code which contains the information needed to produce the organism. DNA is encoded with organic molecules, but those molecules are not information. They are used to encode information, just like the letters I am using to write this post. Information, as far as I can tell, had to come from outside the code.
So, could information have come from Darwinian Evolution, i.e. random mutation and natural selection? As far as I can tell, information always comes from an intelligent being. I have seen no examples of natural forces encoding information. As far as I can tell, random mutation always reduces information, never creates it. In fact, DNA is encoded with error correcting information. Most advanced computer programs do error correcting as well. Otherwise, over time, random mutation would destroy all information contained in the code.
I tire of scientists rejecting Intelligent Design as “non-scientific”. I have an arrowhead I found years ago. Every time I show it to someone and ask them what it is, they always correctly identify it as an arrowhead. I ask them if the rock could have occurred naturally. They always admit that is possible, but they wouldn’t bet on it. I ask them why, and they point out all the evidences of design they see in the rock. How can this be non-scientific? We instinctively identify things as natural or designed. How is that not science?
The fact that Intelligent Design cannot get its results published in scientific journals proves nothing to me. We have debated elsewhere how the peer review process has been completely corrupted in climate science. I have no doubt similar forces are at work against Intelligent Design. And, could somebody please explain to me how “God in the gaps” is relevant to this conversation. Just because we can’t say who produced my arrowhead doesn’t negate our ability to identify design.
Matt,
If you were writing a new program, would you also include sub-routines that you didn't need, and more or less randomly delete or change parts of them so they didn't work?
Your argument subtly begs the question. The reason we know an arrowhead when we see one is because of our background knowledge about the use of arrowheads and what kinds of rocks are found in nature. A three-year-old might not so readily distinguish natural and artificial. What background knowledge allows one to say that the information found in nature (i.e. genomes) cannot have been produced by nature? Are the chemical possibilities understood to the point that natural processes can be ruled out? Without that knowledge, or corroborating positive evidence for design, one can only conclude that nature cannot create information by assuming that it can't in the first place.
The fact of the matter is that mutation, combined with selection, does create information. We know of several ways it can occur, and your body does it every day by randomly rearranging and mutating genes in order to make antibodies that specifically bind proteins on pathogens. There's no theoretical reason why the genome of a dog-like animal can't gradually change to become the genome of a modern whale, any more than the genome of a wolf can't gradually become that of a beagle.
You might say, at least with respect to the origin of life, that evolutionists also beg the question by assuming that nature could produce life. However, although how life originated is still unknown, there are interesting theoretical and experimental leads. Of course, it's impossible to prove ID has never happened in the long history of the earth, and here we come to part of the reason that many do not consider ID to be science.
Whether ID claims can be considered scientific depends on how they are formulated. Mostly they have been advanced in a way that resists hypothesis testing, and those that have been testable have been largely rejected. This is probably because, for the Discovery Institute, the largest pusher of ID, it was never about science in the first place.
So, did God design any of the organisms (or components of organisms) found on Earth? I don't know. As a matter of personal opinion I haven't ruled it out, and some days I'm sympathetic to it, but I don't see it as an absolute necessity, and the whole idea has a ways to go before I can respect it as science.
Jared,
No, I would not include sub-routines I did not need. If that is in fact what we find in nature, I have no explanation for it. Add it to the growing list of things I cannot explain.
I completely agree that a three year old would not be as good at recognizing design as an adult. It is something we learn to do with experience. So it only seems logical that we (collectively) should be able to improve our ability the recognize design in nature as we get more experience and more information.
I obviously cannot rule out the possibility that information we find in nature was produced randomly, just as you cannot rule out the possibility that it was produced by an intelligent agent. I honestly suspect the truth will be found to lie somewhere between the two.
“The fact of the matter is that mutation, combined with selection, does create information.” Of course it does! I’ve done enough selective breeding and artificial insemination with cattle to know that for a fact. But you left out an important word, RANDOM. In order for Darwinian Evolution to be true you need evidence that random mutation produces information. I understand that given an infinite number of repetitions it may be theoretically possible, but I challenge you to come up with a real world example. I remember reading about an experiment where fruit flies were irradiated for many years to increase the number of random mutations in their DNA. After thousands of generations, the best they ever got were sick and deformed fruit flies. Most mutations proved fatal, but the ones that didn’t never produced a better fruit fly. That doesn’t prove that they never will, it was just an illustration that they did not, within the time allotted.
Wolf to beagle? I can conceive of that. Selective breeding is very powerful. Wolf to whale? Now that would be one heck of a selective breeding program, but I will concede that it may be theoretically possible with selective breeding, and enough time. What I am looking for is evidence that non selective breeding, i.e. truly random mutation, could produce all the different life we find today, within the time frame of this earth. I’m willing to concede that it may be theoretically possible, I’m just looking for evidence.
I obviously know who the Discovery Institute is, but I am not a “plant”. I have no association or interest in them other than to read some of their stuff. I understand “many” do not consider ID science, but there are eminently qualified scientists who do. There are also a relatively few eminently qualified scientists who do not support anthropogenic global warming, while most do. I tire of name calling and argument from authority. Just stick with what you can prove, have the humility to admit what you can’t prove, and deal with ideas reasonably and respectfully.
By the way, my faith in God is independent of Darwinian Evolution or ID. I am convinced that God physically exists in time and space (although his experience of time and space may be much different from ours), that he is obedient to all law which allowed him to create the universe, and that we are the same species as God, which means that we have the potential to eventually know what he knows and do what he does. I believe that truth is truth, regardless of the source by which it is obtained. I aspire to live obedient to the truth I have received, and continue to obtain more truth.
Matt,
You should check out my (unfinished) series, What Separates Humans from the Animals?
You can read about how new genes form here and here. Also check out Richard Lenski's long-term E. coli experiment here. There's a lot more out there to read, if you're so inclined.
When it comes to religion and science, I just do not worry. I don't know enough about physics or biology to make an informed conclusion as to the origins of the universe, the beginning of life, or evolution.
I do have spiritual experiences over a lifetime that have convinced me that there is a god, that there is a Jesus, and that the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints is just what its name implies.
As a world, we are less than infants in out knowledge and understanding. We have a paradigm about the sped of light and that paradigm has clouded the view of scientists for decades. yet, when I read of angels visiting earth from heaven, wherever that is, I think that there must be laws that we have yet to discover and understand.
I think that all laws regarding this universe and god himself, will eventually be found to be natural laws and we will have to learn and understand those laws as part of out progression. Laws which we probably are not capable of in our mortal state.
Glenn
Jared,
Thanks for the links. I did click on each one and at least try to follow it and I have a few comments.
First, you will forever know more on this subject than I can ever know. That is your job. As a result, you will always be able to overpower me with citations. But truth is not established by a consensus of scientists, or religionists for that matter. There are too many examples of the consensus being wrong.
The article about the bacterium evolving a new characteristic while scientists were watching is interesting, but I don’t find it that dramatic. It was still E coli but with the ability to make use of a nutrient in its environment that it didn’t have before. It reminds me of the Galapagos Finch that evolved larger (or smaller) beaks in response to changes in their environment. Evidence of micro evolution to be sure, but nowhere near evidence for macro evolution.
New Scientist had a section on myths and misconceptions of evolution. One of the myths is that “mutations can only destroy information.” That is my position, so I was particularly interested in it. I found the rebuttal kind of weak. It cited several examples of organisms exhibiting micro evolution in response to changes in their environment. At the end it talked about reverse mutation or “reversion”. It said;
“For any mutation that results in a loss of information, logically, the reverse mutation must result in its gain. So the claim that mutations destroy information but cannot create it not only defies the evidence, it also defies logic.”
If truly random mutation causes the loss of a piece of information necessary for the survival of an organism, what are the probabilities of another truly random mutation reversing that loss before the organism dies out? It may be theoretically possible given an infinite number of permutations but I question the probability within the age of the earth.
Your series on what makes humans different was very interesting, but I think what really makes humans different is spirit. I am willing to concede that the biology of modern humans is essentially no different from that of pre Adamic humans. And I have no doubt that pre Adamic humans had spirit, but it is clear that something about humans changed approximately 6,000 years ago. All of a sudden (relatively speaking) humans developed language and civilization. When Genesis says that God breathed his spirit into Man and he became a Son of God, that is what I think differentiates Man from pre Adamic humans. And we are told that one of the things God gave Adam was language. I realize that other species communicate with each other, but no other species has developed anything close the human language.
Matt,
Thanks for taking time to read the links.
Dividing changes into micro and macro is irrelevant to the question of whether mutations can add information. Either they can or they can't. They can. If they couldn't there would be no such thing as drug resistant bacteria or viruses, and your antibodies would be worthless.
Because of the timescales involved, we cannot observe large changes in real-time. We can look backwards through comparative analysis and in some cases piece together a mutation-by-mutation account how a particular gene changed. However, ID/creationists can then say, "Well, you're assuming that those mutations happened naturally." However, most ID/creationists are circumspect enough not to question whether mutations observed in the laboratory are natural or not. Further, large changes rarely happen all at once. They come from accumulation of small changes over time. So small changes are relevant.
It seems like you are operating with some background misconceptions. For example:
"If truly random mutation causes the loss of a piece of information necessary for the survival of an organism, what are the probabilities of another truly random mutation reversing that loss before the organism dies out?"
Of course lethal mutations are unlikely to be reversed--because the organism is dead. But that's a narrow slice of the possibilities. Very many mutations are not lethal, so they are added to the gene pool.
Anyway, this is a difficult topic to hash out in the comments section of a blog. If you are that interested in it, you ought to pick up some books (like these) or spend some time at TalkOrigins (especially the Index to Creationist Claims). I applaud your critical thinking, but you need more information as a substrate for it if you are going to hold firm opinions.
Post a Comment