Vitamins Are Only Useful in their Sphere of Physiology
I don't know exactly why vitamins have such a hold on people's imagination as the key to good health [1], but they are really overrated when it comes to infectious diseases. They are kind of like motor oil--needed for engine function, but otherwise pretty useless when a car is stuck in the mud or snow. If your engine seizes up while trying to escape, sure, that's a problem. But pouring more and more oil into the engine just isn't going to address the fundamental problem.
So embracing vitamin A (or any vitamin) as the answer to measles (or any infectious disease) is health malpractice, pure and simple.
But this reminds me of a story: Early in my career a lady who worked in the same lab as me said that before traveling she had taken a popular vitamin supplement that claimed to protect from colds, but that it didn't work and she got sick anyway. I was appalled. Not because she took a bogus disease preventative, but because she concluded it didn't work. Not that I thought it would, because of course it wouldn't. But her conclusion was not scientific in the least. She had no idea when she got infected vs when she started taking the supplement, what she got infected with, or any sense for how long and at what dose she would need to take it to supposedly be protected. So how could she draw any conclusions about its efficacy? (Again, not that I thought for a second it would actually prevent sickness.) The point is that these kinds of loosey-goosey anectdotes drive most people's decision making...even people who ought to know better.
Notes:
1. Well, maybe I do: marketing
Continue reading...




