Saturday, May 10, 2025

The Church Accepts an Old Earth and is Neutral on Evolution

The Church recently added a new entry to its Topics and Questions section of the Gospel Library titled, Religion and Science. It is significant in that it is the most positive collection of statements for general membership about science that I have seen in a long time. Mostly, it just tries to keep the peace by remaining neutral and giving people room to sort through scientific and religious truths on their own. This paragraph is typical of the tone and content:

The Church does not take a position on most scientific matters. Instead, the Church focuses on teaching revealed, spiritual truths and helping God’s children live by those truths. At the same time, many Latter-day Saints seek to understand and contribute to scientific knowledge, following the Lord’s invitation to Joseph Smith to “seek learning, even by study and also by faith.”
However, the following statement caught my eye. Not so much because of its implicit acceptance of an old earth (which has generally not been a major sticking point for Church members), but because of what it says about how we know the earth is old.
Using reliable methods of measurement, such as radiometric dating, scientists currently estimate the age of the earth to be approximately 4.5 billion years.
To understand the significance of this, you need to know that rejection of scientific chronology is a cornerstone of fundamentalist young-earth creationism and they have invented a number of excuses for disbelieving radiometric dating. To the extent that Church members align with creationism, they import (sometimes without knowing) the arguments of fundamentalist creationism into their own thinking. Moreover, an LDS twist on this comes in the form of the so-called "Heartland Model" of Book of Mormon geography, which relies on a young-earth creationist paradigm. Although Book of Mormon geography would seem to have nothing to do with the age of the earth, the connection comes from trying to torture DNA data into showing that Native Americans are decendants of ancient Israel. The problem is that the particular DNA marker in question was present in native populations thousands of years before the Book of Mormon events took place. Thus, the need to deny scientific chronology.

For the Church to call radiometric dating a "reliable method of measurement" breaks a lot of brackets, so to speak [1].

Then there is the section on evolution: "Over the years, Church leaders have expressed differing views about evolution. However, the Church takes no position on the topic."

This also breaks brackets. I can't remember the number of online arguments I have seen (or occassionally participated in) where LDS critics of evolution would insist that the Church DID in fact have a position on evolution. They would lay out a variety of Church teachings about the Fall and so forth, including the 1909 First Presidency statement, "The Origin of Man", and then conclude that whether or not the Church said so explicitly, its teachings clearly excluded evolution. If you pointed to the First Presidency's instructions to General Authorities in 1931 that struck a neutral balance, they would counter that the statement had never been published to the general Church membership. Well, now it has been (in at least three separate places within the Gosepl Library), and the Church here explicitly says that it takes no position on evolution.

Perhaps the best thing about this new topical entry is that it can be used to defuse attacks based on General Authority quotes. As I previously wrote,
Although pronouncements by authorities do not determine the truth or falsity of a proposition (hence the logical fallacy), we look to the prophets and apostles as a source of truth, and their thoughts deserve consideration. This style of argumentation, where one is made to feel like s/he is rejecting the prophets, can therefore be quite difficult and frustrating to grapple with because, in its strongest form, there can be no counter-argument. Attempting to do so only validates the perception that you reject the prophets. And yet, we who defend science cannot remain silent or else the authoritarian bullies will be the only ones heard. So what can we do when confronted with such material?
Well, now you can just point to this entry in the Gospel Library.

Notes:
1. I'm using predicted March Madness college basketball tournament brackets as a metaphor.


Continue reading...

Saturday, April 19, 2025

Trump is Raking it in. Congratulations to All Who Fell for the Hunter Biden Misdirection

Last month Forbes did their best to figure out Donald Trump's various sources of income and summarized it in the graphic below. A large chunk of his wealth is now in the form of cryptocurrency-associated activities. $Trump of course is the meme coin he launched days before his inaugruation and that he has occasionally plugged via social media. Market caps of meme coins are not necessarily what they seem, but what is more certain is that Trump has made $350 million just from the trading fees alone. Beyond that, he has a cryptocurrency company, World Liberty Financial, that was established last year just two months before the election while the crypto industry was making big donations to his campaign. He is thereby positioned to directly benefit from his own administration's decisions around crypto, not to mention creating a portal for global forces to funnel money to him. (Independent journalist Molly White tracks the crime and corruption in the crypto industry. See her latest rundown on Trump's crypto profiteering here.)

Remember, Republicans in the House wanted to impeach Joe Biden because his son had previously brought in $20 million by allegedly trading on his family name, with the innuendo that Joe Biden had also profited. The whole theory was dodgy as noted by multiple fact-checking organizations (here and here), but it was all Fox News could talk about. It was pretty obvious at the time, and is even more so in retrospect, that the whole Hunter Biden obsession of Republicans was just a cynical ploy to damage Joe Biden's re-election and to direct the public's attention away from the sins of Donald Trump and minimize them by making Joe Biden look just as bad.

Donald Trump trades on his own name right out in the open while holding presidential office for vastly greater amounts of money while controlling policy making and law enforcement. Too bad Hunter Biden wasn't a "businessman". Because if you're a "buisinessman", they let you do it.



Continue reading...

Saturday, April 12, 2025

Everything Good Flows from Truth

Oh say, what is truth? ’Tis the fairest gem
That the riches of worlds can produce,

Unless it conflicts with political views.
Then disparage it, deny it, and call it fake news,
And count it but dross and refuse.


The New Testament book of James asks,

Doth a fountain send forth at the same place sweet water and bitter? Can the fig tree, my brethren, bear olive berries? either a vine, figs? (James 3:11–12)
This is echoed by Mormon, who said,
For behold, a bitter fountain cannot bring forth good water; neither can a good fountain bring forth bitter water (Moroni 7:11)

Elder Richard G. Scott once said, "[T]ruth is the only meaningful foundation upon which we can make wise decisions." Some people don't know what is true because they are "blinded by the subtle craftiness of men." Others, however, know what is true but choose not to honor it because they believe that they will receive some favored outcome or because embracing the truth is harmful to their self-conception. But the fact of the matter is that you cannot get good medicine, a good economy, or good public policy if you do not value what is true. A random process may indeed yield rewards from time to time. It's why people go to casinos, after all. But over the longer term, as the consequences of decision after decision build, you are ultimately left with bitter water.

America decided to give the most powerful position in the world to a man who not only does not value the truth, but is himself a continual source and enforcer of untruth. A man whose guiding ethic is, "It doesn’t matter what you say...say it enough and people will believe you." Somehow people thought that this would bring forth sweet water. Moreover, this time around he made sure to put sycophants in the most powerful positions of government, and now we watch one continual parade of toadying, deflecting, and gaslighting. How can we expect anything other than bitter water [1]?

Inasmuch as this is ostensibly a science blog, you may wonder why I am harping on politics. The reason is that science is downstream of valuing truth, as it is the primary method for discovering truth in this world. A nation that doesn't care about truth has little need for science, and therefore we shouldn't be surprised to see science under attack by the current administration as it cuts grants, destroys its science-based agencies, and replaces competent professionals with cranks and "influencers". When you don't care about the truth, science isn't just irrelevant. It gets in the way because it insists on distinguishing truth from falsehood.

Value truth and you can have good water. Ignore or deny truth and you join those who, as the prophet Isaiah put it, eat their own dung and drink their own piss.

Notes:
1. You would think that voters who lived through the Iraq War under George W. Bush would intuitively understand this, but evidently not!


Continue reading...

Friday, March 28, 2025

We Can Do All Things Through Christ

This is just a reminder that anything done in the name of Christ is OK. Nobody has ever done anything unethical, dishonest, unwise, wicked, or fraudulent under his name, nor have they ever flaunted their Christianity as a cover for bad behavior [1]. Jesus would never allow his name to be misused [2]. So if someone claims to be a Christian, then their public or political words and actions should not be criticized. To do so is to criticize Jesus [3].

The Bible says so (Philippians 4:13). I don't make the rules.

Notes:
1. I didn't include "illegal" because laws are made by men and often used to oppress true Christians. Therefore, breaking the law in the name of Jesus is OK.
2. Since Jesus knows the end from the beginning, anything a Christian does is according to his plan.
3. What if some Christians don't like what other Christians are doing in the name of Jesus? That's not a question a true Christian would ask.


Continue reading...

Tuesday, March 18, 2025

Time to Get Your Year Supply of Excuses Ready

Now that Trump is regularly making menacing statements about annexing Canada and Greenland, it's time to make sure you are stocked up on excuses for supporting him. If you've made it through the lies about the 2020 election, January 6, his court convictions, pardoning J6 insurrectionists, turning the management of the executive branch over to Elon Musk, purging the Department of Justice and the Department of Defense of anyone who might stand between him and illegal or unconstitutional orders, halting humanitarian aid, deciding that he can deport virtually anyone if he wants to, working to nulify the 14th amendment, turning against European allies and increasingly aligning with Russia, threatening the press, universities, and companies that don't align themselves to his will, his on-again-off-again tariffs, and so on, and so on...

...if you've made it through all of that, you may find your short-term supplies of excuses dwindling. And if you think you aren't going to need more, you are kidding yourself. You definitely need to stock up a least a year supply, if not more. You can start small and just regularly add to your supply. Perhaps you think you can just get by with, "I never thought that would happen". A little bit is certainly helpful, but you really are going to need something more substantial.

Probably the most cost-effective way to stock up on excuses is to go to the storehouse of Fox News. They regularly feature excuses that, although not of high quality, will sustain you in a pinch. For example, just recently they had a guest on claiming that Canada has been taken over by Mexican drug cartels. Sure it's stupid, but down the road when the U.S. is taking military action against Canada you are going to need something to justify your support. Other excuse suppliers that you find on social media or in podcasts can also be helpful, but I would recommend comparison shopping by cross-checking with Fox News to make sure that your excuses are of the best MAGA quality.

While you are building your supply of excuses to make it through the short-to-medium term, you also need to start working on your long-term excuses. Generations after you are going to ask, "Why on earth would you do that?" Providing excuses to them is beyond the scope of this post, but I recommend that you start building a story about how it's what God wanted. Few excuses are as durable.


Continue reading...

Tuesday, March 04, 2025

America Needs A Crypto Strategic Reserve So That...

America Needs A Crypto Strategic Reserve...

In light of Trump's announcement last Sunday that a cryto strategic reserve would be forthcoming, can anyone complete the above sentence without using some combination of the following:

...so that Donald Trump can use taxpayer money to prop up assets with no underlying value as a gift to the crypto industry, which spent so much to help get him elected.

...so that Donald Trump can enrich himself and his friends by insider trading and pump-and-dump schemes [1].

...to ensure that countries like North Korea are able to continue to fund their hostile activities.

...so that gullible people hoping to get ahead willingly throw their money away to unknowingly support one of the above.

...in case the United States runs out of dollars [2].

Notes:
1. Somebody made a killing off of Trump's announcement last Sunday. According to Forbes:

Mere hours before Trump made the announcement, an anonymous trader opened a 50x leveraged long position on BTC and ETH with $4 million on margin. As crypto prices surged on Trump’s news, the trader closed the position, netting over $6.8 million in profit. The timing was fortunate, and the bet was structured with little downside protection, making some wonder if it may not have been fortuitous and if the trader had advanced knowledge of Trump’s announcement....To reiterate and put the risk in perspective, the long positions were so highly leveraged that a price dip of merely ~2 percent in BTC or ETH would have liquidated the trader’s entire $4M stake​. Yet, instead of faltering, prices rose precisely when needed.
I'm sure the Trump-loyal SEC and DOJ will get right on that.

2. The United States is the source of dollars. It cannot run out.


Continue reading...

Sunday, February 23, 2025

We Are Trading Dollars for Pennies

When I was in grade school I learned of a cruel trick that you could play on younger kids of about 5-6 years old. (I'm happy to report that I never tried to do this.) The trick was simply this: offer to trade them a few pennies for a dollar, with the explanation that the pennies are (numerically) more than a dollar. To a young mind that understands numeric values but doesn't yet comprehend the relative worth of units of money, this seems like a good deal. It is, of course, a dishonest and cruel exploitation of their naivety.

I keep thinking about this trick as a metaphor for this political moment. Voters have been bombarded for decades with messaging that tells them that their taxes are being wasted and that our country can't afford it's current services and the debt that it has accumulated. The solution Republican politicians have proposed has been to trade government spending for tax cuts [1].

The cruelty of this trick, as more people are beginning to realize, is that government spending is mostly "wasted" on...we the people. One way to see this is to look at how much states pay into the federal system vs how much they receive in benefits. It quickly becomes obvious that states like Washington, New Jersey, Massachusetts, and especially California are helping to fund everyone else, while virtually the whole southern United States receives more than it contributes.

Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid are the largest and most direct examples of how federal spending benefits citizens, but federal spending extends deeply into the national economy in less obvious ways and helps create demand for entire industries. Again, some of this is direct, but some of it is indirect and easily overlooked until it is gone. For example, Alabama is realizing that cuts to scientific funding could greatly damage one of the largest employers of the state (University of Alabama at Birmingham), the effects of which will ripple further into the Alabama economy. And all of this doesn't even consider the intangible benefits we all receive from federal spending--things that make our lives better without us knowing, or the fact that many government workers are actually underpaid relative to the services they provide. There is a real sense in which federal spending is like fertilizer to the soil of our economy.

The benefit we are to receive for trading these things away is lower taxes. This is a great deal for people like Elon Musk because they have very high income and therefore stand to save a lot in taxes [2]. But they can buy virtually anything they want anyway (including politicians). If you have the median household income, on the other hand, your benefit is a relative pitance. And even then you will likely end up spending it (and even more) on things like more expensive household appliances and cars due to the Trump tariffs, or more expensive tuition because universities have to make up for loss of federal funds, or specialized therapy for your disabled child because public schools have lost funding for those services. And if Social Security, Medcaid, or Medicare get cut, there's no making up for what you lose.

Moneyed interests and politicians are taking advantage of our naivety, having stirred us up to anger against a system upon which we all depend. As a result, the average person is trading dollars for pennies.

Notes:
1. Talking about the federal debt is complicated by the fact that there's not a known threshold above which it becomes a big problem. Even at current levels it doesn't seem to be causing much harm to our country, but that's not to say that it should be allowed to grow without restraint. Republicans have railed against federal debt for as long as I can remember (usually only when Democrats are in power), as if it violates some law of nature or offends God. However, cutting taxes gives away the game. If you truly care about the debt then it makes no sense to cut taxes. If anything, in times of prosperity taxes should be raised a little. And here again, most of that federal debt is owed to...we the people.
2. Financial commentator Ben Carlson once quipped that rich people hate paying taxes more than they like making money.


Continue reading...

Wednesday, February 19, 2025

Am I Allowed to Refer to Trump Supporters as King-men Now?

Now that Donald Trump is referring to himself as a king, and the White House X [Twitter] account is providing the imagery, am I allowed to refer to Trump supporters as king-men, or is that in bad taste (even though he is working to eliminate any checks or accountability on his power) [1,2,3]?


Notes:
1. For example, firing of Inspectors General, turning the Department of Justice into his personal protection/enforcement racket, firing prosecutors who worked on J6 cases, pardoning criminals (including but not limited to J6) for personal political advantage, indescriminate firing of federal employees in violation of law, blocking funding appropriated by Congress, getting the Supreme Court to rule that he can't be prosecuted for any "official actions", his Vice-President floating the idea of ignoring the courts, and more.
2. I'm not an expert, but I seem to remember the Book of Mormon taking a dim view on kings...hence the term king-men. Also I'm not a historian, but I remember that even in the pre-woke days America rejected the idea of kings and crafted the Constitution accordingly.
3. This is all just braggadocio you say? I would be more inclined to dismiss it as such if not for #1 above.


Continue reading...

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP